Can Evil Fall Truly, Madly, Deeply In Love?

Can a lawful evil character fall in love? This question has been posed by many, especially in the context of role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons (DnD) and in fictional narratives. Lawful evil characters are typically driven by a rigid code of conduct, personal gain, and a willingness to hurt others to achieve their goals. They value allegiances and loyalty to their cause, government, religion, or organization, and are known for their manipulation and deception. However, the concept of love is complex and multifaceted, and it is worth exploring whether a lawful evil character, despite their alignment, can experience romantic love. This topic sparks intriguing discussions and raises questions about the nature of love, the potential for redemption, and the dynamics of relationships between characters with differing alignments.

Lawful evil characters can be loyal to any society, including good-aligned ones

Alignment is a guideline to help determine what axis a character's motivations and behaviours tend to fall on. An evil character may be very selfish or unscrupulous about their methods, but it doesn't mean they have no redeeming qualities.

Lawful evil characters can be found in, and sometimes even be sincerely loyal to, any kind of society, including good-aligned ones. They are prepared to commit evil actions and are prone to invoke moral myopia to justify their deeds. They may also be driven by a paycheck, holding a position in an evil military or government organisation. They are committed to their cause, government, religion, or other organisations, and value their allegiances and those they call allies. They will help those they consider allies, even at personal risk and cost.

Lawful evil characters are also loyal to the law, obeying it out of fear of punishment. They are careful about giving their word, and will only break it if they can find a way to do so legally. They use the law to destroy their enemies and increase their power over others. They are driven to attain their goals through force, power, and intimidation. They may also be loyal to an evil deity or master, seeing their evil deeds as part of their duty.

In fiction, it is not uncommon to find a good-aligned character trapped among evil, who finds someone else who is also good but in a different status. This is similar to a real-life phenomenon called Hybristophilia, an attraction to extremely violent people.

In the context of relationships, a lawful evil character may be willing to turn a blind eye to some goodness in their partner, especially if their affections become their greatest ambition. While it may be challenging, it is possible for a lawful evil character to fall in love with someone of a different alignment, such as a good-aligned character.

Lawful evil characters are driven by power, force and intimidation

Lawful evil characters are driven by power, force, and intimidation. They are committed to a strict code of conduct, often working within the law, to achieve their goals. They value structure and organisation, believing that these elevate those who are worthy to rule and create a clear hierarchy. They are loyal to their allies and will go to great lengths to support them, even if it involves personal risk. However, they are also willing to hurt others and spread evil to achieve their ambitions.

Lawful evil characters are often associated with selfishness, cruelty, and power-hungry tendencies. They may be committed members of a military organisation or serve an evil government or ruler, which naturally places them in the "lawful evil" category. They are driven by a desire for personal gain and will use any means necessary, including force and intimidation, to attain their goals. This may involve manipulating and exploiting others to further their own interests.

In terms of relationships, a lawful evil character may be capable of falling in love, but their motivations and behaviours will still be driven by their alignment. They may turn a blind eye to immoral actions or adopt certain sensibilities to ingratiate themselves with their loved ones. However, their primary focus remains on attaining power and achieving their ambitions.

For example, in a relationship, a lawful evil character might use their partner to increase their own power or status. They may manipulate or exploit their partner's affections to achieve their goals, treating their significant other as a means to an end. While they may experience genuine romantic love, it is often overshadowed by their drive for power and their willingness to use force or intimidation to get what they want.

It is important to note that even within the alignment system, real people are far too complex and multi-dimensional to be classified solely by their alignment. A lawful evil character's capacity for love and their expression of it may vary depending on their individual personality traits and experiences.

Lawful evil characters obey the law to avoid punishment

While it may seem counterintuitive, the idea of a lawful evil character falling in love is not far-fetched. Alignment is a guideline to help determine a character's motivations and behaviour, and even evil characters can have redeeming qualities. In the context of role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons, a lawful evil character may be driven by a desire for power, order, and self-interest, but that does not preclude the possibility of romantic entanglements.

