Confession Seal: Can Priests Legally Break It?

The Catholic Church forbids priests from breaking the Seal of Confession, also known as the Seal of the Confessional or the Sacramental Seal, under any circumstances. The Code of Canon Law states that the sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent by word or deed and for any reason. However, there have been legal challenges and proposed legislation in some countries, such as the United States and Australia, that would require priests to report information related to child abuse or neglect confessed in the confessional. These proposals have sparked debates between those who prioritize the protection of children and those who uphold the sacredness of the Seal of Confession.

What is the Seal of Confession?

In the Catholic Church, the Seal of Confession, also known as the Seal of the Confessional or the Sacramental Seal, is the absolute duty of priests or anyone who happens to hear a confession not to disclose anything that they learn from penitents during the course of the Sacrament of Penance (confession). The seal of confession is considered sacred by the Church and is protected by the rule of evidence of confessional privilege, which forbids judicial inquiry into communications made under the seal of confession. According to Roman Catholic canon law, "The sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent in words or in any manner and for any reason." This means that priests cannot break the seal to save their own lives, to protect their good name, to save the life of another, to aid the course of justice, or to avert a public calamity. They cannot be compelled by law to disclose a person's confession or be bound by any oath they take, such as a witness in a court trial.

The seal of confession is considered so sacred that even those who overhear a confession are bound by the seal. In addition, a priest cannot reveal the contents of a confession either directly or indirectly, by some sign, suggestion, or action. The punishment for breaking the seal of confession is severe and includes excommunication, which is imposed by the Apostolic See, and other penalties according to the gravity of the offence. The Church's position on the seal of confession is supported by the free exercise of religion clause, which has been recognized as a basic right in the United States.

There are limited cases where portions of a confession may be revealed to others, but always with the penitent's permission and without revealing their identity. For example, in the case of more serious offenses, such as excommunicable offenses, permission must be obtained from the Holy See to grant absolution. In such cases, the priest hearing the confession asks the penitent's permission to write a petition to the bishop or the Apostolic Penitentiary, using pseudonyms and containing only the necessary information.

The seal of confession has been a topic of debate, with some arguing that it should be broken in certain circumstances, such as when a priest learns of child sexual abuse during confession. However, the Catholic Church maintains that the seal of confession must never be broken, even in cases of grave criminality. The Church's position on this matter is that "children would be less safe if mandatory reporting of confessions was required" and that lifting the ban on breaking the seal would be "contrary to our faith and inimical to religious liberty."

When can a priest reveal a confession?

The Catholic Church's stance on the matter is clear: the Seal of the Confessional must never be broken under any circumstances, even in cases of grave criminality. Canon 983.1 of the Code of Canon Law states: "The sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent by words or in any manner and for any reason." This means that a priest cannot break the seal to save his own life, to protect his reputation, to refute a false accusation, to save the life of another, to aid the course of justice (such as reporting a crime), or to prevent a public calamity.

However, there are differing opinions among Catholics. Some believe that the seal is absolute and must never be broken, regardless of the severity of the matters learned during confession or the pressure exerted by lawmakers. On the other hand, others argue for some flexibility, suggesting that if a penitent expresses the intention to harm or kill someone, a priest may be able to warn the potential victim without disclosing the source of the information.

In certain situations, a priest may need to discuss a confession with another priest or a superior without revealing the identity of the penitent. This is particularly relevant in cases of grievous sins, where permission from a superior is required for absolution. In these instances, the priest hearing the confession will ask the penitent's permission to write a petition, using pseudonyms and minimal information, to the bishop or the Apostolic Penitentiary, who is delegated by the Pope to handle such requests.

It is worth noting that not all jurisdictions provide legal protection for the seal of confession. For example, in Australia, a priest may be legally compelled to break the seal in certain circumstances, facing jail time if they refuse to comply. Similarly, in 2014, the Louisiana Supreme Court ruled that a priest could be ordered to testify about information disclosed during confession in a sexual abuse case, risking excommunication or contempt of court.

Despite these legal complexities, the Catholic Church maintains that the seal of confession is sacred, and priests are expected to uphold absolute secrecy regarding any confessions they hear.

Can a priest be compelled to testify about a confession?

The Catholic Church forbids breaking the Seal of Confession, which is the absolute duty of priests or anyone who happens to hear a confession not to disclose anything that they learn from penitents during the Sacrament of Penance (confession). Canon 983.1 of the Code of Canon Law states that "the sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent by word or in any manner and for any reason". This means that a priest cannot break the seal to save his own life, to protect his good name, to save the life of another, to aid the course of justice, or to avert a public calamity.

