Common-Law Wife: What Are Her Entitlements?

In the US, common-law marriage, also known as marriage without formalities or informal marriage, is a valid and legal way for a couple to marry in some states. These include Texas, Utah, Alabama, Georgia, Idaho, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. While the requirements vary by state, common-law marriage generally involves both parties consenting to be married, living together, and presenting themselves to the community as a married couple. However, it is important to note that not all states recognize common-law marriage, and the laws can change over time. For example, South Carolina abolished common-law marriage in 2019.

In the context of a common-law marriage, the rights of a common-law wife to claim anything depend on the specific state laws and the legal recognition of the marriage. While common-law spouses may have some rights, such as inheritance and medical decision-making, they are generally not entitled to the same legal protections as a married couple in a divorce. For example, there is typically no right to claim maintenance or financial support from the ex-partner after the relationship ends.

To summarize, the ability of a common-law wife to claim anything varies depending on the state and the specific circumstances of the relationship. It is always advisable to seek legal advice for a comprehensive understanding of one's rights and options.

Characteristics of a common-law wife

Common law marriage recognition

In general, a "common-law spouse" or "common-law partner" is a term used for couples who live together but are unmarried, akin to a husband and wife, and may or may not have children. The term is widely used and understood, but legally, there is no recognition for a "common-law partner/spouse".

However, common-law marriages are legally recognised in some places, such as Texas, where it is known as a "marriage without formalities" or "informal marriage". In Texas, there is no requirement for a couple to be together for a specific period of time before they can declare themselves to be in a common-law marriage. As long as both parties agree to the three elements listed in Section 2.401, they meet the requirements of a common-law marriage. Couples can register their common-law marriage by filing a declaration with the county clerk. If no declaration was filed, and there is a dispute as to whether a common-law marriage existed, it may be necessary to go to court in order to prove the marriage.

In Australia, the term "common-law marriage" is not used, but the equivalent term is a "de facto relationship", which is recognised in the Family Law Act (Commonwealth), applicable in states that have referred their jurisdiction on de facto couples to the Commonwealth's jurisdiction.

In the US, all jurisdictions recognise common-law marriages that were validly contracted in the originating jurisdiction, although the US Constitution's requirements for interstate marriage recognition have not been fully articulated by the Supreme Court. Some states provide for the registration of an informal or common-law marriage based on the declaration of each of the spouses on a state-issued form. Due to their colonial past, the islands of the English-speaking Caribbean have statutes concerning common-law marriage similar to those in England.

In terms of the rights of common-law partners, in some places, they are treated the same as married couples when assessed for entitlement to welfare benefits, Working Tax Credit or Child Tax Credit. If they are claiming means-tested benefits, they will usually be expected to claim as a couple, and the income, savings and financial needs of both partners are taken into account. Common-law partners may also be eligible for various federal government spousal benefits. In terms of tax returns, common-law couples cannot file joint tax returns with the IRS if they live in a state where common-law marriage is not recognised.

In terms of property ownership, if the house is in one partner's name only, the other partner does not have an automatic right to share in the property on separation. However, they might be able to prove that they have a beneficial interest if they can demonstrate that it was intended that they would both share the equity in the property, for example, by contributing to the deposit or mortgage.

If one partner dies without leaving a will, the surviving partner will not automatically inherit anything unless the couple owned property jointly. As an unmarried couple, it is necessary to make wills if you wish to ensure that the other partner inherits. If one partner dies without leaving enough in their will for the other to live on, the surviving partner may be able to go to court to claim from the estate.

If there are children in the relationship, and parents cannot reach an agreement, mediation can be attempted, and if that fails, there is the option to ask the court for assistance via Children Act Proceedings or attempt child arbitration. If one partner is the primary caregiver, the other partner would be expected to pay child maintenance and, in certain circumstances, the primary caregiver may also have the right to claim for the financial needs of a child, which can include periodical payments, a lump sum, settlement of property or a Mesher order.

Property rights

The rights of a common-law wife regarding property depend on several factors. Firstly, it is important to note that the term "common-law spouse" is not legally recognised in most places. Couples who live together without being married are typically considered "cohabitants" or "cohabitees" and do not have the same legal rights as a married couple.

However, in some states, common-law marriages are recognised, and property division upon separation is treated the same as it would be for a formally married couple. These states include Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin, which are community property states. In these states, all assets and debts acquired during the marriage are considered joint property and will be divided equally in the event of a divorce.

On the other hand, most other states follow the equitable distribution or common-law system, where assets accumulated during the marriage are divided fairly but not necessarily equally. In these states, property acquired by one member of a married couple typically belongs solely to that person unless it is put in both spouses' names.

