Maintenance Rights Of Widows: Claiming From In-Laws

In India, widows often face challenges in maintaining themselves after the death of their husbands. While there are laws in place to support widows, the process of claiming maintenance from in-laws can be complex and requires legal counsel. Under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, a widow has the right to claim maintenance from her in-laws, specifically her father-in-law, under certain conditions. These conditions include the inability to maintain herself, the availability of her husband's estate, and the possession of coparcenary property by the father-in-law. The court considers various factors when deciding on maintenance claims, including the financial situation, income, property, and standard of living of the claimant.

Can a Widow Claim Maintenance from In-Laws?

A widow's right to claim maintenance from in-laws

In India, women often find themselves unable to maintain and sustain themselves alone after a divorce or the death of a husband. To address this, the parliament has established laws to protect widows' rights to claim maintenance from their in-laws.

Under Section 18 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act (HAMA), any Hindu wife, even a widow, has the right to maintenance from her husband while he is alive. If he does not pay, she has the right to claim maintenance from his estate. However, a widow is not allowed to make a separate maintenance claim against her in-laws under the HAMA. The husband's estate bears the primary liability.

According to Section 19 of the HAMA, a widowed daughter-in-law can claim maintenance from her father-in-law only if she is unable to maintain herself from her own earnings or property, or from the estate of her husband, father, mother, son, or daughter. This right is conditional and restricted to the father-in-law's share of coparcenary property, which includes ancestral property, joint acquisitions, or property thrown into the common stock and accretions to such property. The father-in-law is not obligated to support his daughter-in-law from his independent or individual property. Additionally, any obligation for maintenance shall cease upon the remarriage of the daughter-in-law.

The court considers several factors when deciding on maintenance claims, including the financial resources, social standing, income, property, earning potential, age, health, and standard of living of the claimant.

It is important to note that claiming maintenance from in-laws involves understanding legal provisions and seeking appropriate legal counsel, such as consulting with a family lawyer.

Limitations of a widow's claim

In India, widows often face challenges in maintaining and supporting themselves after the death of their husbands, due to the limitations and restrictions imposed by a patriarchal society. To address this, the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act (HAMA) of 1956 was established. Under Section 19 of HAMA, a widowed daughter-in-law can claim maintenance from her father-in-law if she is unable to support herself and if her father-in-law has the necessary resources. This right to claim maintenance is, however, subject to certain limitations:

• A widow cannot make a separate maintenance claim against her in-laws under HAMA. The principal liability rests with the husband or his estate.
• The in-laws are not legally required to support the widow unless they have inherited the husband's property and have sufficient resources. In such cases, they may be morally obligated to provide for the widow.
• The right to claim maintenance is conditional. The widow must demonstrate that she is unable to maintain herself through her own earnings, her estate, or that of her husband, parents, or children.
• The father-in-law's obligation to provide maintenance terminates if the widow remarries.
• The widow's claim is limited to the share of coparcenary property held by the father-in-law in which she has not taken any share.
• The court's interpretation of the law and specific circumstances may vary on a case-to-case basis.
• Social Security benefits for widows are subject to an age limit. In the US, the widow's limit provision of Social Security generally requires that a widow's benefit not exceed that of her deceased spouse.

Court considerations when deciding maintenance claims

In India, women often struggle to maintain and sustain themselves after a divorce or the death of a husband. To address this, the parliament has established laws to support widowed women, such as the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act of 1956 (HAMA). Under Section 19 of HAMA, a widow can claim maintenance from her in-laws under certain circumstances. Here are some key considerations for courts when deciding on maintenance claims:

Standard of Living

The court considers the lifestyle, conveniences, and comforts the claimant was accustomed to during her marriage. It evaluates the claimant's way of life before the conflict or separation.

Age and Health

The claimant's age and health status are assessed to determine their ability to support themselves financially and earn a living. Older individuals or those with health issues may have more difficulty sustaining themselves.

Financial Needs

The court evaluates the claimant's financial requirements, including their need for food, clothing, shelter, education, medical care, and other essential needs. It determines what level of financial support is necessary to meet these basic needs.

Maintenance of Children

If the claimant has children, the court considers their financial obligation to provide for their offspring's needs. This includes expenses related to education, well-being, and the general upbringing of the children.

Reasonable Expenses

The court takes into account the claimant's reasonable expenses incurred during the legal process, such as attorney fees and other associated costs. These expenses are considered when determining the overall financial needs of the claimant.

Status and Position

The court assesses the financial resources, social standing, and way of life of both the claimant and respondent. This includes evaluating their earning potential, income, and real estate holdings.

Exceptional Circumstances

In unusual situations, a widow may seek maintenance from her in-laws if her husband's inheritance is insufficient for her maintenance, and the in-laws have significant resources. The court may consider the overall financial situation and ability to support the claimant.

Other Relevant Factors

The court may also take into account any additional factors that arise during the proceedings and may impact the decision. This allows for flexibility and ensures that unique circumstances are given due consideration.

It is important to note that the process of claiming maintenance involves legal complexities, and seeking appropriate legal counsel is advisable. The specific laws and considerations may vary based on regional legislation and judicial interpretations.

Legal provisions and seeking appropriate legal counsel

In India, a widow is entitled to claim maintenance from her in-laws under the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956. This Act defines 'maintenance' as including "provisions for food, clothing, residence, education, and medical treatment". Additionally, in the case of an unmarried daughter, it also covers the reasonable expenses of her marriage.

The legal provisions for maintenance in India are contained in various statutes, including the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (under sections 125 to 128) and Article 39 of the Constitution of India, which states that citizens, regardless of gender, have the right to adequate means of livelihood.

When it comes to widows claiming maintenance from their in-laws, there have been several notable court cases in India. One such case is V. Tulasamma And Others v. Sesha Reddy, where the appellant Tulasamma filed a petition for maintenance against the respondent in 1944. Another example is the 2015 case of a widow who was forced out of her matrimonial home by her in-laws and claimed maintenance from her father-in-law. The court ruled in her favour, directing the father-in-law to pay a monthly maintenance of Rs 40,000 and a lump sum of Rs 7 lakh for the period between the filing of the petition and the date of the order.

In another instance, the Nagpur bench of the Bombay High Court ruled that a widow was entitled to maintenance from her in-laws if they held properties in their deceased son's name. The court directed the in-laws to pay the widow a monthly maintenance of Rs 7,500 from February 2008 to December 2009, amounting to Rs 1.75 lakh, which included litigation costs.

To seek legal counsel and navigate the complexities of maintenance laws in India, one can approach legal aid services that provide support to claimants, particularly women. These services can offer guidance on understanding legal rights, filing petitions, and ensuring timely disposal of cases. Additionally, awareness campaigns are also conducted to educate individuals about their rights and legal provisions for maintenance.

Maintenance from in-laws vs. maintenance from husband's estate

In India, women often become dependent on their husbands and are unable to support themselves in the event of a divorce or their husband's death. To make things easier for them, the parliament has established laws on the subject.

Maintenance from in-laws

According to the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956, a widow can claim maintenance from her in-laws if they are holding properties in their son's name or have the possession of estates/coparcenary properties in which the former husband had rights and interest. This is only possible if the widow is unable to maintain herself from her own earnings or out of the estate of her husband or her parents.

Maintenance from husband's estate

The right to claim maintenance by a widow is conditional. The court ruled that if the father-in-law lacks the means to place his daughter-in-law in the custody of any coparcenary property of which the daughter-in-law has not gained any part, he is not obliged and the right is not actionable. The estate of the husband comes first to claim maintenance by a widow.

Frequently asked questions