Lease Agreements: State Law Vs Rental Lease, Who Wins?

The relationship between rental leases and state law is a complex one, with landlords and tenants needing to be aware of their rights and responsibilities. While leases can be more easily changed, they cannot supersede state law, and landlords must be careful not to include provisions that may be illegal. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law, such as the right to contact the police or emergency services, or to lawfully possess a firearm. With specific reference to California, a rental contract cannot override the statute of limitations that California law establishes.

A lease cannot contradict the law

Leases are legal contracts, and many people assume that the clauses in a lease are non-negotiable and legal according to federal, state, and local laws. However, this is not always the case. A lease cannot contradict the law, and tenants cannot sign away their rights. For example, in North Carolina, a lease cannot say that the landlord is not responsible for providing heat and access to water in the house. Similarly, in Mississippi, a landlord cannot add a clause stating that a tenant must stay longer than a year to recover their deposit, as the state has no statute that disallows such a clause.

In some cases, leases may include provisions that contradict state law. For instance, a lease in upstate New York stated that the landlord would return security deposits within 30 days of a move-out, even though state law requires deposits to be returned within 14 days. In another case, a lease in California included a six-month statute of limitations on damages, while the state law allows for a four-year period.

It is important to note that the Residential Tenancies Act always takes priority over a lease. This means that a lease cannot take away any of a tenant's rights under the law. For example, if a lease states that a landlord only needs to give two months' notice to end a month-to-month periodic tenancy, this term is unenforceable if the Residential Tenancies Act requires landlords to give at least three months' notice.

While a lease cannot contradict existing laws, it is still essential to carefully review and understand the terms and conditions of a lease before signing it. If you encounter any questionable, punitive, or anti-tenant clauses, it is advisable to seek legal advice to ensure your rights as a tenant are protected.

Local laws may prohibit certain provisions

A lease or rental agreement cannot supersede state law. However, local laws may prohibit certain provisions. For example, landlords may include provisions in the lease agreement that restrict tenant behaviour, such as causing a nuisance or annoyance to other tenants or nearby residents, intentionally damaging the property, or smoking in individual units and common areas. Landlords may also set restrictions on tenant use of the property, such as prohibiting waterbeds, plants on wood floors, or bikes in the hallway, as long as these restrictions are not discriminatory or retaliatory and do not violate state law.

In some states, landlords may be limited in their ability to prohibit certain activities, such as running a daycare operation in a rented home. For example, in California and New York, there are laws in place to encourage family-run daycares, so landlords may not be able to flatly prohibit this type of business. However, they can still impose certain restrictions, such as limiting the number of children and requiring compliance with state fire and health regulations.

Additionally, landlords typically include provisions in the lease agreement that prohibit tenants from renting rooms on short-term rental services like Airbnb. While this is common, it is important to note that these provisions may be subject to local laws and regulations. For example, some cities have enacted regulations that limit the ability of landlords to prohibit short-term rentals.

It is worth noting that lease agreements may also include provisions that are favourable to tenants. For example, tenants have the right to live in the property without unreasonable interference from the landlord. This means that landlords cannot enter the property without just cause or proper notice, as specified by state landlord access laws. These laws outline when landlords may legally enter the premises, such as in an emergency or to make repairs, and the amount of notice required.

State law is explicit that a landlord can't refuse to make repairs

Leases do not supersede state law. In the United States, each state has its own laws regarding landlord-tenant relationships, and these laws outline the rights and responsibilities of both parties. While the specific laws vary from state to state, there are some general principles that apply in most states. For example, in most states, a landlord cannot refuse to make necessary repairs, especially if the issue could lead to health and safety problems.

If a landlord refuses to make necessary repairs, tenants have certain rights and options available to them. These options may include calling state or local building or health inspectors, repairing the problem themselves and deducting the cost from their rent ("repair-and-deduct"), or paying the rent and then suing the landlord for the difference between the rent paid and the value of the defective premises. It is important to note that tenants must typically give their landlord a certain amount of time to fix the problem before taking any of these actions. Additionally, tenants may only be able to take these actions for major repairs or habitability problems, not minor issues.

