Practicing Law: State-By-State Licensing For Lawyers

Lawyers in the United States are often confronted with the question of whether they can practice law in any state. While federal law allows a lawyer from any state to represent a client, state law varies and is more complex. Each state has its own bar exam, and most require lawyers to be licensed by their bar association to practice within their jurisdiction. However, some states offer reciprocity, allowing lawyers licensed in other states to practice without taking their bar exam. Additionally, remote work has blurred the lines, with some states permitting lawyers to practice virtually from another state.

Can a lawyer practice law in any state?

Practicing federal law in multiple states

Securities, immigration, environmental law, and bankruptcy are some of the areas governed almost exclusively by federal law. For instance, a lawyer practicing bankruptcy law in Michigan with only a Texas bar card was initially admitted to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan. However, the Michigan Bar sued him for unauthorized practice, and the bankruptcy court suspended him. The Sixth Circuit eventually sided with the lawyer, but the issue remains unclear outside of that circuit.

To practice federal law in multiple states, lawyers have a few options. Firstly, they can take the bar exam in multiple states, as many states schedule their bar exams simultaneously to facilitate this process. Secondly, they can utilize bar reciprocity agreements between states, which allow lawyers to be admitted to a new state without retaking the bar exam. For example, Alaska has reciprocity agreements with 28 other states, while Illinois has agreements with 30. However, some states, like Alabama, Arizona, and Arkansas, do not offer reciprocity.

Additionally, some states offer shorter bar examinations for lawyers in good standing licensed in other states. For instance, California, despite previously having the longest and most challenging exam, now offers a shorter exam for attorneys licensed in other states with good standing for at least four years. Maine and Maryland have similar provisions, requiring good standing in another state for at least three and five years, respectively.

Finally, remote work for attorneys has become more common due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The American Bar Association (ABA) clarified in December 2020 that attorneys may practice law remotely in a jurisdiction where they are licensed. However, if practicing remotely in an unlicensed jurisdiction, lawyers must ensure that the remote jurisdiction allows it and must not advertise their services there.

In conclusion, while practicing federal law in multiple states is possible, it requires careful navigation of each state's bar admission rules and regulations.

State-specific rules and requirements

Each state in the US has its own bar association with specific rules and requirements for lawyers to practice law within the state. While some states have reciprocity agreements, allowing lawyers licensed in one state to practice in another, others require lawyers to pass a separate bar exam for that state.

For example, Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Hawaii, and Idaho do not offer reciprocity, meaning that lawyers from other states must pass that state's bar exam to practice law there. On the other hand, states like Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, and Maryland offer some form of reciprocity, allowing lawyers licensed in other states to practice there under certain conditions. These conditions often include having a certain number of years of experience or a certain score on the bar exam.

Additionally, some states have unique requirements for lawyers to practice law within their jurisdiction. For instance, Minnesota requires lawyers to be 18 years of age or older and of good character and fitness, in addition to having a law degree or a bachelor's degree from an accredited institution.

Furthermore, the type of law practiced can also determine the specific rules and requirements. Transactional lawyers, who don't frequently appear in courtrooms, may find it easier to practice in multiple states as long as they have passed the bar exam for each state. Litigators, on the other hand, must also be familiar with courtroom procedures, which vary from state to state, making it more challenging to practice in multiple states.

In conclusion, while it is possible for lawyers to practice in multiple states, it requires careful navigation of the state-specific rules and requirements, including reciprocity agreements, bar exam requirements, and variations in courtroom procedures.

Bar reciprocity and bar admission rules

The general rule is that a lawyer can only practice law in a state court when they have been admitted to the bar of that state. However, there are several ways to gain admission to the bar of a state other than taking that state's bar exam.

Bar Reciprocity

Bar reciprocity is an umbrella term for transfer agreements between states. There are several types of bar reciprocity:

• Admission on Motion Based on Criteria: Allows attorneys from any state to be admitted as long as they meet the set criteria.
• Admission on Motion Based on Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted if their transferring jurisdiction also allows attorneys from the admitting jurisdiction to be admitted under similar rules.
• Semi-Pure Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted if their transferring jurisdiction also allows attorneys from the admitting jurisdiction to be admitted under similar rules. However, attorneys face stricter procedures and potential transfer fees.
• Pure Reciprocity: Allows attorneys to be admitted according to the rules of the transferring jurisdiction.
• No Admission on Motion: Attorneys are not allowed to be admitted into the jurisdiction without examination.

