Lawyers: Can They Double As Realtors?

The roles of a lawyer and a realtor are distinct, but there is some overlap between the two professions. Realtors are real estate professionals who are members of the National Association of Realtors (NAR). They are either brokers or agents who have paid a membership fee and annual fees and complied with the NAR's code of ethics. On the other hand, real estate attorneys are legal professionals who assist home buyers and sellers in completing the property transaction and handling the legal aspects of property transfer. While realtors can help with tasks bordering on legal ones, such as preparing a home purchase contract, they are not licensed to provide legal advice. In some states, only a lawyer can prepare home purchase documents, perform a title search, and close the deal. Lawyers, on the other hand, may not have the same level of knowledge and experience as brokers or realtors in the real estate industry. This raises the question: can a lawyer be a realtor, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of such a dual role?

Lawyers as realtors: the pros and cons

The process of buying a house is complex, and while a real estate agent can help with tasks bordering on legal ones, such as preparing a home purchase contract, they cannot provide legal advice. In some states, like New York and Massachusetts, only a lawyer is allowed to prepare the home purchase documents, perform a title search, and/or close the deal. In such cases, a lawyer functioning as a realtor could be beneficial.

Pros of lawyers as realtors

• They can provide legal advice and protections, which is especially useful when dealing with complex or non-standard contracts.
• They can help with tasks like preparing the home purchase documents, performing a title search, and closing the deal.
• They can help avoid litigation by ensuring all parties are aware of the requirements of the purchase agreement.
• In some jurisdictions, it is a legal requirement that property deals can only proceed with a lawyer's input.

Cons of lawyers as realtors

• Lawyers may charge sky-high hourly rates, which could be a significant con for buyers.
• Lawyers may not have the same level of knowledge or experience as real estate agents when it comes to specific neighbourhoods, preparing a comparative market analysis, drawing up a real estate contract, or spotting home defects.
• There may be ethical and competency issues when a lawyer takes on the dual role of attorney and broker.
• In some states, like New Jersey, a lawyer cannot function as a broker if they are not also performing legal services.

In conclusion, while there may be some benefits to having a lawyer as a realtor, it is important to consider the potential drawbacks, including the cost and the lawyer's level of expertise in the real estate industry.

Why realtors can't give legal advice

While realtors can help with tasks bordering on legal ones, such as preparing a home purchase contract, they are not licensed to provide legal advice. This means that they cannot answer legal questions, even if they know the answer, without breaking the law. In California, for example, only attorneys licensed with the State Bar Association are permitted to practice law. The unauthorized practice of law is a crime under Business & Professions Code 6125, punishable by serious criminal penalties.

Realtors are licensed to help people buy, sell, and rent real estate. They are paid on commission to bring buyers and sellers together. They know how to put a home's best foot forward for selling and how to prepare an appealing offer if you are buying. Realtors can also spot home defects and negotiate repairs, and they have intimate knowledge of certain neighbourhoods.

However, if a buyer wants to know the legal ramifications of a shared driveway easement, for example, this is a legal question that requires a qualified and competent real estate lawyer. A lawyer can provide legal protections and advice, and they can defend you in court if a legal problem arises during a real estate transaction. While lawyers may charge a few hundred dollars per hour, a brief consultation with a lawyer is generally the way to go.

In a few states, such as New York and Massachusetts, only a lawyer is allowed to prepare the home purchase documents, perform a title search, and/or close the deal. In Georgia, an attorney is required to oversee the closing of any real estate transaction.

When to hire a lawyer or realtor to buy a house

When to hire a lawyer to buy a house

In most states, a real estate agent can help you buy a house. However, in some states like New York and Massachusetts, only a lawyer is allowed to prepare the home purchase documents, perform a title search, and/or close the deal. If you are in one of these states, you will need to hire a lawyer to buy a house.

Even if your state does not require it, it is still a good idea to hire a lawyer. Real estate contracts are complex, and a lawyer will ensure that all paperwork is correctly drawn up and filed with the proper authorities. They can also perform a title search to ensure that the property is free of any encumbrances, such as liens or judgments, and counsel you on how to proceed if any issues are uncovered. They can also help resolve technical issues, such as easements, rights of way, boundary disputes, or other issues involving the property.

