Company Policies: Above Or Below The Law?

Company policies are a set of guidelines that govern the internal workings of an organization, outlining expected employee behaviour and conduct. While these policies are unique to each company, they must operate within the bounds of the law. This is where the complex relationship between company policy and law comes into play. Laws regulate broader aspects of business operations, interactions with entities like consumers and government bodies, and industry-specific regulations. Organizations must adhere to stringent federal, state, and local laws that oversee various aspects, from equality to health and safety. This raises the question: can a private company's policies ever go against the law?

Company policies are internal guidelines, while laws regulate broader aspects of business operations and interactions with other entities

Company policies are a set of internal guidelines that govern the day-to-day operations of a business, including employee conduct, interactions, and the company's vision and goals. They are often outlined in an employee handbook and can cover areas such as dress code, tobacco use, paid time off, and code of conduct. These policies are unique to each company and reflect its culture and values. On the other hand, laws are external regulations that apply broadly to businesses and their interactions with other entities, including consumers, government bodies, and other businesses. These laws ensure fairness, safety, and equity in various aspects of business operations.

While company policies provide internal guidelines, laws establish mandatory requirements that companies must adhere to. Federal, state, and local laws govern various aspects of organisations, from equality to health and safety. Compliance with these laws is critical, as non-compliance can result in severe penalties and legal repercussions. For example, the Fair Labour Standards Act mandates that companies establish policies adhering to the federal minimum wage. Similarly, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) safeguards employee health data, requiring companies to have policies protecting this information.

Company policies and laws work together to ensure the smooth functioning of a business. While policies guide employees' day-to-day actions, they must also comply with relevant laws to avoid legal issues. For instance, a company's data privacy policy must respect legal mandates while remaining practical for daily operations. Organisations should regularly review and update their policies to maintain alignment with changing laws and regulations. Understanding the interplay between company policies and laws is crucial for effective business operations.

It is important to note that company policies cannot contradict or go against the law. While policies may go beyond legal requirements, they cannot violate legal boundaries. For example, a company policy that enforces a tobacco-free workplace goes beyond legal requirements but does not contravene any laws. Organisations must ensure their policies are reasonable, well-advertised, and consistently enforced to be enforceable and to maintain a positive work environment.

In conclusion, company policies serve as internal guidelines that shape the conduct and interactions of employees within a company's unique culture and values. Laws, on the other hand, regulate broader aspects of business operations and interactions with external entities, ensuring fairness and compliance across industries. Organisations must navigate the complex relationship between company policies and laws to maintain legal compliance and a well-functioning workplace.

Companies must be aware of universal laws, industry-specific laws, and regional differences

Company policies are bound by universal laws, industry-specific laws, and regional differences, and it is crucial for companies to be aware of these nuances to ensure legal compliance and avoid repercussions. While companies are not free to operate without considering legal boundaries, their internal policies may offer more rights to employees than the law requires. For instance, a company handbook may state that employees will always get two warnings before termination, which is not mandated by law, but if an employee is fired without warning, they may be able to file a wrongful termination lawsuit based on the company handbook.

Universal laws that companies must adhere to include those that protect intellectual property, such as copyrights, patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. These laws are especially important in the digital age, where the mass dissemination of consumer data has led to data protection laws worldwide. Companies must also be aware of universal laws that govern contracts between companies and with customers or suppliers, as these legally binding agreements must be carefully scrutinized to ensure all parties understand their rights and obligations.

Industry-specific laws vary from environmental protection regulations for automotive companies to air toxicity standards for utility providers. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) also ensures that policies related to workplace harassment and discrimination are followed, prohibiting discrimination based on race, gender, age, religion, and disability.

Regional differences are another important aspect of compliance, with companies needing to be aware of local, state, and federal laws. For example, payroll taxes and contributions vary drastically worldwide, with some countries managing employment taxes only at the federal level, while others implement taxes at regional and local levels. Companies must also be aware of sanctions that may restrict or forbid trade with certain markets and regions, such as Iran and North Korea.

