Practicing Law: Who Can And Who Can't

The Advocates Act of 1961 outlines that only advocates enrolled with a State Bar Council are legally permitted to practice law in India. This act imposes ethical obligations on advocates, such as upholding the dignity of the profession, acting in the best interests of their clients, and maintaining confidentiality. Legal advocates play a crucial role in upholding justice, ensuring fair representation, and protecting the rights and interests of individuals within the legal system. While the specific requirements vary across different countries, such as Jersey, Guernsey, Norway, Sweden, and Russia, the common theme is that a legal education, qualifications, and enrollment with a relevant legal body are typically required to practice law.

Can a person who is not an advocate practice law?

In India, only advocates enrolled under the Bar Council can practice law

In India, the Advocates Act of 1961 governs the law on advocates, and it is controlled and implemented by the Bar Council of India. The Bar Council of India is the chief administrative body that manages the entire system and consistency of law in India.

The Advocates Act of 1961 states that advocates enrolled in the Bar Council of India are the only recognised class of persons with the power to practice law in court. This means that only advocates enrolled under the Bar Council have the right to practice law in India. This right is protected at two levels: general protection and specific protection.

General Protection: Article 19(1)(g) of the Indian Constitution protects the right of individuals to practice their choice of profession, occupation, trade, or business.

Specific Protection: Section 30 of the Advocates Act, 1961, states that a person enrolled with the State Bar Councils has the right to practice before any court or tribunal in India, including the Supreme Court. This means that advocates have the right to enter and observe proceedings in any court or tribunal, regardless of whether they are registered with that particular court or tribunal.

In addition to the right to practice, advocates have other rights and duties, such as the right to meet with their clients in jail without any restrictions on the number of visits, the right to professional communication with their clients, which is protected under the Indian Evidence Act, and the right to charge fees for their services. Advocates also have specific duties to their clients, such as the duty to serve their client once they have agreed to take on the case, to provide a valid reason for withdrawing from a case, and to refund any unaccrued fees.

It is important to note that there are restrictions on advocates taking up other employment or business ventures. For example, an advocate shall not be a full-time salaried employee of any person, government, firm, corporation, or concern while continuing to practise law. However, with the consent of the State Bar Council, advocates may accept part-time employment that does not conflict with their professional work and is consistent with the dignity of the profession.

In summary, only advocates enrolled under the Bar Council in India have the right to practice law, and this right is protected and regulated by the Advocates Act of 1961 and the Bar Council Rules.

In Jersey, a law degree and recognised legal qualification are required to practice

In most countries, the practice of law is regulated at the national level. However, the legal profession in the United States is regulated by jurisdiction, with 57 different sets of rules governing the right to practice law. Each state has its own set of rules for admission to the bar, and prospective lawyers must review these rules carefully before undertaking any steps to qualify.

In the state of New Jersey, the Supreme Court has exclusive authority over who is qualified to practice law and the admission procedure. To practice law in New Jersey, one must be admitted to the New Jersey Bar, which has specific requirements that must be met. These requirements include:

• Qualifying for and passing the New Jersey bar examination or applying using a qualifying Uniform Bar Examination (UBE) score, or qualifying and applying for admission by motion.
• Receiving a Certification of Character.
• Passing the Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) with a score of 75 or higher, or passing an approved law school course on ethics with a grade of "C-" or above.
• Taking the Oath of Admission and signing the attorney's roll.

Additionally, candidates must be at least 18 years of age and have received a juris doctor degree or its equivalent from a law school approved by the American Bar Association (ABA). They must also demonstrate good standing in every jurisdiction in which they have been admitted to practice law.

In Nordic countries, non-advocates can represent parties legally

In most countries, only advocates enrolled under the Bar Council are permitted to practice law. This is in accordance with the Advocates Act, 1961, which states that "there shall be only one class of persons entitled to practice the profession of law, namely advocates". However, in Nordic countries, non-advocates can legally represent parties.

