The Fifth Amendment: Rights Of Lawful Permanent Residents

Lawful permanent residents of the United States, also known as green card holders, are protected under the laws of the United States and all local jurisdictions. They are also protected by the Constitution, which grants them due process of law and equal protection under the law. This includes the First Amendment right to free speech, which applies to all people in the US, including citizens, foreign tourists, and non-citizen residents. However, the Supreme Court has upheld the deportation of lawful permanent residents based on their political activity, and they do not have the same rights as citizens to vote, hold public office, or serve on juries. So, while lawful permanent residents have many of the same rights as citizens, there are some key distinctions.

Lawful permanent residents have First Amendment rights to free speech

Lawful permanent residents of the United States are people born in other countries who can legally work and live in the U.S. They are protected under the laws of the United States and all local jurisdictions. Lawful permanent residents are also protected and maintain rights as given by the Constitution, including due process of law and equal protection under the law.

The Fourteenth Amendment, and through its extension by the Fifth Amendment, gives the right of equal protection under the laws of the United States to all foreign nationals within the boundaries of the United States. The Supreme Court has also ruled that alienage is a "suspect" class, and therefore, any differences in treatment based on alienage must be justified by a compelling state interest.

The First Amendment protects the right to speak, protest, and publish views, regardless of citizenship status. The Supreme Court and other courts recognize that lawful permanent residents have First Amendment rights to free speech. However, this does not prevent deportation based on political activity, as demonstrated by the Supreme Court's decision to uphold the deportation of lawful permanent residents in the 1950s due to their membership in the Communist Party. While lawful permanent residents cannot be criminally prosecuted for their political speech or activity, their statements may affect their ability to remain in the U.S. if they are deemed a security risk by the government.

In addition, lawful permanent residents are not allowed to vote, hold public office, or serve on juries, with a few exceptions, such as voting in some local elections. They may also face restrictions on certain public benefits and must wait several years before becoming eligible for certain programs intended to support low-income individuals.

Lawful permanent residents can lose their legal immigration status

Secondly, lawful permanent residents can lose their status by intentionally abandoning it. This includes moving to another country with the intention of living there permanently, declaring oneself as a "nonimmigrant" on US tax returns, or remaining outside the US for an extended period. Obtaining a re-entry permit or a returning resident visa before leaving the US can help demonstrate that the absence was temporary.

Thirdly, permanent residents can lose their status if they engage in certain criminal activities or are deemed a security risk. While they have First Amendment rights to free speech, their political speech or activity may affect their ability to remain in the US if the government determines they pose a threat. Additionally, conditional residents who fail to remove the conditions on their residence, such as foreign national investors or spouses with two-year green cards, may be removable upon expiration.

Finally, lawful permanent residents can lose their status if an immigration judge issues a final removal order. This can occur if the resident was deemed ineligible for a Green Card at the time their adjustment of status application was approved or if there is fraud involved in obtaining the conditional residence. In the case of a removal order, individuals will lose their permanent resident status and may be placed in deportation proceedings.

Lawful permanent residents are protected under the laws of the US

Lawful permanent residents, also known as legal permanent residents, are protected under the laws of the United States. They have the right to permanently live and work in the United States. These rights are protected by the Fourteenth Amendment, which provides guarantees for "any person", as seen in the case of Yick Wo v Hopkins (1886).

The Fourteenth Amendment, extended by the Fifth Amendment, gives the right of equal protection under the laws of the United States to all foreign nationals within the country's boundaries. This means that lawful permanent residents are protected by the Constitution, including the right to due process and equal protection under the law.

In addition, the Supreme Court and other courts have recognised that lawful permanent residents have First Amendment rights to free speech and freedom of religion. However, it is important to note that lawful permanent residents may still be deported based on their political activity or speech if the government determines they are a security risk. Lawful permanent residents do not have the right to vote, hold public office, or serve on juries, and they may face longer waits or restrictions when accessing certain public benefits and support programmes.

While the United States government has broad powers to decide who is allowed to enter the country, lawful permanent residents who have maintained their immigration status cannot have their green cards revoked without a hearing before an immigration judge. They also have the right to travel outside the United States and return within a specified time frame.

Lawful permanent residents can bring claims in US courts

Lawful permanent residents, also known as legal permanent residents, are people born in other countries who can legally live and work in the US. They are protected under US laws and local jurisdictions, including the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees "any person" due process of law and equal protection under the law.

The Fifth Amendment extends the Fourteenth Amendment, giving the right of equal protection under US laws to all foreign nationals within US boundaries. This means that lawful permanent residents can bring claims in US courts, as allowed under subject matter or standing jurisdiction.

Foreign nationals who are not physically present in the US can also sue in US courts if the cause of action originates within the US, such as in cases involving contracts or property. Lawful permanent residents are also protected by the First Amendment, which guarantees freedom of speech, religion, press, assembly, and petition. However, the Supreme Court has upheld the deportation of lawful permanent residents based on their political activity, particularly if it is deemed a security risk.

While lawful permanent residents cannot vote, hold public office, or serve on juries, they are eligible for certain public benefits and education. They are also required to register for Selective Service, and failure to do so can result in ineligibility for permanent residency and potential deportation.

Lawful permanent residents are not eligible for the same public benefits as citizens

Lawful permanent residents, or green card holders, are non-citizens who have been granted the right to permanently live and work in the United States. While they are protected by the laws of the United States and its local jurisdictions, there are certain distinctions between the rights of citizens and non-citizens. One of the most significant differences is in the area of public benefits.

The Fourteenth Amendment, through its extension by the Fifth Amendment, guarantees equal protection under the laws of the United States to all foreign nationals within its boundaries. However, the Supreme Court has ruled that any differences in treatment based on alienage must be strictly scrutinized, and there must be a compelling state interest to justify the difference. As a result, lawful permanent residents are not eligible for the same public benefits as citizens.

Public benefits that are typically restricted for lawful permanent residents include Medicaid and other forms of government support. For example, they often have to wait for a certain period, typically five years, before becoming eligible for certain programs intended to support low-income individuals, such as Supplemental Security Income and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. Additionally, unlike citizens, lawful permanent residents can lose their legal immigration status and be deported on grounds of national security or terrorism concerns, even without committing a crime.

In terms of political participation, non-citizens, including lawful permanent residents, do not have the right to vote, hold public office, or serve on juries. However, they can still participate in protests and publish their political views, as the First Amendment protects the right to free speech and assembly for all individuals in the United States, regardless of citizenship status. Nevertheless, civil liberties groups have expressed concerns about the broad latitude granted to the executive branch in deportation matters, which creates a gray area where the rights of lawful permanent residents may be at risk.

Frequently asked questions