In some states, tenants may also be able to withhold rent until the necessary repairs are made. However, this option should be approached with caution, as it could lead to an eviction if not done in accordance with state law. Before withholding rent, tenants should ensure they have met all the requirements outlined by their state, such as being up-to-date with rent payments and giving the landlord proper notice of the issue.

While the law generally favours the tenant in these situations, it is important to remember that tenants also have responsibilities. Tenants are typically responsible for repairing any damage they cause themselves or to their own personal property. Additionally, tenants should put their repair requests in writing and give the landlord reasonable time to respond and make the necessary repairs. By understanding their rights and responsibilities, tenants can effectively navigate landlord-tenant disputes and ensure their rental property remains habitable.

A lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law

A lease is a legally binding contract between a landlord and a tenant. However, it is important to note that a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. In other words, a lease cannot supersede state law.

For example, in the United States, a landlord cannot evict a tenant without a valid reason and proper legal process, regardless of what the lease may say. This is because the landlord-tenant relationship is governed by a combination of state and common law, which establishes certain rights and protections for tenants. These laws vary by state but typically include the right to "quiet enjoyment" of the property, which means the tenant has the right to live in a safe and peaceful environment without interference from the landlord or other tenants.

Additionally, tenants have the right to withhold rent if the landlord fails to make necessary repairs or address major issues that make the property uninhabitable. This is true even if the lease does not explicitly state this right. For example, if there is a major problem such as a gas leak or structural damage that makes the property unsafe to live in, the tenant can withhold rent until the issue is resolved. In some states, tenants may also have the right to "repair and deduct," which means they can pay for the necessary repairs themselves and deduct the cost from their rent.

Furthermore, tenants have the right to terminate the lease early under certain circumstances, such as if the landlord violates the terms of the lease or fails to maintain the property. This is known as "constructive eviction," and it allows the tenant to break the lease without penalty. Again, this right exists regardless of whether it is explicitly stated in the lease.

In summary, while a lease sets forth the terms and conditions of the landlord-tenant relationship, it cannot override the rights and protections granted to tenants under state and common law. It is important for both landlords and tenants to understand their respective rights and responsibilities under the law to ensure a fair and equitable rental experience.

Landlords must strike a balance between the freedom to enter into contracts and the letter of landlord-tenant law

Landlords must be mindful of the rights and responsibilities they are granting and taking on when creating or signing a lease. The lease agreement cannot contradict the law, and the law must always be upheld. However, there is a power struggle between the freedom to enter into contracts and landlord-tenant law. Landlord-tenant laws tend to be reactionary, difficult to interpret, and unresponsive, which makes it challenging to strike a balance.

Landlords must be aware of the applicable laws and regulations when drafting a lease agreement. For example, a lease cannot require a tenant to give up any right or protection afforded under the law. Provisions regarding the payment of attorneys' fees, forgoing litigation, or waiving a landlord's liability for property conditions are potentially illegal. If an illegal provision is included in the lease, it may render the entire contract unenforceable. Therefore, landlords should avoid using lease forms from other states, as the laws may differ.

To strike a balance, landlords can include a "severability" clause in the lease. This clause allows for the illegal portion of the contract to be severed, while the remaining contract remains in force. Additionally, the lease agreement should be carefully negotiated between both parties to ensure that the rights and responsibilities of both the landlord and tenant are respected. Landlords should not rush tenants to make a decision, and both parties should be clear about the terms and conditions before signing.

It is also important to note that the type of tenancy, such as a lease or tenancy-at-will, will impact the rights and responsibilities of both parties. For example, in a tenancy-at-will, the tenant can end the tenancy by giving notice, and the rent can change within the same period. On the other hand, a lease agreement typically lasts for a fixed term, during which the monthly rent must stay the same, and the landlord cannot end the tenancy unless the tenant fails to satisfy the conditions in the lease.

Frequently asked questions