In the context of a romantic relationship, a lawful evil character might fall in love with someone who represents group values or upholds a certain status quo that aligns with their own interests. They might turn a blind eye to immoral actions, or even adopt some of their beloved's sensibilities, not necessarily out of genuine conversion but as a means to further their own ambitions. The relationship could be one of mutual benefit, where the lawful evil character gains social standing or influence through their connection to their beloved.

It is important to note that a lawful evil character's interpretation of "love" may differ from the traditional sense. Their feelings might not be what we typically associate with love, but rather a form of obsession, possessiveness, or a desire for control. Their idea of romance could be more akin to manipulation or a power dynamic, where they seek to dominate or mold their partner to suit their own ends.

That being said, even in a toxic relationship, a lawful evil character might find themselves genuinely attracted to their partner. They could fall in love with someone who challenges their worldview, or they might develop a twisted sense of affection for someone they initially intended to use or manipulate. While the relationship dynamics would undoubtedly be complex and potentially volatile, the notion of a lawful evil character falling in love is certainly plausible and could lead to intriguing narrative possibilities.

Lawful evil characters can be in a relationship with good-aligned characters

In a relationship between a lawful evil and a good-aligned character, the evil character might be willing to turn a blind eye to their partner's goodness and even adopt some of their sensibilities to maintain the relationship. They might also be loyal and committed to their partner, as lawful evil characters value their allegiances and allies. At the same time, the good-aligned character might find the evil character intriguing, or they might have an "I can fix them" attitude, hoping to reform their partner.

An example of this dynamic can be seen in the relationship between Harley Quinn, a dedicated mental health professional and initially good-aligned character, and the Joker, a chaotic evil character. Harley's focus shifts from the "good of society" to the "good of the Joker," illustrating how a good-aligned character might be drawn into a relationship with an evil character.

Additionally, in fiction, it is common to find good-aligned characters trapped among evil, where they form connections with others in similar positions. This dynamic can be seen as similar to Hybristophilia, or an attraction to extremely violent people, and can lead to complex relationships between good and evil characters.

While a relationship between a lawful evil and a good-aligned character is possible, it may not always be healthy or successful. There is a risk of manipulation, toxicity, and betrayal, as the two characters navigate their differing values and motivations. However, with mutual understanding and a willingness to compromise, it is conceivable for such a relationship to flourish.

Lawful evil characters can be in a toxic relationship with good-aligned characters

Lawful evil characters can find themselves in a toxic relationship with good-aligned characters. While it may seem counter-intuitive, there are several reasons why this could happen. Firstly, alignment is just a guideline to help understand a character's motivations and behaviour. Evil characters may have selfish tendencies and unscrupulous methods, but they can still contribute to social good and have relationships with good people. A lawful evil character might turn a blind eye to their partner's goodness, or even adopt some of their sensibilities to ingratiate themselves with their partner.

Secondly, lawful evil characters value allegiances and loyalty. They can be sincerely loyal to any society, including good-aligned ones, as long as it benefits them. They may also be driven by a desire for power and control, which could lead them to manipulate and use their good-aligned partner for their own gain. This dynamic could result in a toxic relationship where the evil character exploits the good character's trust and altruism.

Additionally, some people are attracted to power and find toxic relationships with people in positions of authority, as seen in the example of Hybristophilia, where individuals are aroused or attracted to extremely violent people. This could lead a good-aligned character to become involved with a lawful evil character, especially if the latter presents a facade of charm and civility. The good-aligned character might believe they can reform their partner or turn a blind eye to their flaws, hoping to find a worthwhile and lovable person underneath.

However, it is important to note that such relationships are often unhealthy and unsustainable. The good-aligned character's altruism might be seen as silly and naive by their partner, and the relationship could end in betrayal or manipulation. Ultimately, while it is possible for lawful evil and good-aligned characters to be in a relationship, it is likely to be challenging and may not have a positive outcome.

Frequently asked questions