Stark Law Violations: Hospitals And Their Ethical Boundaries

The Stark Law, enacted in 1992, is a federal statute that prohibits physicians from engaging in certain business and financial practices that may lead to fraud or abuse in healthcare services. The law is designed to protect patients from conflicts of interest and ensure that medical referrals are based on necessity rather than personal gain. Hospitals and healthcare providers must comply with the Stark Law to avoid severe penalties, including civil financial penalties and exclusion from federal healthcare programs. Violations can occur through various means, such as improper compensation arrangements, lease agreements, and false claims submissions. Understanding and adhering to the Stark Law is crucial for hospitals and medical professionals to provide ethical and transparent patient care.

Physician incentive plans

The Stark Law, or Stark Act, is a set of United States federal laws that prohibit physician self-referral. In other words, it prevents physicians from referring patients to receive designated health services (DHS) payable by Medicare or Medicaid from entities with which the physician or an immediate family member has a financial relationship. This includes ownership, investment interests, and compensation arrangements. The Stark Law was named for United States Congressman Pete Stark, who sponsored the initial bill.

The Stark Law is an important tool to prevent conflicts of interest and ensure that patients receive high-quality, comprehensive care without unnecessary or fraudulent testing, referrals, or medical services. It is crucial for physicians and healthcare practitioners to understand the complexities and nuances of these regulations to avoid legal consequences and provide the best possible care to their patients.

The Stark statute allows physician incentive plans as long as no compensation between an entity and a physician or physician group is exchanged that may directly or indirectly have the effect of reducing or limiting medically necessary services to enrollees. These physician incentive plan requirements are what prevent hospitals from trying to lower their expenses by paying physicians part of the money saved from DRG payments (gainsharing arrangements).

The Stark Law contains several exceptions, including physician services, in-office ancillary services, and bona fide employment relationships. It is important to note that the Stark Law only applies to physicians with specific definitions for MD, DO, DDS, DPM, Optometrist, and Chiropractor. Some of the key exceptions to the Stark Law include:

• Nonmonetary compensation
• Preventive services
• Fair market value
• Hospital incidental benefits
• Hospital compliance training
• Risk-sharing arrangements
• Lease arrangements
• Personal services arrangements

Lease arrangements

Hospitals can violate the Stark Law with lease arrangements if they are not consistent with the fair market value (FMV) and commercially reasonable. The Stark Law prohibits a physician from referring Medicare or Medicaid patients for designated health services (DHS) to an entity that the physician or their immediate family has a "financial relationship" with.

To avoid violating the Stark Law, lease arrangements must meet specific requirements. These include ensuring that the lease is set out in writing, signed by all parties, and specifies the premises covered by the lease. The space rented or leased should be reasonable and necessary for the legitimate business purposes of the lease and used exclusively by the lessee. The lease should also provide for a rental term of at least one year, and the rental charges should be set in advance, consistent with FMV, and not influenced by the volume or value of referrals or other business generated.

Additionally, the Anti-Kickback Statute, similar to the Stark Law, prohibits space leasing arrangements between health systems and referral sources unless the arrangement meets the space rental safe harbor. This means that remuneration, including cash, discounts off FMV, or investment opportunities, cannot be exchanged directly or indirectly for patient referrals or the purchase of an item or service covered by a federal healthcare program.

False claims

The False Claims Act (FCA) makes it illegal to knowingly present or make a false claim to the government. The FCA defines "knowing" as including not only actual knowledge but also instances in which the person acted in deliberate ignorance or reckless disregard of the truth or falsity of the information. Under the FCA, each instance of an item or service billed to Medicare or Medicaid counts as a claim, and fines can add up quickly.

The False Claims Act contains a whistleblower provision that allows a private individual to file a lawsuit on behalf of the United States and entitles that whistleblower to a percentage of any recoveries. Whistleblowers could be current or former business partners, hospital or office staff, patients, or competitors. In addition, employers can be held liable for retaliation under the False Claims Act if they take hostile action against an ex-employee who is now a whistleblower.

The Stark Law, or Physician Self-Referral Law, is a conflict-of-interest prevention statute that prohibits physicians from referring federal healthcare beneficiaries to providers with whom the physicians have a financial relationship. This includes both ownership interests in other entities and compensation agreements with other providers, as well as financial relationships involving a provider's immediate family members. The Stark Law is a strict liability statute, meaning that it applies regardless of whether the physician intended to refer a patient to a practice they own or have a financial relationship with.

