Mayors' Power: Zoning Laws And Their Removal

Zoning laws are government regulations that dictate how land is used and what can be built on it. They are typically governed by local county or city laws and help an area grow in a way that benefits the community. While zoning laws are generally enforced by local governments, a mayor can play a role in their removal. For example, in 2023, Gilbert Mayor Brigette Peterson testified against an Arizona Senate bill that aimed to remove many local zoning laws. The bill, SB 1117, sought to address the state's housing crisis by removing zoning rules and speeding up the approval process for new housing developments. However, Mayor Peterson argued that the bill would disregard important aspects of the community's long-term planning and restrict their ability to implement design standards. While the mayor can influence zoning laws, the power to enact or remove them ultimately lies with the legislative body that created them.

Mayors can oppose bills to remove zoning laws

Mayors can play a crucial role in opposing bills to remove zoning laws, as demonstrated by the case of Gilbert Mayor Brigette Peterson, who testified against an Arizona state Senate bill aimed at eliminating various local zoning laws. This bill, known as SB 1117, sought to address the state's housing crisis by requiring municipalities to permit new housing developments on small lots in residential areas. While the bill's proponents argued for the need to cut red tape and boost housing supply, Mayor Peterson and other critics highlighted the potential disregard for community-specific planning processes, design standards, and citizen participation—factors that contribute to the uniqueness and strength of a community.

The power to zone land is typically granted to local governments by state laws, and it serves as a principal tool for urban planning and community development. Zoning laws enable municipalities to control the character of specific locations, ensuring that growth occurs in an orderly and beneficial manner for the public interest. Mayors, as leaders of their communities, are intimately involved in this process and are responsible for ensuring that zoning decisions align with the needs and desires of their constituents.

By opposing bills that remove zoning laws, mayors can protect their communities from undesirable or inappropriate development. They can argue that zoning laws are essential for maintaining the unique character of their cities and that any changes should be carefully considered through established planning processes. Mayors can emphasize the potential negative consequences of removing zoning laws, including increased traffic, safety issues, noise, and decreased property values.

Furthermore, mayors can advocate for the preservation of zoning laws that promote specific community goals, such as environmental sustainability and resilience. For example, the Mayor's Office of Climate and Environmental Justice in New York City has been instrumental in implementing policies that integrate climate standards and new technologies into building and zoning codes, promoting carbon neutrality and housing affordability. By opposing bills to remove zoning laws, mayors can ensure that their communities continue to benefit from such forward-thinking policies and initiatives.

In conclusion, mayors can play a vital role in opposing bills to remove zoning laws by highlighting the importance of community-specific planning, citizen engagement, and the pursuit of broader community goals. Their involvement in these matters ensures that the unique characteristics and needs of their cities are considered, fostering the creation and maintenance of strong, vibrant communities.

Zoning laws are local county or city laws

Zoning laws are local laws that dictate how a property can or cannot be used within a certain geographical area. They are typically enacted by a municipal corporation or county, and they vary greatly by region. The purpose of zoning laws is to separate incompatible land uses, such as residential and commercial properties, and to provide stability to property values.

Zoning ordinances are the specific regulations that make up zoning laws. These ordinances can be bypassed with a variance, which is a request to deviate from current zoning rules. For example, a property owner may request an exception to allow a home-based business to operate within a residential zone. The process for applying for a variance may vary depending on the municipality.

Zoning laws can also be used to protect and enhance the value of real estate and stimulate economic growth. They can help accomplish the overall goals of a given community, such as providing affordable housing or promoting sustainable development. However, zoning laws can also be subject to change over time, and property owners may request exceptions or amendments to the laws.

While zoning laws are typically enacted and enforced at the local level, there may be cases where state or federal laws also come into play. For example, in the United States, the Supreme Court has ruled on several cases related to land use regulations and zoning ordinances. It is important for individuals and communities to be involved in the zoning process and to understand the applicable laws and regulations to ensure that their interests are represented.

Zoning laws help areas grow in an orderly way

Zoning laws are an essential aspect of urban planning and development, providing a roadmap for how a city or area should grow and change over time. They are designed to ensure that the development of a city is well-ordered and takes into account the interests of its citizens. By dividing the city into different districts, zoning laws can limit the uses allowed in each area, ensuring that incompatible land uses are not placed side by side. For example, zoning laws can prevent factories or industrial facilities from being built in residential areas, maintaining the character of the neighbourhood and protecting residents from noise, pollution, and other negative impacts.