In the United States, there is a priest-penitent privilege that protects priests from being compelled to testify about a confession. This privilege was first recognised in the case of People v. Philips in 1813, which stated that confessions of Irish Catholic refugees could not be used as testimony in United States courts as they were given confidentially. Every state now has a statute protecting this privilege, although there are some states that allow a priest to waive this right, particularly after confessions addressing abuse or similarly heinous crimes. Outside of cases involving the use of a confession, priests are permitted to testify in court.

In other countries, the law varies. In Canada, for example, religious communications are not afforded an automatic class privilege (except in Newfoundland and Quebec), and are instead subject to an admissibility test, which requires that the contents of the communication be disclosed to the court. In Germany, the Code of Criminal Procedure includes a right to refuse testimony on professional grounds, which applies to priests.

In Australia, the Catholic Church has rejected a government push to force priests to report accusations of child sexual abuse heard during confession, stating that "children would be less safe if mandatory reporting of confessions was required". The Church's response has been criticised, with allegations that the Church may be protecting criminals in its ranks.

While the Catholic Church forbids breaking the Seal of Confession, there are limited cases where portions of a confession may be revealed to others with the penitent's permission, but never by revealing the penitent's identity. This is the case, for example, with more serious offences, where permission to grant absolution must be obtained from the Holy See. In these cases, the priest may write a petition to the bishop or the Apostolic Penitentiary, using pseudonyms and containing minimal information.

What happens if a priest violates the seal of confession?

The Catholic Church considers the Seal of Confession, also known as the Seal of the Confessional or the Sacramental Seal, to be absolute. According to Roman Catholic canon law, it is forbidden for a priest to break the seal of confession under any circumstances, and they are under no obligation to report confidential information heard during a sacramental confession. The Code of Canon Law states:

> The sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent in words or in any manner and for any reason.

However, there may be conflict between the obligation of confidentiality of confession and civil law. For example, in 2014, the Louisiana Supreme Court ruled that a priest could be compelled to testify about what he was told in the confessional regarding a sexual abuse case, leaving the priest at risk of excommunication if he confirmed that a confession took place, or jail for contempt of court if he refused to testify.

The punishment for breaking the seal of confession is determined by the severity of the violation. A priest who directly violates the seal of confession incurs automatic excommunication. If the violation is indirect, the priest is punished according to the gravity of the offence.

In addition, anyone who overhears a confession, such as an interpreter, is also bound by the seal and can be punished for violating it.

What is the history of the Seal of Confession?

The Seal of Confession, also known as the Seal of the Confessional or the Sacramental Seal, is a Christian doctrine that forbids priests from disclosing any information they learn from a penitent during confession. This doctrine is recognised by several Christian denominations, including the Catholic Church.

The history of the Seal of Confession dates back to the early Church, when the Sacrament of Reconciliation was administered communally. During this time, grave sinners would confess their sins publicly and perform acts of penance to seek forgiveness. However, by the end of the 6th century, St. Columban and his fellow missionary monks popularized the practice of private penance. As private confession became the norm across Christendom, the privileged secrecy of sacramental conversations became formalized.

Canon 21 of the Fourth Council of the Lateran in 1215, binding on the whole church, laid down the obligation of secrecy for priests hearing confessions. The canon stated that priests must absolutely refrain from betraying the sinner "by word or sign or by any manner whatever in any way". The 15th-century English canonist William Lyndwood also spoke of two reasons why a priest must keep confessions secret: firstly, due to the sacrament, and secondly, because it is of the essence of the sacrament to maintain secrecy.

Over the centuries, powerful forces have attempted to break the Seal of Confession, but priests have steadfastly protected it, even under suspicion and ridicule. In modern times, there have been legal challenges and debates surrounding the Seal of Confession, with state legislatures and trial court judges pressuring priests to disclose information, particularly in cases of clergy sexual abuse. However, these attempts have been resisted, with some countries and states enacting laws and constitutional arguments to protect the confidentiality of the confessional as a matter of religious freedom.

The Seal of Confession is considered a sacred trust between the priest and the penitent, and any violation of this trust is met with severe penalties within the Church, including excommunication. The Catechism of the Catholic Church emphasizes the delicacy and importance of the Sacrament of Confession, stating that priests are bound under very severe penalties to maintain absolute secrecy regarding the sins confessed to them.

Frequently asked questions