Ohio Law Firms: Referral Fees And Their Legality

In the United States, referral fees are commonplace in the legal industry. However, the rules surrounding them vary from state to state. In Ohio, referral fees are not prohibited, but they must comply with the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct. These rules include the requirement that the client is made aware of the referral fee agreement and does not object to it. The fee must also be reasonable and based on the services performed by each lawyer. This guide will explore the nuances of referral fees for law firms in Ohio and provide insight into how these fees operate in practice.

Referral fee agreements

Ohio's Rules of Professional Conduct outline the requirements for attorney referral fee agreements. Rule 1.5(e) governs the division of fees among lawyers and states that lawyers who are not in the same firm may divide fees only if certain conditions are met. These conditions include proportional division based on the services performed by each lawyer or joint responsibility for representation, written client consent, and disclosure of the fee division.

When establishing referral fee agreements, it is essential to put the agreement in writing and obtain the client's consent. The referring attorney should inform the client about the fee-sharing arrangement and ensure they do not object to it. This transparency helps maintain trust and ethical standards in the legal profession.

Additionally, referral fees should be reasonable and not excessive. The determination of reasonableness considers factors such as the time and labour involved, the complexity of the case, the skill required, and the customary fees charged for similar legal services in the locality.

It is worth noting that attorneys must perform some work to earn the referral fee. Simply referring a case without providing any additional services may not be sufficient to collect a fee in Ohio. Any fee-sharing agreement must also comply with ethical rules and relevant laws to be enforceable.

Compliance and ethics

Firstly, it is essential to understand the applicable rules and regulations, such as the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct, which include specific provisions for attorney referrals. Rule 1.5(e) of the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct governs the division of fees and sets out several requirements. These include proportionality, where the division of fees should be in proportion to the services performed by each lawyer, or joint responsibility, where each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation and agrees to be available for consultation with the client.

Additionally, written disclosure and client consent are crucial. Both the fee-sharing agreement and the identities of all lawyers involved must be disclosed to the client in writing, and the client must provide written consent. The total fee charged should also be reasonable and not excessive, considering factors such as the time and labour required, the novelty and difficulty of the case, and the skill needed to perform the legal service properly.

Another important aspect is that referral fee agreements should only be made with competent attorneys who are qualified to handle the referred matter. This ensures that the client's interests are protected and that the referral is made in good faith.

Furthermore, while attorneys can divide fees with suspended or disbarred attorneys, it is only permissible if the agreement was made while all attorneys were active and in good standing, and the division is based on work completed while the referring attorney was active.

In the context of personal injury litigation, it is essential to be cautious and ensure that the client is fully informed and advised of the referral fee agreement. This was highlighted in a case addressed by the Court of Appeals in 2019, where a fee dispute arose due to a lack of a written agreement and client acknowledgment.

Lastly, it is worth noting that referral fees must be disclosed to the client, as per Rule 4701-11-04(E) of the Ohio Administrative Code.

By adhering to these guidelines, law firms in Ohio can ensure they comply with ethical standards and maintain the integrity of the legal profession.

Written consent from clients

In Ohio, lawyers who are not in the same firm may divide fees only if the client has given written consent after full disclosure of the identity of each lawyer. The client must also be informed that the fees will be divided and that the division will be in proportion to the services performed by each lawyer. This is outlined in Rule 1.5(e) of the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct.

The written consent of the client is a crucial aspect of referral fee agreements. Without it, referral fees may be lost. In the case of Reeve v. Meleyco, the California Court of Appeal reversed a judgment in favor of an attorney seeking to enforce a referral fee agreement. The court concluded that the client's written acknowledgment did not constitute written consent to the agreement. This case highlights the importance of obtaining explicit written consent from the client, specifically for the referral fee agreement, in addition to any other written disclosures or acknowledgments.

To ensure compliance and reduce the risk of losing referral fees, law firms should implement rigorous client consent and notification procedures. This includes obtaining written consent from the client, providing full disclosure of the identities of all lawyers involved, and clearly stating the terms of the fee division. It is also important to note that the client has the right to retain the referral fee and have it remitted back to them if they wish.

In addition to obtaining written consent, law firms should also be mindful of other requirements and considerations. For example, referral fees should be limited to attorneys who are competent to handle the matter at hand, and the total fee should be reasonable and not excessive. Furthermore, it is worth noting that, in most states, attorneys are prohibited from collecting fees based on a fee-sharing agreement if they have not done an appropriate amount of work to earn those fees.

By adhering to these guidelines and obtaining written consent from clients, law firms in Ohio can ensure that their referral fee agreements are ethical, enforceable, and compliant with the relevant rules and regulations.

Fee division

In Ohio, fee divisions between lawyers who are not in the same firm are allowed, but they must comply with certain rules. Rule 1.5(e) of the Ohio Rules of Professional Conduct states that such divisions are permitted only if the following conditions are met:

• The division of fees is proportional to the services performed by each lawyer, or each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation and agrees to be available for consultation with the client.
• The client has given written consent after full disclosure of the identity of each lawyer, the fee division, and the proportionality of the division to the services performed. Alternatively, each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation.
• The written closing statement in a case involving a contingent fee shall be signed by the client and each lawyer, except where court approval of the fee division is obtained.

These rules aim to protect clients from excessive fees and ensure transparency in legal services. It is important to note that any referral fee agreement between attorneys must also comply with ethical rules and relevant laws.

Additionally, according to Opinion 89-002, an attorney may divide fees with a suspended or disbarred attorney if the agreement was made while all attorneys were active and in good standing, and the division is based on work completed while the attorney was active and in good standing.

In the context of personal injury litigation, it is common for smaller firms to rely on referrals from other attorneys, which can result in significant fees. However, it is crucial to have a written agreement and acknowledgment by the client to avoid potential disputes.

While referral fees are generally prohibited in Ohio, there are reports of PI attorneys receiving referral fees after settling a referred case. This may be due to specific exceptions or interpretations of the rules, but it highlights the complexity of referral fee regulations.

Overall, law firms in Ohio can pay referral fees, but it is a nuanced area with specific requirements that must be carefully navigated to ensure compliance with ethical and legal obligations.

Reasonable fees

In Ohio, attorney referral fees are allowed under certain circumstances. Firstly, the division of fees must be in proportion to the services performed by each lawyer. If this condition is not met, each lawyer must assume joint responsibility for the representation and agree to be available for consultation with the client. Secondly, the client must give written consent after full disclosure of the identity of each lawyer, the fees to be divided, and the proportion in which the fees will be divided. Alternatively, each lawyer may assume joint responsibility for the representation. Thirdly, a written closing statement must be signed by the client and each lawyer involved in the referral. This statement must specify the manner in which the compensation was determined, any costs and expenses deducted, and the actual division of fees.

The total fee must be reasonable. A fee is considered excessive when, after reviewing the facts, a lawyer of ordinary prudence would be convinced that the fee exceeds a reasonable amount. Factors to be considered when determining the reasonableness of a fee include the time and labour required, the novelty and difficulty of the questions involved, and the requisite skill to perform the legal service properly. Other factors include the likelihood that accepting the case will preclude other employment for the lawyer, and the fee customarily charged in the locality for similar legal services.

In Ohio, lawyers who are not in the same firm may divide fees only if the above conditions are met. In addition, referral fees must comply with Ohio's Rules of Professional Conduct, which state that lawyers can only refer cases to competent attorneys.

It is important to note that any referral fee agreement between attorneys must comply with the ethics rules governing attorneys and law firms. While it is common for attorneys to refer business to other lawyers, some attorneys shy away from lawyer referral fees to avoid any potential issues.

Frequently asked questions