How Presidents Influence Lawmaking

The President of the United States has a lot of influence over the creation of new laws. While they cannot directly propose a law, they can propose a bill and send Congress a presidential message urging its enactment. The President can also work with members of Congress to encourage them to create a bill based on certain ideas, and they can publicly lobby for or against legislation. The President can also make an executive order, which bypasses Congress but must conform to specific guidelines. Ultimately, it is the President's decision whether a bill becomes a law, as they can veto any bill passed by Congress.

The president can propose a bill

The President can also propose a bill by championing it and actively campaigning for one to be written, insisting on specific language. The President can also propose a bill by working with members of Congress to encourage them to create a bill based on certain ideas, concepts, and provisions. The President can also propose a bill by making an executive order, which bypasses Congress but must conform to specific guidelines.

The president can't introduce a bill

While the US president can propose a bill, they cannot introduce it. The president can send Congress a message urging its enactment into law, but only an elected member of Congress can place a bill in "the hopper" for formal consideration. The president can, however, work with members of Congress to encourage them to create a bill based on certain ideas, concepts, and provisions.

The idea for a bill can come from a sitting member of the US Senate or House of Representatives or be proposed during their election campaign. Bills can also be petitioned by people or citizen groups who recommend a new or amended law to a member of Congress that represents them. Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned to a committee whose members will research, discuss, and make changes to the bill. The bill is then put before that chamber to be voted on. If the bill passes one body of Congress, it goes to the other body to go through a similar process of research, discussion, changes, and voting.

The president can propose legislation and publicly lobby for (or against) it. They can also make an executive order that bypasses Congress but must conform to specific guidelines. The president can also draft legislation and send it to Congress with a letter or other explanatory material discussing the reasons for submitting it. The House may then order that the bill and its accompanying material be printed as an official House Document.

The president usually has a lot to do with the bills that are passed during their administration, even if they do not directly write them. They can champion a bill and actively campaign for one to be written, and even insist on it having specific language. For example, the Affordable Care Act is known as ObamaCare.

The president can veto a bill

While the president does not have the power to formally propose a law, they do have a significant role in the legislative process. One of the most important powers the president holds in this process is the ability to veto a bill. The president can use their veto power to prevent a bill passed by Congress from becoming law. This means that the president can refuse to approve a bill and block it from being enacted.

The president's veto power is not absolute, however. Congress can override a presidential veto and allow the bill to become law. To do this, two-thirds of both chambers of Congress must vote to override the veto. This demonstrates the system of checks and balances in the US legislative process, where the president can check Congress's power to pass laws, but Congress can also check the president's power to block them.

If the president chooses to veto a bill, they are constitutionally required to state their objections in writing, and Congress must consider these objections. The president usually issues a veto statement or message explaining their reasons for vetoing the bill when returning it to Congress. This statement does not have any legal precedential value, but it can contribute to the American constitutional tradition and influence the executive branch's interpretation of the law.

It is important to note that there are different types of vetoes. A regular veto occurs when the president returns a bill to Congress unsigned within ten days, excluding Sundays, while Congress is still in session. Congress can then attempt to override the veto. On the other hand, a pocket veto occurs when the president does not sign the bill and Congress adjourns before the ten-day period has passed. In this case, the bill is vetoed by default, and it cannot be overridden by Congress.

The president can sign a bill into law

The president plays a crucial role in the legislative process, and they have the power to sign a bill into law. While the president does not draft the bill, they can propose legislation and work closely with members of Congress to encourage and influence the creation of a bill based on their ideas and concepts. The president can even send Congress a presidential message urging the enactment of a bill into law. This proposal can be in the form of a draft of the proposed bill transmitted to the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the President of the Senate. The president can also include a letter or other explanatory materials discussing the reasons for submitting the legislation.

Once a bill is introduced in Congress, it goes through a process of consideration and voting in both the House and the Senate. If a bill passes both chambers of Congress, it is then presented to the president for approval. At this stage, the president has the authority to approve the bill and sign it into law. The president's signature is essential for a bill to become a law, unless Congress has adjourned sine die, in which case the bill can become law without the president's signature.

The president also has the power to veto a bill, which means refusing to approve it. However, Congress can override a presidential veto with a two-thirds vote in both chambers, and the bill will then become a law. On the other hand, if the president does not sign off on a bill and Congress adjourns before returning it with objections, the bill is considered pocket vetoed and cannot be overridden by Congress.

In conclusion, while the president may not formally introduce a bill, they can propose and influence legislation and ultimately sign a bill into law. This power to approve or veto bills gives the president significant influence over the legislative process and the shape of US law.

The president can't be forced to implement a law

While a president can propose a law, they are not required to implement any law. The president has a duty to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed", according to the Constitution's Take Care Clause. This clause grants the president broad enforcement authority. However, it also limits that power by mandating that the executive faithfully execute the laws of Congress without disregarding them.

The president has a wide range of discretion in how to enforce laws, and it is impossible to enforce every federal law against every offender. As a result, presidents may consider policy priorities when deciding how to enforce laws. For example, the president can send Congress a message urging the enactment of a bill into law but cannot introduce it. They can also choose not to prosecute federal laws in certain states, such as in the case of federal marijuana possession laws in states where marijuana has been decriminalized.

However, serious questions arise when presidents use their enforcement power to invalidate or rewrite statutes with which they disagree. In such cases, it is unclear whether the president is meeting their "take care" obligations. While Congress can counter by refusing to pass legislation the president favours or by cutting funding to executive agencies, it would be impossible to force the president to enforce a particular category of cases. Ultimately, the president cannot be forced to implement a law, but their power is limited by the Constitution and the content of the laws they enforce.

Frequently asked questions