Expunging Megan's Law Tier One Offenses: Is It Possible?

Megan's Law is a US sex offender registry that divides offenders into three tiers based on their risk of recidivism, or the likelihood of committing another sex offense. Tier one includes any sexual crime involving minors that is not categorized in Tier 2 or Tier 3, and offenders are required to register their location annually for at least 10 to 15 years. While some sources suggest that Tier One offenders can petition for removal from the registry after 10 years, others state that sex offenses are typically exempt from expungement.

Tier One offenders are considered low-risk and must register their location annually

Tier One offenders are considered low-risk for re-offense, meaning they are unlikely to commit another sex offense. This tier typically only requires notifying local law enforcement agencies in the area the offender lives or works. Tier One offenders are required to register their location annually, including the location of anywhere they reside, work, or attend school. They must register with local police once a year within five working days of their birthday. If they move, they must abide by the laws of the new locality, including restrictions on where they can live. If a Tier One offender is transient, without a permanent residence, they must register every 30 days.

In California, Tier One offenders must register as sex offenders for at least 10 years. After 10 years, they can petition the court to be removed from the registry on their next birthday. However, it is important to note that even if removed from the registry, a Tier One offender may still have their information available to the public via the Megan's Law website. Offenders can apply for removal by submitting a Megan's Law exclusion form to the California Department of Justice.

In New Jersey, Tier One offenders are also placed into this category based on their risk of recidivism, or the possibility that they will commit sex crimes again. Here, Tier One offenders are considered to have a low risk of committing another sex offense, resulting in minimal consequences.

While it is possible for a Tier One offender to be removed from the registry or have their case expunged, it is a challenging process that may require legal assistance. The specific requirements and processes for removal or expungement vary by state, and some states may have lifetime registration requirements for certain offenses. It is recommended to consult with a lawyer to understand the specific laws and options available in each state.

Offenders can challenge their tier classification

In the state of New Jersey, Megan's Law offenders are placed into tiers based on the severity of their crime and their risk of recidivism. There are three tiers, with Tier 1 being for low-risk offenders, Tier 2 for moderate-risk offenders, and Tier 3 for high-risk offenders. If you feel you have been placed in the wrong tier classification, you can challenge it.

The County Prosecutor's office uses the Registrant Risk Assessment Scale (RRAS) to determine your tier classification. This scale considers 13 categories, including the stability of your employment or educational situation, to assign a score that determines your tier. If you believe that your tier classification is incorrect, you can contact a criminal defense attorney who can review your case and help you challenge the classification.

After receiving a Notice of Proposed Tier Classification, you will have a limited amount of time, typically 14 days, to notify a Superior Court Judge and the prosecution that you intend to challenge the classification. The case will then be heard in the county where the offense occurred, and the prosecution will present a discovery packet, including the judgement of conviction, indictment or accusation of the offense, and a completed RRAS. Your attorney will also submit documents and arguments on your behalf.

It is important to note that challenging your tier classification may be a difficult and costly process, and it is recommended to seek legal advice to understand your options and the potential consequences. Additionally, the laws and procedures for challenging a tier classification may vary depending on the state and the specific circumstances of your case.

Tier Three offenders must remain on the registry for life unless their tier status was due to their risk assessment

In the state of California, Tier Three sex offenders must remain on the registry for life. However, if their tier status was due to their risk assessment rather than their crimes, they can petition for removal after 20 years.

In California, Senate Bill 384 permits removal from the sex offender registry in some cases. After registering as a Tier Three offender for 20 years, an offender can petition the court to be removed from the registry. This is also the case for Tier Two offenders after 10 years, and Tier One offenders after 10 or 15 years.

In New Jersey, Megan's Law Tier Three is for high-risk offenders, those who are deemed to have a high risk of committing another sex offense. Tier Three carries the greatest amount of public notification, including local law enforcement agencies, educational institutions, and door-to-door notification of neighbours. Tier Three offenders are also included on the New Jersey Sex Offender Internet Registry.

It is possible to challenge a Tier Three classification in New Jersey. A Superior Court judge will review the classification challenge, and the prosecution will produce a discovery packet. This will include the judgement of conviction, the indictment or accusation of the offense, portions of the Pre-Sentence Report, and a completed Registrant Risk Assessment Scale (RRAS).

In some states, Tier Three is a lifetime registration, and sex offenses are exempt from expungement. However, it may be possible to be removed from the registry via pardon or expungement.

In California, Senate Bill 384 permits removal from the sex offender registry in some cases

In California, Senate Bill 384 (SB 384) permits removal from the sex offender registry in some cases. Before SB 384 was passed, all sex offenders were required to register for life, and any petitions for removal were ignored. Now, only Tier Three offenders are required to register for life. Tier Three covers the most serious sex offenses, such as rape and sex trafficking, and are often characterized by violence, threats, or the young age of the victim.

SB 384, which went into effect on January 1, 2021, establishes a three-tiered approach based on the offense of conviction and other relevant factors. Tier One offenders are required to register as sex offenders for at least 10 years for low-level sex crimes, such as misdemeanor indecent exposure. Tier Two offenders must register for at least 20 years for mid-level sex crimes, such as lewd conduct with a minor.

Tier One and Tier Two offenders can petition the court to be removed from the sex offender registry after the specified periods of time (10 years for Tier One, 20 years for Tier Two) if certain requirements are met. The petitioner must have completed at least the minimum mandated period of registration. Law enforcement must provide a report to the prosecuting agency within 60 days concerning their recommendation on the petition. The prosecuting agency then has 60 days to request a hearing if they believe public safety will be significantly enhanced by continued registration. If the petition is denied, the court must set a period of at least one year but no more than five years before the petitioner may re-apply for termination from the registry.

It is important to note that even if an offender is removed from the California sex offender registry, they may still be required to register as a sex offender in other states. Additionally, removal from the registry does not mean that an offender's criminal record is expunged or that their conviction is removed.

Some crimes prevent offenders from ever being removed from Megan's Law

Megan's Law is a federal law in the United States, which was enacted in response to the rape and murder of seven-year-old Megan Kanka by a neighbour who was a previously convicted child sex offender. The law requires law enforcement authorities to notify the public about registered sex offenders. The information shared includes the offender's name, picture, address, incarceration date, nature of the crime, and more. The information is often displayed on free public websites but can also be published in newspapers or pamphlets.

While registration as a sex offender may not be required for Tier One offenders in some states, it is important to note that some crimes will prevent offenders from ever being removed from Megan's Law. In most states, sex offenses are exempt from expungement, and registration may be required for life. For example, in California, Tier Three sex offenders must remain on the registry for life unless their tier status was due to their risk assessment and not their crimes. In such cases, they can petition for removal after 20 years.

The requirements for sex offender registration and the time period for registration depend on the state and the nature of the criminal offense. While some states may require registration for a fixed period, typically at least ten years, others may mandate lifetime registration for certain offenses. It is important to note that failure to comply with sex offender registration requirements can result in additional penalties.

To apply for removal from Megan's Law in California, individuals must submit an exclusion form to the California Department of Justice. However, it is crucial to understand that even if the minimum sentencing period has been completed, some crimes will still prevent an offender from being removed from the registry.

Given the complexity of the legal system and the varying laws in different states, consulting a lawyer who specializes in sex crimes and sex offender registration laws is highly recommended to understand your specific situation and options.

Frequently asked questions