Rewrite All Laws: A Necessary Task?

The legislative process is a complex and lengthy one, and it is important for citizens to be informed about how laws are made and changed. In the US, laws are made by Congress, which consists of the Senate and the House of Representatives. The process of making a law starts with a bill, which is a proposal for a new law or a change to an existing one. Bills can be proposed by members of the Senate or House of Representatives, or by citizen groups. Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned to a committee, which researches, discusses, and makes changes to it. The bill then goes through several stages of voting and amendments before it can become a law. Given the intricate and lengthy process, it is possible that all laws could be rewritten, but it would be a challenging and time-consuming endeavour.

The legislative process and the role of Congress

The legislative process in the United States is a complex and deliberate system that involves the collaboration of various entities, most notably Congress, which plays a fundamental role in the creation of laws. Congress, as outlined in Article I, Section 1 of the United States Constitution, consists of two chambers: the Senate and the House of Representatives. Both chambers possess equal legislative powers, and a proposal cannot become a law without the consideration and approval of both Houses, a key feature of the bicameral legislative system.

The legislative process begins with the introduction of a bill. Bills can originate in either the House of Representatives or the Senate, except for those related to raising revenue, which must originate in the House of Representatives, per Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution. There are two types of bills: public bills, which affect the general public, and private bills, which pertain to specific individuals or entities. Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned a legislative number and referred to the appropriate committees by the Speaker of the House.

The committees play a crucial role in the legislative process. They consist of members from both parties, allowing for diverse perspectives and expertise. The committees assess and develop the bills, making amendments if necessary. The majority of policy expertise resides in these committees, and members often serve on a small number of committees for extended periods, gaining extensive knowledge in specific policy areas. Once the committees have completed their work, the bill moves back to the full House or Senate for further discussion and deliberation.

The House of Representatives and the Senate have distinct methods of processing legislation due to their constitutional differences. The House tends to act more swiftly, driven by numerical majorities, while the Senate favours a more deliberative approach, providing individual senators with significant procedural influence. Ultimately, for a bill to become a law, both chambers must separately agree to the same bill in its final form. This collaborative process ensures that all sides are heard and that the interests of the minority are protected, reflecting the democratic ideals of the legislative system.

How to find laws, acts, and statutes

To find laws, acts, and statutes, there are several places you can look. Firstly, you can refer to the United States Code ("U.S. Code"), which is available in print or online. Each citation listed will include a public law number or chapter number, the date the public law was enacted, and a citation to where the public law can be found in the United States Statutes at Large.

The United States Statutes at Large is another resource for finding laws, acts, and statutes. It is published annually by the Government Publishing Office and contains public laws from each session of Congress. You can access the United States Statutes at Large for free online, depending on when the public law was passed. For public laws passed before 1875, you can visit the website "A Century of Lawmaking for a New Nation". For laws passed from 1875 onwards, you can visit the Constitution Society's website, but you will need to download the entire Statutes at Large volume that contains the law.

Additionally, you can refer to U.S. Code Congressional and Administrative News (U.S.C.C.A.N.), a commercial publication that provides timely access to the text of laws as originally passed by Congress. U.S.C.C.A.N. may be available at large public libraries or federal depository libraries. Over 1,100 libraries participate in the Federal Depository Library Program (FDLP), providing public access to government documents.

Finally, the Senate and House Document Rooms may be able to provide a copy of a slip law, and you can also refer to the research guides available online for more detailed instructions on how to trace federal legislation.

The process of amending laws

The idea for a new bill or amendment to an existing law can come from a sitting member of the Senate or House of Representatives, or it can be proposed during an election campaign. Bills can also be petitioned by citizens or groups who recommend changes to a member of Congress. Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned to a committee that researches, discusses, and makes changes to it. This is where the bill can be notably improved by amendment before it becomes law or is defeated.

Bills may originate in either the House of Representatives or the Senate, with one exception: Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution states that all bills for raising revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives. The Senate, however, may propose amendments. There are two types of bills: public and private. A public bill affects the general public, while a private bill affects a specific individual or entity.

After a bill is passed by both bodies, they must reconcile any differences between their versions. Then, both chambers vote on the same version of the bill. If it passes, it is presented to the President for consideration. The President can approve and sign the bill into law or veto it. If the President vetoes, Congress can, in most cases, vote to override the veto and the bill becomes law. However, if the President does not sign off on the bill and Congress is no longer in session, the bill is pocket vetoed and cannot be overridden.