Claims submitted under the Anti-Kickback Statute and the Stark Law violate the False Claims Act. AKS violations can give rise to FCA liability because claims tainted by AKS violations are deemed false for purposes of the FCA. Similarly, a claim that results from a kickback or is made in violation of the Stark Law may also render it false or fraudulent, creating liability under the FCA.

There have been several cases involving allegations of AKS and Stark Law violations. For example, in U.S. ex rel. Jennings v. Flower Mound Hospital Partners, LLC, it was alleged that a physician-owned hospital violated the AKS and the Stark Law when it purchased shares from older physician-owners and resold them to younger physicians based on their volume of referrals. The hospital agreed to pay $18.2 million to resolve the violations. In another case, Rialto Capital Management LLC and its former affiliate RL BB-IN KRE LLC agreed to pay $3.6 million to resolve allegations that they violated the Anti-Kickback Statute, the Stark Law, and the False Claims Act by engaging in illegal financial arrangements with two doctors who referred patients to their hospital.

Anti-kickback statute

The Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) is a federal criminal statute that prohibits the exchange or offer to exchange anything of value to induce or reward the referral of business reimbursable by federal healthcare programs. The AKS is one of the five most important federal fraud and abuse laws that apply to physicians, along with the Stark Law, which is also known as the Physician Self-Referral Law.

The AKS prohibits the knowing and willful payment of "remuneration" to induce or reward patient referrals or the generation of business involving any item or service payable by federal healthcare programs. Remuneration includes anything of value and can take many forms besides cash, such as free rent, expensive hotel stays and meals, and excessive compensation for medical directorships or consultancies. The statute covers both the payers and recipients of kickbacks. Each party's intent is a key element of their liability under the AKS.

The AKS applies to all sources of referrals, including patients. For example, it is generally required to collect copays from patients when the Medicare and Medicaid programs mandate them. Routinely waiving these copays could implicate the AKS, and advertising that you will forgive copayments is prohibited. However, it is permissible to waive a copayment if you determine that the patient cannot afford to pay or if your reasonable collection efforts fail. It is also legal to provide free or discounted services to uninsured individuals.

Violating the AKS can result in criminal penalties, civil fines, exclusion from federal healthcare programs, or loss of a medical license from the State medical board. The government does not need to prove patient harm or financial loss to establish a violation of the AKS. A physician can be found guilty of violating the AKS even if the service was rendered and was medically necessary.

Patient harm or financial loss

The Stark Law, or the Physician Self-Referral Law, is a set of United States federal laws that prohibit physician self-referral. In other words, it prevents physicians from referring patients to receive "designated health services" (DHS) payable by Medicare or Medicaid from entities with which the physician or an immediate family member has a financial relationship. This includes ownership, investment interests, and compensation arrangements. The law was named for United States Congressman Pete Stark, who sponsored the initial bill.

The Stark Law is a strict liability statute, which means proof of specific intent to violate the law is not required. The law prohibits the submission or causing the submission of claims in violation of the law's restrictions on referrals. Violations of the Stark Law can result in criminal penalties, civil fines, exclusion from federal healthcare programs, or loss of a medical license. The government does not need to prove patient harm or financial loss to the programs to show that a physician violated the Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS). A physician can be guilty of violating the AKS even if the physician actually rendered the service and the service was medically necessary.

The Stark Law is designed to prevent conflicts of interest in the healthcare industry, where physicians could benefit financially from their own referrals. It is an essential law that prevents fraudulent and unnecessary testing, referrals, and medical services. It also prevents physicians from seeking further personal financial or equity gains regarding patient care. The Department of Justice, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and the Department of Health and Human Services are responsible for enforcing the Stark Law.

To prevent Stark Law violations, Texas healthcare providers should implement a robust compliance program, including written policies and procedures, regular staff training, and the designation of a compliance officer. They should also regularly review financial arrangements to ensure all physician compensation and referral agreements are at fair market value and do not include referral incentives. Conducting internal audits of billing practices, referral patterns, and financial records can help identify potential red flags. Seeking legal counsel from experienced healthcare attorneys can also ensure compliance with the Stark Law and other relevant regulations.

Frequently asked questions