Martial Law: Electing A President Amidst Uncertainty

The concept of martial law in the United States is vague and has never been well understood. The U.S. Constitution does not define or specify who can declare it, and there is no federal law that explicitly authorizes the president to do so. While several presidents have imposed or approved declarations of martial law throughout history, the Supreme Court has never ruled that the president can declare it. Given the uncertainty and potential for abuse of power, the question arises: can a new president be elected during martial law, and what implications would this have for civil liberties and democratic processes?

The US Constitution does not specify who can declare martial law

Throughout history, martial law has been imposed at least 68 times in limited, usually local areas of the United States. It was first used in 1814, near the end of the War of 1812, when General Andrew Jackson, who later became president, declared martial law in New Orleans to defend against a British invasion. The Louisiana Supreme Court later referred to Jackson's use of martial law as "trampling upon the Constitution and laws of our country."

Several presidents and many state governors have imposed or approved declarations of martial law throughout American history. State officials have sometimes declared martial law in response to violent civil unrest or natural disasters, such as the Akron Riot of 1900 or the 1900 Galveston hurricane. During the West Virginia Coal Wars (1920-1921), martial law was declared in the state of West Virginia at the behest of Governor Cornwell, who requested federal troops to deal with striking miners.

There are two competing theories regarding the source of the power to declare martial law. One theory suggests that martial law "arises from the nature of things, being the law of paramount necessity." In other words, it stems from the government's right, power, and/or duty to "maintain public order" and keep the peace. The other theory argues that the Constitution's enumerated war powers of the legislative and executive branches give both Congress and the president the power to declare martial law.

The US President does not have the authority to declare martial law

The US Constitution does not define martial law, nor does it specify who can declare it. While the Constitution's war powers grant each branch some control over the military, it does not give the president "conclusive and preclusive" authority over the domestic use of the military. Instead, it explicitly vests power in the legislative branch, meaning the president cannot act against Congress's wishes in this area.

Some scholars argue that the president has the executive power to declare martial law. However, this is a minority view, and the majority believe that the president needs congressional authorization to impose martial law in a civilian area. Therefore, Congress may be the only governmental branch that can legally declare martial law, and the president can only act according to its actions.

The Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled that the president or federal government can declare martial law. While it has implied that the federal government can, it has never stated this conclusively. The Court has also never explained the legal basis for martial law, and its statements on the matter have been inconsistent.

Throughout American history, martial law has been declared over 60 times by federal and state governments. While several presidents have imposed or approved declarations of martial law, this does not mean they had the constitutional authority to do so.

Martial law has been declared over 60 times in the US

Martial law in the United States refers to instances in US history where a region, state, city, or the entire country was placed under the control of a military body. While the US Constitution does not define martial law or specify who can declare it, both the US President and Congress have the power to impose it, as they can be in charge of the militia. Similarly, in nearly every state, the governor can impose martial law within their state's borders.

The first use of martial law occurred in 1814, near the end of the War of 1812. General Andrew Jackson, who later became the seventh US President, declared martial law in New Orleans to defend against a British invasion. After successfully leading the defence of the city, Jackson continued to enforce martial law for two months. In 1815, the Louisiana Supreme Court referred to Jackson's use of martial law as "trampling upon the Constitution and laws of our country."

Since then, martial law has been declared over 60 times in the US, with some sources placing the number at 68. These declarations have been made by both state and federal officials. Notable instances of martial law being imposed include the Illinois Mormon War, the Utah War, the Omaha race riot of 1919, the Lexington riots of 1920, the West Virginia Coal Wars (1920-1921), and the General Strike of 1935 in Vigo County, Indiana.

While the president has ample authority under current law to deploy troops to assist civilian law enforcement, the power to declare martial law is less clear. Some scholars believe the president has the executive power to declare it, while others argue that congressional authorization is required for the president to impose martial law in civilian areas. The Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled that the president or federal government can declare martial law, and no federal laws grant the president this authority.

State governors can declare martial law

The United States Constitution does not define martial law and does not specify who can declare it. However, state governors can declare martial law, and throughout history, several have imposed or approved declarations of martial law. Nearly every state has a constitutional provision authorizing the government to impose martial law. This power is given to them by either the state constitution or the state legislature.

The Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled that the president or federal government can declare martial law, but it has held that states can. The modern interpretation of the Constitution allows the president and state officials to declare "degrees of martial law in specific circumstances." The Insurrection Act, enacted in 1807, is a federal law that allows the president to deploy military forces domestically to suppress insurrections, rebellions, or domestic violence. However, the president's authority to declare martial law is disputed, with some scholars arguing that only Congress has the power to do so.

The first use of martial law in the United States occurred in 1814, near the end of the War of 1812. General Andrew Jackson, who later became the seventh president, declared martial law in New Orleans to defend against a British invasion. After successfully leading the defense, Jackson continued to enforce martial law for two months. In 1815, the Louisiana Supreme Court criticized Jackson's use of martial law as "trampling upon the Constitution and laws of our country."

Since then, martial law has been imposed at least 68 times, mostly in limited, local areas. It has been declared twice for war or invasion, seven times for domestic war or insurrection, eleven times for riot or civil unrest, 29 times for labor dispute, four times for natural disaster, and fifteen times for other reasons. Notable examples include the Great Chicago Fire of 1871, the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, and the Utah War.

In summary, while the president's authority to declare martial law is unclear and disputed, state governors can declare martial law and have done so throughout history.

Martial law is a vague term for when military authorities take control of civil governance

Martial law is a somewhat vague legal term for when military authorities take control of civil governance and law enforcement. It is a rare occurrence that has been used over 60 times throughout American history. The U.S. Constitution and founding documents do not mention martial law, nor has Congress passed a law specifying when martial law can be declared. The Constitution does not define martial law and does not specify who can declare it. However, several presidents and many state governors have imposed or approved declarations of martial law throughout American history.

The Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled that the president or federal government can declare martial law. The Court has, however, held that states can declare martial law. Almost all state constitutions allow the state governor or legislature to impose martial law. The Posse Comitatus Act, passed by Congress in 1878, forbids U.S. military involvement in domestic law enforcement without congressional approval.

There are two competing theories regarding the source of the power to declare martial law. The first theory suggests that martial law does not come from any direct authority but rather "arises from the nature of things, being the law of paramount necessity." In other words, it stems from the government's right, power, and/or duty to "maintain public order" and keep the peace. The second theory argues that the Constitution's enumerated war powers of the legislative and executive branches give both Congress and the president the power to declare martial law.

Declaring martial law is typically a last resort, as it could be easily abused as a political tool to control the population, especially political dissenters. It is intended to be reserved for times of extreme emergencies when existing civilian government and law enforcement have ceased to function or become ineffective. During martial law, the executive or military leaders may suspend certain civil liberties.

Frequently asked questions