Additionally, if you are buying a home with an illegal in-law unit and want to evict the existing tenant, only a lawyer can say with certainty whether your plans are feasible. If you are drafting non-standard language for the purchase contract or are concerned about some language in your mortgage, it is also a good idea to have a lawyer look over the documents.

When to hire a realtor to buy a house

While it is not necessary to hire a realtor to buy a house, it can be extremely beneficial. Realtors have a wealth of knowledge, experience, and expertise in the complex real estate market, which can help ensure a successful and hassle-free process. They can help you identify investment properties that meet your specific criteria, gain access to a wide range of property listings, and save you time. They can also help you market and advertise a property, negotiate on your behalf, and handle all the necessary paperwork and legal issues.

If you are buying a house, it is likely that the seller will have a listing agent working on their side of the deal. Hiring a buyer's agent to work on your behalf can help ensure that you have someone on your side to have your back in negotiations and help you make a competitive offer. A realtor can also help you prepare your property for sale, suggest minor repairs or improvements to increase the property's value, and provide tips for making it more appealing to potential buyers.

The legal requirements of realtors and lawyers

In the United States, the real estate industry is subject to a variety of laws and regulations that vary from state to state. Realtors and lawyers play distinct but sometimes overlapping roles in this industry, each with their own unique legal requirements and responsibilities.

Realtors

Realtors, or real estate agents, are professionals in the real estate industry who are often members of the National Association of Realtors (NAR). They are typically licensed by their respective states and must comply with various legal and ethical requirements. For example, in Florida, realtors must be at least 18 years old, hold a high school diploma, submit fingerprints, and report any criminal convictions. They must also complete a pre-licensing course and pass the state's real estate sales associate examination. Realtors are not licensed to provide legal advice and are prohibited from doing so by law. They can, however, provide legal information, such as reciting the legal requirements of a transaction without interpretation. In some jurisdictions, realtors are required to have a close working relationship with a real estate attorney to support their transactions.

Lawyers

Lawyers, on the other hand, are legal professionals who can provide both legal advice and services related to real estate transactions. They typically have a minimum of a law degree and are licensed to practice law in their respective states. Lawyers are often hired to handle the legal aspects of property transfers, including drafting and revising purchase agreements, performing title searches, and closing deals. In some states, such as New York and Massachusetts, only lawyers are permitted to perform these tasks. Lawyers may also face ethical considerations when dealing with "fee-sharing" situations or acting as a broker while providing legal services.

In summary, while realtors and lawyers have distinct roles and legal requirements in the real estate industry, they often work together to facilitate property transactions and ensure compliance with the law.

The education requirements of realtors and lawyers

The education requirements to become a lawyer or realtor vary depending on the jurisdiction. In the United States, each state has its own set of real estate laws and requirements for obtaining a real estate license. On the other hand, the path to becoming a lawyer in the UK involves a similar yet distinct process across the three main jurisdictions: England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.

Realtors

To become a realtor in the US, one must typically complete specific training, licensing, and on-the-job experience requirements. This includes taking a state-approved sales course, passing a licensing exam, gaining experience as a real estate agent, obtaining real estate certifications, and passing the broker's exam. Some states, like Florida, have additional requirements, such as submitting fingerprints and reporting any criminal convictions.

Lawyers

Becoming a lawyer, on the other hand, typically involves a more lengthy and rigorous academic process. In the UK, the traditional path to becoming a solicitor or barrister is to obtain a degree, followed by vocational training and professional examinations or assessments. This can take between 5-6 years to complete.

The first step is to achieve strong GCSE and A-Level results in academic subjects, with universities often requiring a combination of A* or A grades. Following this, one can pursue an undergraduate degree in any subject, followed by a Graduate Diploma in Law (GDL) or Solicitors Qualifying Examination (SQE) to gain the necessary legal knowledge. Alternatively, one can pursue a CILEx Lawyer Apprenticeship, which combines work and study through an apprenticeship.

After completing their degree and additional legal studies, aspiring lawyers must undertake further vocational training and pass professional examinations or assessments. This process can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the specific path chosen, such as becoming a barrister or solicitor.

In the US, the requirements may differ slightly, but it generally involves completing an undergraduate degree, followed by additional legal studies and passing a state bar exam.

Frequently asked questions