Practicing Federal Law: State Lawyers' Jurisdictional Limits

Lawyers are often required to cross state borders or travel to other states to meet with clients, and many wonder if they can practice law in multiple states. While it is possible to become a multi-state lawyer, it is not as simple as taking one bar exam and being licensed to practice law nationally. The general rule is that a lawyer can only practice law in a state court when they have been admitted to the bar of that state. However, there are some exceptions and workarounds to this rule.

Becoming a multi-state lawyer

The process of becoming a multi-state lawyer is not uniform across different states. The two primary ways of being licensed to practice in multiple states are:

• Applying for reciprocity with other state bars: Most states have some form of reciprocity, where they will allow lawyers admitted in a reciprocal state to gain admission on application without an exam. However, states offering reciprocity may have experience requirements, such as a certain number of years of active law practice.
• Passing the bar exams in multiple states: Each state crafts its bar exam to meet its jurisdictional needs, and you may need to take a separate exam or course on state laws.

Even if you are licensed in multiple states, you will need to pay license fees and complete Continuing Legal Education (CLE) hours for each license, which can be costly and time-consuming. Additionally, state laws vary widely, and you will need to keep up with different regulations, which can cause confusion.

Practicing Federal Law

There is debate on whether a lawyer needs multiple state bar association licenses to practice federal law in multiple states. Some lawyers take the stance that they can practice federal law anywhere as long as they have a state bar license. However, this approach can be risky, as demonstrated by a case in Michigan where a lawyer with only a Texas bar card was sued by the Michigan Bar for unauthorized practice.

Benefits of Being a Multi-State Lawyer

• Increased client reach: You can work with clients on both sides of state borders and become the go-to attorney for niche practice areas across multiple states.
• Enhanced professional flexibility: You can handle more diverse legal issues and broaden your legal career options.
• Remote work opportunities: Technological advancements have made it easier for lawyers to work remotely across various states.

Practicing federal law in state court

Firstly, it is important to understand the distinction between federal and state law. Most crimes are considered state crimes, governed by state-specific rules and requirements. In contrast, federal crimes involve matters related to the Federal government, such as non-payment of federal taxes, interference with the Postal Service, or crimes committed on federal property. Lawyers practicing federal law may find themselves dealing with cases that cross state borders, which can complicate the issue of state bar admissions.

To practice law in a particular state, lawyers typically need to pass that state's bar exam. This process can be time-consuming and expensive, as each state has its own licensing agency with unique protocols. However, there are ways to obtain licenses in multiple states without taking separate bar exams. Reciprocity agreements between states allow lawyers admitted in one state to gain admission in another without an additional exam. Additionally, the Uniform Bar Exam (UBE), currently administered by 13 states, enables attorneys to transfer their scores and apply for admission in other UBE states.

For lawyers interested in practicing federal law in state court, there are a few options. One approach is to obtain a State Bar license in the state where the district court is located. This is because admission to a federal district court generally requires a state bar license, although it doesn't have to be from the same state as the court. Alternatively, lawyers can seek admission on a pro hac vice basis, where an out-of-state lawyer can practice with an in-state attorney acting as local counsel. In-house counsel for companies may also practice federal law, but they cannot appear in court unless they are licensed in that state.

While it is possible to practice federal law in state court, it is a complex and evolving area of legal practice. The benefits of being a multi-state lawyer include increased geographical freedom and a larger client base. However, there are also challenges, such as higher costs, marketing difficulties, and the need to stay updated with varying state laws and courtroom procedures. Ultimately, each state and federal district has its own rules for admission, and lawyers must carefully navigate these requirements to avoid unauthorized practice.

State bar reciprocity

Bar reciprocity is an umbrella term for transfer agreements between states. Generally, states fall into one of the following categories:

• Admission on Motion Based on Criteria: Allows attorneys from any state to be admitted as long as they meet the set criteria.
• Admission on Motion Based on Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted if their transferring jurisdiction also permits attorneys from the admitting jurisdiction to be admitted under similar rules.
• Semi-Pure Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted if their transferring jurisdiction also permits attorneys from the admitting jurisdiction to be admitted under similar rules, but with stricter procedures and potential transfer fees.
• Pure Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted according to the rules of the transferring jurisdiction.
• No Admission on Motion: Attorneys are not allowed to be admitted into the jurisdiction without examination.

