Real Estate Agents: Can They Practice Law?

Real estate agents are frequently limited in their work capacity and are not allowed to engage in the unauthorized practice of law. While they can assist clients with various common issues concerning the sale or purchase of a home, they should never provide legal advice concerning a legal issue or complication. If a real estate agent engages in unlawful activities, they will face legal consequences, such as the loss of their professional license and possible lawsuits initiated by clients. On the other hand, lawyers can become real estate agents, but they must be cautious about providing legal advice to clients while acting as a real estate agent, as this could lead to a conflict of interest.

Real estate agents and legal liability

Real estate agents are licensed professionals authorized to conduct real estate business in specific states. They are educated in real estate matters and must pass a state board exam to practice. However, their work capacity is limited, and they may require confirmation from a supervising broker for more important transaction decisions.

Real estate agents can become legally liable if they breach a duty owed to their clients, such as through a breach of contract or negligence. This can result in civil lawsuits initiated by the harmed party to recover damages. Additionally, real estate agents must refrain from the unauthorized practice of law, which includes providing legal advice or drafting legal documents. Engaging in such activities can lead to legal consequences, including the loss of professional licensure and lawsuits for fraud and forgery.

The Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of Realtors address the unauthorized practice of law by realtors. It states that practicing law without a license is prohibited. Real estate agents should advise their clients to seek legal counsel if there is any question of whether an action may constitute the unauthorized practice of law.

To avoid liability, real estate agents must exercise diligence and understand their legal and professional responsibilities. They should be aware of industry practices, customs, and statutory or regulatory standards to ensure their conduct meets the standard of care expected of a reasonably careful agent in the same circumstances. By being diligent and knowledgeable, agents can mitigate the risk of legal liability in their work.

It is worth noting that lawyers can also be real estate agents, but they must maintain professional boundaries between their legal and real estate practices. They must avoid providing legal advice to clients seeking real estate services and vice versa to prevent conflicts of interest. Transparency with clients about potential risks and benefits is essential, and financial considerations of dual practice should be carefully addressed.

Unauthorized practice of law

The Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of Realtors clearly prohibits realtors from practicing law without a license. Real estate agents are typically limited to using pre-drafted contracts approved and circulated by the state's Association of Realtors. They are not allowed to draft legal documents or provide legal advice to their clients. This includes expressing legal opinions, guiding clients on the effects of a contract, assisting in initiating civil lawsuits, or representing a client before a tribunal or in any administrative or real estate proceeding.

If a real estate agent engages in the unauthorized practice of law, they may face legal consequences, including the loss of their professional license and the possibility of being banned from regaining their license. They may also face lawsuits initiated by clients for fraud and forgery. Real estate agents must be cautious and advise their clients to seek legal counsel from a licensed attorney if there is any question of unauthorized practice of law.

On the other hand, lawyers who choose to become real estate agents must also be mindful of the potential pitfalls of dual practice. They must maintain clear professional boundaries between their legal and real estate roles and avoid providing legal advice to clients seeking real estate services. Lawyers who act as real estate agents should be transparent about their dual roles and ensure they do not use their legal expertise to promote their real estate business or vice versa.

While some federal administrative agencies, such as the Social Security Administration, allow non-lawyers to represent individuals in certain cases, it is important to verify the specific rules and regulations of each agency. Unauthorized practice of law can have significant consequences, and individuals should always seek the advice of a licensed attorney to ensure they are receiving accurate and lawful guidance.

Legal advice from agents

Real estate agents are not allowed to engage in the unauthorized practice of law. This means that they cannot provide legal advice or offer opinions on the legal effect of a contract or any party's actions. They are also prohibited from drafting legal documents or engaging in any activities that may be considered the unauthorized practice of law, such as assisting clients in initiating a civil lawsuit or representing a client before a tribunal. If a real estate agent provides legal advice, they may face legal consequences, including the loss of their professional license and possible lawsuits initiated by clients.

It is important to note that the law and professional organizations do not allow professionals to exceed the scope of their training and licensing. The Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of Realtors address the unauthorized practice of law, stating that realtors practicing law without a license is prohibited. Real estate agents should advise their clients to seek legal counsel from a licensed attorney if there is any question of whether an action may constitute the unauthorized practice of law.