Company policies can be enforceable, even if they are unwritten

Company policies are not always written down, and they don't need to be written down to be enforceable. However, it is important to note that company policies cannot go against the law. There are federal, state, and local regulations that govern the workplace, and companies must comply with these regulations. For example, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act prohibits discrimination based on age, and the Americans with Disabilities Act supports the rights of disabled people at work. These policies are required by law and are not just internal guidelines but legal mandates to ensure fairness, safety, and equity in the workplace.

While unwritten policies can be enforceable, it is generally recommended that companies document their policies clearly to avoid any confusion or legal issues. An employee can claim they were unaware of an unwritten policy, and without a paper trail, it can be challenging to prove otherwise. Additionally, having written policies allows for consistent enforcement and ensures that all employees are aware of the expectations and consequences.

In some cases, unwritten policies may be considered part of a contract if they are referenced within it. For example, if an employer mentions certain documents or policies during the hiring process, those unwritten policies may be considered binding. However, it is always advisable to review all relevant documents and seek clarification on any unclear policies before assuming they are not enforceable.

Furthermore, there are situations where an employer can enforce policies that have never been formally established. For instance, in the case of "at-will employment," employers can change the terms and conditions of employment, including policies, at any time and for any reason, as long as it does not constitute harassment or discrimination.

Overall, while company policies can be enforceable even if they are unwritten, it is essential to consider the specific circumstances, applicable laws, and potential consequences for both employers and employees. Clear and written policies are generally the best practice to ensure fairness and consistency in the workplace.

Employers must give employees unequivocal notice of a policy before it becomes effective

While there is no legal requirement for company policies to be written, employers must give employees unequivocal notice of a policy before it can become effective. This means that employees must be made aware of any new policies or changes to existing ones before they are implemented. Most companies place their policies in handbooks or some other type of written document so that they can prove that employees were given notice of the policies. This is important because policies control employees' behavior at work, and employers can enforce them, even taking disciplinary action or terminating employment if they are violated.

When an employer notifies an employee of changes to the terms of their employment, the employee is deemed to have accepted the new terms if they continue working with knowledge of the changes. This is the case even if the employee handbook is not provided as part of the contract. Therefore, it is important for employees to review all documents related to their employment, including any handbooks or policies referenced in the contract.

Employers should also be aware that while policies that go beyond what is required by law are not illegal, they can still be enforced as if they were. For example, if an employer includes a policy in their handbook stating that employees will always receive two warnings before being terminated, they can be sued for wrongful termination if they then fire an employee without warning.

In addition to company policies, there are also federal, state, and local laws that govern the workplace and with which companies are legally required to comply. These laws cover areas such as minimum wage, non-discrimination, health and safety, and employee privacy.

Company policies must be reasonable, unambiguous, well-advertised, and consistently enforced

Company policies are an essential part of any organisation, as they outline expectations for employee behaviour and provide a framework for decision-making at all levels. They are also a way to ensure compliance with federal laws and regulations, protecting the company from legal risks and fostering a positive workplace culture.

While companies have the right to set ethical, professional, and operational standards, their policies must be reasonable, unambiguous, well-advertised, and consistently enforced. This means that employees must be made aware of the policies and any consequences for breaching them. This can be done through training sessions, employee handbooks, and regular communication from managers and HR professionals.

To ensure consistent enforcement, it is important to train supervisors and managers to lead by example and follow the policies themselves. A well-documented strategy for policy enforcement is also key, making all policies easily accessible to employees and explaining why compliance is important. For example, if a company has a policy of always giving two warnings before terminating an employee, they must uphold this standard, or face the possibility of a wrongful termination lawsuit.

Additionally, when implementing new policies that constitute a substantial change, employers should either provide something of value in exchange for the employee's adherence or give advance reasonable notice of the policy coming into effect. This ensures that employees are not blindsided by new rules and gives them time to adjust or seek further clarification.

Frequently asked questions