The Nordic countries consist of Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Iceland. The legal rights of people in these countries are guaranteed by their constitutions, and certain fundamental principles underlie all of today's Nordic legal systems. These include full equality before the law, guaranteed access to due process and professional representation, and the innocence of the accused until proven guilty. Court procedures in Nordic countries are less formal than in many European countries, but they are strictly followed. An interesting feature of the court system is that hearings and trials in the courts of first instance are often conducted by panels composed of one or more professional judges and several lay judges. These panels, rather than juries, decide the cases.

The Advocates Act, 1961, grants every advocate enrolled under the Bar Council the right to practice law. However, Section 30 of the Act also states that "any court, authority, or person may permit any person, not enrolled as an advocate under this Act, to appear before it or him in any particular case". This provision gives authority to any court or person to permit the appearance of any non-enrolled person in a specific case.

While the right to practice is exclusively given to advocates, it is important to note that this right also comes with certain duties and responsibilities. These are outlined in the Advocates Act, 1961, and are designed to ensure the proper administration of justice.

In Russia, only members of the 'Advokatura' may practice criminal law

In Russia, the legal profession is mostly deregulated. There is no single regulation or regulator that oversees or licenses all lawyers. However, the Advokatura is regulated, and only members of the Advokatura may practice criminal law. This means that only advocates are allowed to represent clients in criminal cases and appear before the Russian Constitutional Court.

The Advokatura is a well-suited structure for the practice of law, but it does not work well for the business of law. Most law firms in Russia choose workarounds such as microholding arrangements or "best friends" informal arrangements. These structures can be cumbersome and lack transparency. The requirement to work in one of the statute-mandated structures is a barrier for in-house lawyers who want to become "licensed" in Russia.

To become a member of the Advokatura, one must have a higher legal education and two years of experience in legal work after graduation or complete a training program in a law firm. An examination, which includes both written and oral components, is administered by the qualifications commission of the regional advocate's chamber for admission to the Advokatura. The written exam covers issues of professional conduct and responsibility, while the oral exam requires candidates to demonstrate their knowledge in various bodies of law and solve real-life legal tasks.

Advocates in Russia have a code of ethics and are regulated by the Federal Bar Association. They are the only ones who get legal professional privilege. While there is no requirement for clients to engage an advocate/bar member for legal representation in non-criminal cases, advocates are the only recognized class of persons with the power to practice law in criminal courts. This 'dualism' in professional legal services has been challenged by reform initiatives led by the Federal Ministry of Justice.

In Guernsey, a law degree and English/French qualification are required to practice

In most countries, a person who is not an advocate cannot practice law.. The right to practice law is usually exclusive to advocates enrolled under the Bar Council as per the Advocates Act, 1961.

In Guernsey, the law is influenced by Norman customary law, English common law, French law, and statute law enacted by the States of Guernsey. The unique legal history of Guernsey, with its links to the Duchy of Normandy, means that lawyers who want to become advocates at the Royal Court must study French law and old Norman law for three months in Caen, France. This tradition is part of an agreement between Caen University and the Guernsey Bar signed in 1956 but dates back to the Channel Islands' Norman past. While neighbouring Jersey removed this requirement for its advocates in the 1990s, Guernsey lawyers must still travel to France for this obligatory part of their legal education.

Queen Mary University of London offers a four-year English and French Law degree that is recognised as a qualifying law degree in both England and Wales, as well as France. This dual degree provides students with the opportunity to study the law of two distinct judicial traditions: common law and civil law. All third and fourth-year modules are taught in French, and students who do not meet the required language level must take compulsory French language classes. Upon completion of this degree, graduates will have access to legal professions in both countries and international organisations.

Therefore, to practice law in Guernsey, a law degree and proficiency in English and French are required. The specific tradition of studying French law and old Norman law in France is an essential part of the legal qualification process in Guernsey, reflecting the unique blend of legal influences in the region.

Frequently asked questions