At the end of each session of Congress, public laws are published in the United States Statutes at Large. A more timely resource for finding the original text of laws is U.S. Code Congressional and Administrative News (U.S.C.C.A.N.).

The role of the Senate and House of Representatives

The United States Senate and House of Representatives, together known as Congress, play a critical role in the legislative process and the functioning of the country's democracy. The legislative process, in which both houses are deeply involved, is a critical safeguard of the American democratic way of life, with its emphasis on minority protection and allowing all sides to be heard.

The Senate and the House of Representatives have distinct roles and powers, as outlined in the US Constitution. The House of Representatives, also known as the lower chamber because it has more members, enjoys significant leeway in deciding how it operates. It is responsible for initiating most laws and is the starting point for all bills aimed at raising revenue, as per Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution. The House also has the power to impeach government officials, serving as a prosecutor. Representatives are elected to two-year terms, and the number of representatives per state is based on population, ensuring equal representation per citizen.

On the other hand, the Senate, or the upper chamber, has a more deliberate and advisory role. Senators have six-year terms, shielding them from short-term political pressure. The Senate reviews and acts on bills, resolutions, amendments, motions, nominations, and treaties through voting. It can propose amendments to spending and taxing legislation, and it has the sole power to conduct impeachment trials, serving as a jury and judge. The Senate also plays a critical role in checking the executive branch's powers, as it must approve presidential appointments to executive and judicial branch posts and can approve treaties made by the executive branch.

While the two houses have distinct roles, they also work together. All proposals must be considered and approved by both houses to become laws, ensuring that the legislative process is thorough and inclusive. This bicameral legislative system is a strength of the American political process, allowing for a balance between quick legislative action in the House and thoughtful deliberation in the Senate.

The impact of laws on minority groups

Laws have a significant impact on the lives of minority groups. In the United States, federal civil rights laws have played a crucial role in improving educational opportunities for minorities, women, individuals with disabilities, and older persons. For instance, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) has made a significant difference in the inclusion and participation of students with disabilities in mainstream classrooms. In 1984, only a quarter of students with disabilities received education in regular classrooms for most of the school day, but by the 1994-95 school year, this number had increased to 45%, with about 2.4 million students benefiting from this change.

Additionally, civil rights laws have contributed to increased minority participation in higher education. Between fall 1986 and fall 1996, total minority enrollment at colleges and universities increased by 61%. During this period, the number of Latino students in higher education increased by 47%, African American enrollment increased by 20%, and American Indian enrollment increased by 30%. Civil rights laws have also had a positive impact on Scholastic Assessment Test (SAT) participation and scores among minority students. From 1988 to 1998, minority participation in the SAT increased from 23% to 33% of all graduating seniors. During this period, SAT scores improved across almost all minority groups, with the average score for African American students increasing by 6 points in verbal and 15 points in mathematics, exceeding the gains made by white students.

However, laws can also negatively impact minority groups. Strict voter ID laws, for example, have been shown to disproportionately affect voters of color and reduce their turnout. Researchers have found that the enactment of strict voter ID laws in North Carolina reduced overall turnout, with a more significant impact on communities of color. Similarly, a study on the impact of Texas's "Reasonable Impediments Declaration," which allows voters without proper IDs to participate, found that it disproportionately benefits Black and Latino voters, who would otherwise be barred from voting due to strict identification laws. Polling place consolidation has also been identified as a barrier to racial and ethnic minority turnout, as evidenced by the depressed turnout in Milwaukee's presidential primary, particularly among Black voters.

To address these issues, the United Nations, through the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and in partnership with the Equal Rights Trust, has developed "Protecting Minority Rights: A Practical Guide to Developing Comprehensive Anti-Discrimination Legislation." This guide provides clear and accessible guidance to states on the necessary scope, structure, and content of anti-discrimination laws to meet their international human rights law obligations. It was developed through extensive research and global consultations with experts and civil society organizations to synthesize and harmonize existing international legal standards. The OHCHR also established an Advisory Committee comprising 13 leading experts in anti-discrimination and equality law from diverse legal systems and regions to ensure the validity and relevance of the guide.

Frequently asked questions