To get reciprocity in a new state, attorneys must typically apply for admission to the bar of that state. Each state has its own rules and requirements for admission, which may include:

• Meeting character and fitness requirements.
• Passing the Multistate Professional Responsibility Exam (MPRE).
• Years of practice.
• A degree from an ABA-accredited law school.
• Registering as in-house counsel.
• Transferring exam scores through the Uniform Bar Exam (UBE).
• Qualifying for a military spouse exemption.

Even if there isn't formal reciprocity between two states, some states allow out-of-state attorneys to transfer to the state's bar without taking the state bar exam. These states typically have a process called "waiver on motion," "waiver," or "comity," which admits attorneys who are already licensed to practise law in another state. To qualify for admission through waiver on motion, an attorney must typically meet certain requirements, such as being a U.S. citizen or permanent resident, being admitted to practise law in another state, and being in good standing in all states where they are admitted to practise.

While state bar reciprocity can offer many benefits, including expanding your legal career, enhancing flexibility, and promoting professional growth, it is important to note that each federal district has its own rules for admission. Additionally, practising law in multiple states can be challenging due to varying state laws and regulations, maintaining multiple state licences, and the potential for confusion with legal statutes.

The debate on practicing federal law in any state

The debate on practising federal law in any state

There is a debate among legal professionals about whether a lawyer can practise federal law in any state. Some lawyers take the stance that they can practise federal law anywhere, as long as they are bar-licensed in any state. This is because most crimes are considered state crimes, and federal crimes can be handled by a lawyer from any state. For example, federal crimes include non-payment of federal taxes, interfering with the postal service, crimes committed on federal property, and crimes committed against federal workers.

However, this approach can be risky. For example, a lawyer who practised bankruptcy law in Michigan with only a Texas bar card was sued by the Michigan Bar for the unauthorised practice of law. While there is an exception for pro hac vice admission, where an out-of-state lawyer can practise with an in-state attorney acting as local counsel, this is not always possible. Additionally, each federal district has its own rules for admission, which can make practising federal law in any state more complicated. For example, the Southern District of New York requires that someone be admitted in New York State or the district courts of Connecticut or Vermont.

Another factor to consider is that most areas of the law have state-specific rules and requirements, and even fields of law that are primarily federal, such as bankruptcy and immigration, may require a State Bar licence. This is because each of the 50 states has its own licensing agency with its own protocols, and bar admission rules are established by state bar organisations. While some states have reciprocity agreements that allow lawyers licensed in one state to practise in another, most states require a separate bar exam for admission. Additionally, maintaining a law licence can be expensive, with licence fees ranging from $200 to $500, and there may be additional costs for Continuing Legal Education hours.

In conclusion, while it is technically possible to practise federal law in any state, there are legal, financial, and logistical considerations that lawyers must take into account before doing so.

Remote work for lawyers

While it is possible to become a multi-state lawyer, it is not a straightforward process. The general rule is that a lawyer can only practice law in a state court when they have been admitted to the bar of that state. This means that, in most cases, lawyers are required to pass the bar exam for each state in which they wish to practice. This can be costly and time-consuming, as lawyers will need to pay license fees and complete a certain number of Continuing Legal Education (CLE) hours to maintain their license.

There are, however, some exceptions to this rule. Firstly, an out-of-state lawyer can practice with an in-state attorney acting as local counsel. Secondly, for federal law, a lawyer must be admitted to appear in the district court where the legal matter is being handled. Admission to a district court generally requires a state bar license, but this does not need to be from the state where the district court is located. Therefore, fields of law that are primarily federal, such as bankruptcy and immigration, may not require admission to the state bar where the attorney is practicing.

There has been considerable litigation and debate on this issue. Some lawyers take the stance that if their practice is primarily federal, they can practice everywhere. However, this approach can be risky, as demonstrated by a case in Michigan where a lawyer who practiced bankruptcy law with only a Texas bar card was sued by the Michigan Bar for the unauthorized practice of law. While remote work has transformed the legal profession, telecommuting from another state can be a complicated matter.

Frequently asked questions