Waiver on Motion

Some states allow out-of-state attorneys to transfer to the state’s bar without taking the state’s bar exam, even if there’s no reciprocity agreement in place between the two states. These states typically have a process called "waiver on motion", "waiver", or "comity" which allows attorneys who are already licensed to practice law in another state to be admitted to the bar of the new state without taking the bar exam. To qualify for admission through waiver on motion, an attorney typically must meet certain requirements, such as:

• Being a U.S. citizen or permanent resident.
• Being admitted to practice law in another state, U.S. territory, or commonwealth.
• Being in good standing in all states where the attorney is admitted to practice.
• Having a certain amount of legal experience, typically at least a few years.
• Meeting the character and fitness requirements for admission to the bar in the new state.

In-House Counsel Registration

In-house counsel registration allows attorneys who work as in-house counsel for a company to practice law on behalf of that company in a state where they are not licensed. To qualify for in-house counsel registration, attorneys must typically be employed full-time as in-house counsel for a company and have a certain amount of legal experience.

Pro Hac Vice

Most states allow attorneys who are not licensed in their jurisdiction to practice law in the jurisdiction on a limited basis through a practice known as pro hac vice. Attorneys must typically submit an application for pro hac vice to the state bar before they can represent a client in a particular case or controversy in the state. Pro hac vice privileges usually last for a specific duration of time and will require the attorney to collaborate with a local lawyer serving as local counsel.

Federal Law

For federal court, a lawyer must be admitted to appear in the district court where the legal matter is being handled. Admission to district court will generally require a state bar license, but that license does not need to be from the state where the district court is located. Therefore, fields of law that are primarily federal, such as bankruptcy and immigration, may not require admission to the state bar where that attorney is practicing. However, each federal district has its own rules for admission.

Remote work and telecommuting

However, this trend has also raised questions about the unauthorized practice of law (UPL) and potential ethical and legal issues. The definition of UPL and the regulations surrounding it vary across states. For example, Ohio has adopted the ABA's rule on UPL, while Kentucky has not. This means that an attorney licensed in another state may be able to practice in Ohio under certain conditions, but doing so in Kentucky could result in UPL charges.

The American Bar Association (ABA) has issued guidelines and opinions to address this issue. For instance, the ABA's Formal Opinion 495 states that lawyers licensed in one jurisdiction can practice remotely in another jurisdiction without violating UPL statutes. While this opinion is not binding, it provides guidance to individual jurisdictions. Some states, like New Jersey, have followed this guidance, allowing lawyers to work remotely from the state as long as they don't give the impression of practicing law there.

Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the shift towards remote work for lawyers, with many jurisdictions clarifying their definitions of UPL to accommodate this new reality. For example, California-licensed attorneys working remotely from another state like Nevada or Texas may not be considered engaged in UPL as long as they are serving California clients and not violating any local UPL statutes.

Overall, while remote work and telecommuting offer increased flexibility for lawyers, it is essential to be mindful of the varying regulations and ethical considerations across states to avoid unauthorized practice.

Becoming a multi-state lawyer: benefits and challenges

While it is possible to become a multi-state lawyer, it is important to note that each state has its own bar admission rules and requirements. The general rule is that a lawyer can only practice law in a state court if they have been admitted to the bar of that state. However, there are some exceptions and alternative paths to achieving multi-state licensure.

One option is to take advantage of bar reciprocity agreements between states. Many states offer reciprocity, which allows lawyers licensed in one state to be admitted to practice in another state without taking an additional bar exam. Reciprocity agreements vary from state to state, and some states do not offer reciprocity at all. For example, California, Arizona, and Delaware do not offer reciprocity, while Alaska offers reciprocity to a wide range of states. It is important to research the specific requirements for each state before assuming reciprocity.

Another option is to practice federal law. As long as a lawyer is bar-licensed in any state, they can practice federal law anywhere. This is because federal courts require admission to the district court where the legal matter is handled, and this admission does not always require a license from the state where the district court is located. However, this approach can be risky, as demonstrated by a case in Michigan where a lawyer practicing bankruptcy law with only a Texas bar card was sued by the Michigan Bar for unauthorized practice.

Additionally, some states allow for admission on motion, where lawyers who have passed the bar exam in other states can be admitted to practice in a new state without taking a new bar exam. This typically involves filing a motion with the desired state's supreme court or bar association and providing certificates of good standing from other jurisdictions.

Practicing law in multiple states offers several benefits, including increased client reach and enhanced professional flexibility. It can be especially advantageous for lawyers in niche practice areas or in states with low population densities. However, there are also challenges to being a multi-state lawyer. It can be more expensive, pose marketing challenges, and cause confusion with legal statutes, as each state has its own unique laws and procedures. Transactional lawyers may find it easier to practice in multiple states, as they don't have to deal with varying courtroom procedures like litigators.

In conclusion, becoming a multi-state lawyer offers both advantages and disadvantages. It requires careful research and planning to navigate the varying requirements and challenges of each state while also expanding one's practice and client base.

Frequently asked questions