However, it is essential to be aware of the differences in state laws regarding this issue. While most states prohibit non-lawyers from drafting contracts, some states, like Minnesota, Colorado, and Utah, have specific statutes governing what real estate professionals can and cannot do during transactions. In other states, the laws may be more vague, creating a grey area. For example, a broker in New York was disciplined for inserting terms of a purchase money mortgage into a sales agreement, while a real estate professional in Ohio was accused of unauthorized practice after answering a landowner's questions about lease terms and legal rights.

Additionally, lawyers who are also real estate agents must maintain professional boundaries between their legal practice and real estate brokerage. They must be transparent about their dual practice, avoid conflicts of interest, and ensure they do not provide legal advice to clients seeking real estate services or vice versa. By following ethical considerations and best practices, they can represent their clients honestly and fairly while providing valuable services in both roles.

Agents and lawsuits

Real estate agents are not allowed to engage in the unauthorized practice of law. The Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of Realtors (NAR) addresses the unauthorized practice of law. The NAR has approximately 1.5 million members in America.

The Code states that realtors practicing law without a license are committing the unauthorized practice of law. The following are some activities that are considered to be the unauthorized practice of law by real estate agents:

• Providing legal advice to clients or offering an opinion on the legal effect of a contract or any party's actions
• Drafting legal documents
• Preparing or expressing any sort of legal opinion, such as guiding the effect of a contract
• Assisting their clients in initiating a civil lawsuit
• Representing a client before any tribunal or in an administrative or other real estate proceeding
• Negotiating legal rights or responsibilities of a client in a contract or other setting

If a real estate agent engages in any unlawful activity, they will face legal consequences. Examples of legal consequences for the unauthorized practice of law by a real estate agent include:

• The loss of their professional license and a possible ban from regaining their license in the state
• Lawsuits initiated by clients for fraud and forgery

In addition to the unauthorized practice of law, real estate agents may be subject to other liabilities. Real estate agent liability refers to instances in which an agent has violated either the law or real estate professional conduct guidelines, such as by providing real estate legal advice. When a legal issue arises, it is difficult to determine which parties are liable to a seller or buyer client.

In March 2024, the NAR agreed to pay $418 million and change its rules to settle lawsuits claiming homeowners were unfairly forced to pay inflated agent commissions. The NAR agreed to do away with policies that helped set agent commissions, moving to resolve lawsuits that claimed the rules forced people to pay inflated costs to sell their homes. The NAR was also facing multiple lawsuits over the way agent commissions are set.

Lawyers as real estate agents

Lawyers can become licensed as real estate agents, combining their legal expertise with the skills required in real estate to navigate complex transactions and become successful agents. While it is possible, there are specific requirements and challenges to be aware of.

Firstly, it is important to note that the licensing process varies from state to state, and some states may prohibit lawyers from acting as real estate agents. Therefore, lawyers must check the laws and regulations in their state before pursuing this career path. In most states, lawyers must complete the same education and training as other real estate professionals, including passing a licensing exam and continuing education courses. Some states may also require lawyers to have prior experience in the real estate industry.

Lawyers who become real estate agents can offer their clients a unique perspective and a deeper understanding of the legal and financial aspects of real estate transactions. They can provide legal advice and representation, ensuring that contracts are legally binding and protecting their client's interests. This combination of skills can be highly beneficial to clients, but it is important to be aware of potential conflicts of interest. For example, a lawyer-agent may face ethical breaches if they fail to disclose their dual role or prioritize their interests over their clients'. Additionally, malpractice insurance may not cover legal advice given while engaged as a broker.

Despite the challenges, combining the roles of a lawyer and a real estate agent can be advantageous for those with the energy and charisma to take on two demanding roles. It allows lawyers to offer a broader range of services and can provide new opportunities for career development and increased earnings. For example, a lawyer with a real estate license can draft and review real estate contracts, ensuring that their client's transactions are legally sound.

Frequently asked questions