Executive Power: Can A President Sidestep Congress?

The US Constitution establishes a rigorous process for enacting laws, requiring the approval of both chambers of Congress and the President. However, the question of whether a President can bypass Congress to pass a law has been a subject of debate and scrutiny. While the President cannot directly pass a law without Congress, they possess certain powers, such as issuing executive orders, that can shape policy and exert influence within the boundaries set by Congress. These executive actions are often subject to legislative review and can be challenged by the courts if deemed to exceed the Executive Branch's authority.

Executive orders

The US President can issue executive orders, which are signed, written, and published directives that manage the operations of the federal government. Executive orders are not legislation and do not require approval from Congress. They are one of the most common "presidential" documents, with every American president since George Washington issuing at least one, totalling more than 13,700 as of 2023.

The process of issuing an executive order typically begins with an introduction that legitimises the order and may include a legal rationale from the President. The body of the order contains the specific directives, which are grouped into sections and subsections. The order is then signed by the President, followed by a "White House" notation and the date of issuance.

While executive orders do not require congressional approval, they are subject to legal review. Congress can also pass legislation that may make it difficult or impossible to carry out the order, such as by removing funding. Additionally, the courts can overturn executive orders if they are deemed to exceed the Executive Branch's authority.

Vetoes

The President of the United States has the power to veto federal legislation passed by the United States Congress. This power was conferred by the 1789 Constitution and allows the President to prevent a bill from becoming law. The veto was constructed with limits, such as the ability of Congress to override a veto with a two-thirds majority in both chambers. The President's objections to the bill must be stated in writing and Congress is required to consider them.

The veto process begins when a bill, passed by both houses of Congress, is presented to the President. The President then has ten days, excluding Sundays, to approve or veto the bill. If the President approves, they sign the bill into law. If the President does not approve, they may veto it by returning the unsigned bill, along with their objections, to the chamber in which it originated. This is known as a direct veto.

If the President does not sign the bill and Congress adjourns within the ten-day review period, it is considered a "pocket veto" and the bill does not become law. The last pocket veto was used by President Bill Clinton in December 2000.

A successful override of a presidential veto is rare. The first occurred on March 3, 1845, during the presidency of John Tyler.

The threat of a veto is often enough to ward off undesirable legislation. This is known as "veto signaling". One official way for the President to signal a veto is by using a Statement of Administration Policy.

Regulatory agencies

The president has a degree of influence over regulatory agencies, which can be used to implement policy without direct approval from Congress. However, regulatory agencies are still subject to legislative review and can be challenged by Congress if they are deemed to be overstepping their boundaries.

Previous administrations have allowed "independent regulatory agencies" to operate with minimal presidential supervision. These agencies have substantial executive authority and can promulgate significant regulations without direct review by the president. This lack of oversight can result in a lack of accountability to the American people and hinder the coherent execution of federal law.

To address this, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) is responsible for providing guidance to regulatory agencies and ensuring their actions align with the president's policies and priorities. The OMB director establishes performance standards and periodically reports on the agencies' performance in attaining these standards.

Additionally, independent regulatory agency chairmen are required to consult with the OMB, the White House Domestic Policy Council, and the White House National Economic Council to ensure their policies are coordinated with the executive branch. These chairmen are also responsible for submitting agency strategic plans to the OMB for clearance.

Presidential judgment

The President's judgment comes into play when a bill is presented to them after being agreed upon by both chambers of Congress. The President has the option to sign the bill into law within ten days, excluding Sundays. Alternatively, they may choose to veto the bill, returning it to the originating congressional chamber. This veto can be overridden if two-thirds of both chambers vote in favor of doing so, but this is a rare occurrence.

One way the President can exert judgment and influence is through executive orders. These are written and signed directives issued by the President to manage the operations of the federal government. Executive orders do not require approval from Congress, and they carry the force of law. They are often used to interpret and enforce existing laws or to direct executive branch agencies on specific actions. However, Congress can pass legislation that may hinder or prevent the execution of such orders.

The President's judgment also extends to the interpretation of laws. For example, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defined CO2 as a pollutant under the Clean Air Act, an action that fell within the President's regulatory powers. While this interpretation was independent of Congress, it was still subject to legislative review, and the courts could overrule it if deemed to exceed the Executive Branch's authority.

In conclusion, while the President cannot bypass Congress to pass a law, they possess significant judgment and influence within the legislative process. This includes the power to sign or veto bills, issue executive orders, and interpret laws through regulatory agencies. The President's actions ultimately shape the direction of legislation and govern the operations of the federal government.

Congressional override

In the United States, laws are made through a legislative process involving both Congress and the President. While the President cannot bypass Congress to pass a law, there are mechanisms by which they can exert influence and take action independently.

The legislative process typically involves both chambers of Congress agreeing to a bill, which is then presented to the President. The President has the option to sign the bill, veto it, or take no action. If the President signs the bill, it becomes law. If they choose to veto, the bill is returned to Congress, which can then attempt to override the veto. A successful override requires a two-thirds majority vote in both chambers of Congress, demonstrating the importance of congressional support in passing legislation.

One way the President can exert influence without directly bypassing Congress is through their power of interpretation and enforcement. Congress may pass a broad law, such as a directive to federal agencies, which the President then interprets and enforces within the boundaries set by Congress. This allows the President some flexibility in implementing the law according to their judgment.

Additionally, the President can issue executive orders, which are written directives that manage the operations of the federal government. Executive orders do not require congressional approval and are considered separate from legislation. They are often used to direct federal agencies and officials and can have the force of law. However, Congress can pass legislation that may hinder or prevent the carrying out of an executive order, such as by removing funding.

In conclusion, while the President cannot unilaterally pass a law without congressional support, they possess tools to influence policy-making and implementation. These include the power to interpret and enforce laws, as well as the ability to issue executive orders. Ultimately, a balance of power exists between the President and Congress, with checks and balances in place to prevent either branch from exerting absolute authority.

Frequently asked questions