Zoning ordinances also play a crucial role in managing urban growth and development. They determine what types of structures can be built, whether existing properties can be repurposed, and if new construction is permitted. Zoning regulations can control the size, placement, density, architectural style, and height of buildings within a specific zone. This helps to ensure that development is compatible and beneficial to the community and allows room for the city to grow sustainably over time.

In addition to regulating the types of structures and land use, zoning laws can also influence the economic and social dynamics of an area. For example, zoning laws that restrict heavy industrial and commercial development to areas adjacent to lower-income neighbourhoods can contribute to a disparity in the quality of life among socioeconomic groups. Integrated, walkable neighbourhoods with mixed-use zones can help reduce car dependency and provide residents with convenient access to essential services and entertainment.

While zoning laws provide a framework for orderly growth, they are not static and can be subject to change. Zone change requests can be made through a rezoning application process, which considers the proposal's compliance with the existing ordinance and, in some cases, a comprehensive plan for the area. Amendments to zoning ordinances may be necessary to adapt to growing populations, address housing shortages, or promote economic development. However, changes to zoning laws can also create tension among current and prospective residents, as well as landlords, who may have differing opinions on how an area should develop.

Mayors can work on programs to improve energy efficiency

While a mayor cannot remove zoning laws, they can play a crucial role in implementing programs to improve energy efficiency in their cities. Mayors across the country are increasingly recognizing the importance of energy efficiency in combating climate change and promoting economic development.

One way mayors can improve energy efficiency is by utilizing building codes, benchmarking requirements, financing programs, and point-of-sale requirements. For instance, cities like Seattle, New York City, and San Francisco have adopted commercial benchmarking and disclosure laws. These laws require large building owners to annually measure and submit energy and water consumption data, enabling cities to track energy use and make informed policy decisions.

Additionally, mayors can encourage the private sector to enhance energy efficiency through financing programs and initiatives. For example, federal green building loan programs and private investments are making a significant impact in this area. Mayors can also promote the use of tools like the EPA's EnergyStar Portfolio Manager, which is freely available and assists in managing energy efficiency.

Furthermore, mayors can prioritize sustainability and clean energy initiatives. This can be achieved by making leases for government buildings contingent on sustainability improvements and attracting socially responsible investors who require sustainability plans before providing capital. By doing so, mayors can reduce energy costs, improve the health of their residents, and make their cities more attractive to developers and homeowners.

Overall, by implementing various policies and programs, mayors can play a pivotal role in improving energy efficiency, reducing carbon emissions, and creating a more sustainable future for their communities.

Zoning laws can be challenged as improper or unconstitutional

While zoning laws are typically enforced by local governments, they can be challenged as improper or unconstitutional. To challenge a zoning ordinance, one must demonstrate that it violates their rights as a property owner and that they have suffered undue hardship as a result. For instance, if a zoning regulation prevents you from carrying out your profession at home, you must show the court the financial losses you have incurred due to this limitation.

In the United States, zoning laws have been challenged in court on the basis of the First, Fifth, and Fourteenth Amendments. In Sable Communications of California v. Federal Communications Commission (1989), the Court stated that "the First Amendment protects indecent but not obscene sexual expression" and that the government cannot restrict access to such speech. This has been applied to zoning laws, where the Supreme Court determined that zoning can create adult zones or limit the placement of adult entertainment companies, but cannot completely zone them out. In the case of Buchanan v. Warley (1917), the Court ruled that city legislation dividing communities by race violated the Fourteenth Amendment, making zoning for racially discriminatory purposes unlawful. The Fifth Amendment has also been used to challenge zoning rules that are overly burdensome and amount to an unjustified taking of property.

Additionally, zoning laws can be challenged as improper if they are inconsistent with the comprehensive plan for the area. A "comp plan" guides the future use and development of land, and a zone change must align with this plan. If a proposed zone change is inconsistent with the plan, the applicant may seek a plan amendment to allow for the zone change. However, becoming familiar with the standards that apply to a comprehensive plan amendment can be complex, and a land use attorney can provide valuable guidance in navigating these processes.

While zoning laws can be challenged in court, it is important to note that opposing a zoning application can be complicated. Understanding the procedural and substantive requirements, as well as the approval criteria, is crucial for mounting an effective challenge.

Frequently asked questions