Part-Time Judges: Can They Practice Law Simultaneously?

The role of a judge is to contribute to the law, the legal system, and the administration of justice. In the United States, the Code of Conduct for judges outlines that a judge's duties take precedence over all other activities and that they should be performed impartially and diligently. While there are no explicit prohibitions on part-time judges practising law, certain conditions must be met. For instance, a municipal court judge may practice law except in the court in which they serve. Additionally, a judge should refrain from financial and business dealings that reflect adversely on their impartiality or interfere with their judicial duties. In some counties, rules are in place to prevent conflicts, such as prohibiting those handling criminal cases from practising criminal law.

Part-time judges and conflicts of interest

Part-time judges, also known as relief judges, are expected to uphold a Code of Conduct and ethical canons that apply to federal judges. This code provides guidance on their performance of official duties and engagement in outside activities.

Part-time judges must disqualify themselves from any proceeding in which they have a financial interest, no matter how small. They must also refrain from engaging in business and financial activities that might interfere with the impartial performance of their judicial duties. This includes the practice of law, where a part-time judge would give the appearance of disregarding their duty to remain impartial if their law practice includes clients whose cases were considered by other judges on the same court.

Part-time judges must also refrain from lending the prestige of their judicial office to advance private interests. For example, a judge should not use their judicial position or title to gain advantage in litigation involving friends or family members. They may, however, without compensation, give legal advice to and draft or review documents for a member of their family, but they are prohibited from officially serving as the family member's lawyer.

In the United States, federal courts and judges must implement automated screening to help identify any financial conflicts of interest.

Part-time judges and professional conduct

Part-time judges are subject to rules and standards of professional conduct that govern their judicial and personal behaviour. These rules vary by jurisdiction, but some common principles include:

Upholding the Integrity and Independence of the Judiciary

Part-time judges are expected to uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary and avoid any impropriety or appearance thereof. This includes refraining from financial and business dealings that reflect adversely on their impartiality, interfere with their judicial duties, exploit their position, or involve frequent transactions with lawyers or individuals likely to appear before their court.

Faithfulness to the Law and Impartiality

Part-time judges, like their full-time counterparts, must be faithful to the law and maintain professional competence. They should not be influenced by partisan interests, public opinion, or fear of criticism. They are also expected to perform their judicial duties without bias or prejudice and to maintain order and decorum in proceedings.

Respect and Courtesy

Judges should be patient, dignified, and courteous to all individuals they interact with in their official capacity, including litigants, jurors, witnesses, and lawyers. They should also require similar conduct from lawyers, court staff, and those under their direction and control.

Conflict of Interest and Ethical Considerations

Part-time judges must be mindful of potential conflicts of interest and ethical dilemmas. For example, they are typically prohibited from practising law in the same court or county in which they serve as a judge. Additionally, they may be restricted from having their law partners or associates practise law in the same court to avoid the appearance of impropriety or violations of judicial conduct rules.

Transparency and Disclosure

Part-time judges, especially those running for public election, may be subject to financial disclosure requirements and restrictions on personally soliciting or accepting campaign contributions. They should also be transparent and avoid any actions that may create the perception of impropriety.

In summary, part-time judges must adhere to ethical standards and conduct themselves with integrity, impartiality, and professionalism in both their judicial and personal lives. These standards aim to maintain public trust and confidence in the judiciary.

Part-time judges and representation of clients

Part-time judges are often appointed to handle initial appearances and other routine matters. While there are rules in place to prevent conflicts of interest, the specific rules regarding part-time judges practising law vary across different jurisdictions.

In some places, a part-time judge may represent an accused in a criminal case that has not been considered by another judge of the same court. However, they are generally prohibited from practising law in the court on which they serve or in any related proceedings. This is to avoid any appearance of impropriety and to maintain the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.

For example, in New York, an assistant public defender can represent defendants in a centralized arraignment part when their cousin and co-judge are not presiding. However, they must cease representation after the arraignment if the case is assigned to the town court where their cousin is a part-time judge. This arrangement does not violate the rules of judicial conduct or professional conduct.

On the other hand, a part-time municipal court judge practising law with clients whose cases were considered by other judges of the same court may give the appearance of disregarding the principles of impartiality, interference with judicial duties, exploitation of the judicial position, and frequent transactions with lawyers or persons likely to come before the same court.

Therefore, while it is possible for part-time judges to represent clients in certain situations, it depends on the specific circumstances and the applicable rules and laws in that jurisdiction. Each case must be carefully evaluated to ensure compliance with ethical standards and to avoid any potential conflicts of interest.

Part-time judges and financial dealings

Part-time judges are subject to strict rules regarding their financial dealings. While a part-time municipal court judge may practice law, they may not do so in the court on which they serve or in any proceeding related to it. This restriction also applies to any cases that have been considered by other judges of the same court.

In the United States, the Code of Conduct for judges outlines further financial guidelines. For example, a judge may hold and manage investments and engage in remunerative activity, but they should refrain from financial and business dealings that exploit their judicial position or frequently involve them in transactions with lawyers or persons likely to appear before their court. Judges are also prohibited from personally participating in fundraising activities or soliciting funds for any organization, except from other judges or family members.

Additionally, Canon 4D(1), (2), and (3) of the Code of Conduct outline further financial guidelines for judges. Canon 3 requires the disqualification of a judge in any proceeding where they have a financial interest, regardless of the amount. Canon 4D mandates that judges refrain from financial and business activities that could interfere with their impartial performance of judicial duties, and Canon 4H requires judges to report compensation received from activities outside their judicial role.

In terms of legal practice, a part-time judge's law practice may not include clients whose cases are considered by other judges on the same court, as this would give the appearance of disregarding the principles of impartiality and interference with judicial duties. However, in some jurisdictions, a part-time judge may represent an accused in a criminal case if it does not violate these principles.

Overall, while part-time judges may engage in financial dealings and legal practice, they must adhere to strict guidelines to ensure impartiality, integrity, and the proper performance of their judicial duties.

Part-time judges and personal conduct

Part-time judges are subject to a code of conduct that applies to both their professional and personal behaviour. They must accept that they will be under constant public scrutiny and that their conduct will be subject to restrictions that might be considered burdensome by ordinary citizens.

In the United States, part-time judges are expected to comply with the Code of Conduct for United States Judges. This code includes rules such as refraining from financial and business dealings that could reflect adversely on their impartiality or interfere with their performance of judicial duties. For example, a part-time municipal court judge should not practice law with a lawyer who represents a defendant in a case involving another judge from the same municipal court.

In addition, part-time judges should not engage in or tolerate workplace harassment, abusive behaviour, or retaliation for reporting such conduct. They should also be mindful of recusal considerations, such as when their spouse or intimate partner is involved in a legal proceeding.

While specific rules may vary depending on the jurisdiction, it is generally understood that part-time judges must maintain a certain standard of conduct in their personal lives to avoid any perception of impropriety or conflict of interest. This includes complying with laws and court rules, as well as avoiding any actions that could bring disrepute to the judicial office.

Frequently asked questions