If a common-law couple lives in a state that does not recognise common-law marriage, they generally do not have the same rights as a formally married couple during a separation. In these cases, if the house is in one partner's name only, the other partner does not automatically have a right to share in the property. However, they may be able to prove a beneficial interest in the property if they can demonstrate that it was intended for both partners to share the equity, such as by contributing to the deposit, mortgage, or renovations.

To avoid complications and ensure clarity regarding property rights, it is advisable for couples to have legal paperwork drawn up before or during cohabitation. This can outline the arrangements and protect any assets or possessions in the sole name of one partner that they do not intend to share with their partner.

Child maintenance

In the context of child maintenance, a common-law wife is typically considered a spouse or partner in a de facto or unmarried relationship. While the specific laws and procedures may vary by jurisdiction, here is an overview of child maintenance as it relates to common-law wives:

Parents have a legal responsibility to provide financially for their children, regardless of their marital status or living arrangements. This obligation extends to both biological and adoptive parents, and it continues even if the parents no longer live together. The extent of this obligation is generally based on the standard of living, income, and financial means of the obligated parent or parents. It is important to note that the obligation does not rest solely on one parent; both parents are expected to contribute according to their respective means.

Calculating Child Maintenance:

The calculation of child maintenance can vary depending on the jurisdiction. In some cases, there may be specific formulas or guidelines used to determine the amount. For example, in certain jurisdictions, the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) calculation is applied to incomes above a certain threshold, and a judge may order a payment above the calculated figure based on the circumstances. The court may consider factors such as the income of both parents, their ability to earn, their properties, and the child's expenses, including food, clothing, accommodation, medical care, and education.

Enforcement and International Agreements:

The enforcement of child maintenance orders can vary by country, but in general, there are mechanisms in place to ensure compliance. For example, in some jurisdictions, personal details of child maintenance defaulters may be shared with credit bureaus, making it difficult for them to obtain credit. Additionally, some countries have reciprocal agreements, such as the Reciprocal Enforcement of Maintenance Orders (REMO) in the UK, which facilitates the enforcement of maintenance orders across different jurisdictions.

Common-Law Wife's Rights:

In some jurisdictions, a common-law wife may have the right to claim maintenance for herself and her children. For example, in certain legal systems, women in live-in relationships can claim maintenance under specific sections of the law. This claim may be based on the principle of ensuring that women are not left vulnerable or destitute after separation or divorce. Additionally, in specific legal traditions, both spouses in a marriage are entitled to claim maintenance or alimony, regardless of their gender.

Application and Negotiation Process:

The process of applying for child maintenance can vary, but it typically involves submitting an application to the appropriate court or authority. In some cases, parents can negotiate child maintenance directly or through their legal representatives and record this in a private agreement. However, it is important to note that private agreements may not be legally enforceable, and seeking the assistance of the relevant maintenance service or court may be necessary to ensure compliance.

Tax benefits

In some countries and regions, common-law partners are recognised for tax purposes and can claim certain benefits.

Canada

In Canada, common-law couples are treated the same as married couples under the federal Income Tax Act. Common-law couples in Canada are not allowed to file joint returns; instead, they each file single returns and mark that they're in a partnership. When filing taxes, common-law partners can transfer some tax credits from their spouse's return to theirs and claim all or part of certain amounts that their spouse or common-law partner qualifies for. They can also split or share certain credits, such as medical expenses, to increase their refund. Additionally, they can split pension income with their partner to reduce their overall tax liability.

United States

In the United States, common-law marriage has been practised since the 1870s, but only a minority of states recognise it. In states that do recognise common-law marriages, couples must meet certain requirements, such as living together for a specified period, having the legal right to marry, and presenting themselves as a married couple to others. In these states, common-law partners can file taxes jointly and may be eligible for various tax benefits, such as combining medical expenses or charitable donations, and claiming family tax cuts.

It is important to note that the recognition of common-law marriages and the associated tax benefits can vary by state and may be subject to change. It is always a good idea to consult a professional for the most up-to-date and accurate information.

Inheritance

In the context of inheritance, common law refers to the legal definition of the term "spouse". In Canada, except for British Columbia, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and the Northwest Territories, a spouse is defined as someone you are married to. In these regions, a common-law partner has no inheritance rights if their partner passes away without a will. However, they can protect their legal claim to inheritance by being named as a beneficiary in their partner's will.

In the US, community property laws apply in Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin. In these states, any property acquired by either spouse during the marriage is jointly owned by the "marital community". Alaska, Kentucky, and Tennessee have also adopted elective community property systems, allowing spouses to sign an agreement creating community property or a community property trust.

In the UK, under English law, if a person dies without a valid will, their estate will be distributed according to intestacy rules, which do not provide for the survivor of a cohabiting couple. Therefore, it is important for cohabiting couples to create a will to ensure their partner can inherit their estate.

Frequently asked questions