Aunt-Nephew Marriage: Canon Law Perspective

Marrying one's aunt or uncle is known as avunculate marriage. In some countries, this type of marriage is prohibited by law, while in others, it is permitted and even common, especially in royalty. The legality of avunculate marriage varies depending on the country and state, with some countries allowing it under certain circumstances. Religious beliefs also play a role in the perception of avunculate marriage, with some religions forbidding it while others encourage it.

Aunt-nephew marriage legality in the United States

An avunculate marriage is a marriage between a parent's sibling or a sibling's child, i.e., an aunt or uncle and their niece or nephew. In some countries, avunculate marriages are prohibited by law, while in others, they are legal and common, though now less frequent. Partners in such marriages are more closely related genetically than first cousins, sharing around 25% of their genetic material.

In the United States, aunt-nephew marriages are generally prohibited. Many states have laws forbidding marriages between close relatives, and the specific laws vary from state to state. However, there are some exceptions. For example, in some states, these marriages may be permitted if the aunt and nephew are of a certain age or if the aunt is unable to have children. Despite legal restrictions, there have been instances of couples challenging these laws in court, arguing that their right to marry is protected by the Constitution. Nevertheless, courts have typically upheld the laws, citing the genetic risks associated with such unions, including an increased likelihood of genetic disorders in any offspring.

The legality of avunculate marriages differs across the world. They are permitted in several countries, including Norway, Denmark, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, the Czech Republic, Chile, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Finland, Macau, Thailand, Malaysia, the Netherlands, Cuba, and Russia. In the United States, while it is generally illegal, avunculate marriages are permitted in specific circumstances in two states. In New York, a marriage between a woman and her mother's half-brother was upheld by the New York Court of Appeals. Rhode Island also has an exception to the general prohibition against "kindred marriages" for Jewish marriages allowed by that religion.

In contrast, avunculate marriages are not permitted in several other countries, including New Zealand, Brazil, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Hungary, Peru, Mexico, Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, and the United Kingdom. In France and Indonesia, such marriages are allowed only under specific conditions. While first cousin marriages are permitted in some societies, avunculate marriages are generally considered to be more controversial due to the closer genetic relationship between the partners.

Religious views on avunculate marriage

Avunculate marriage, or marriage between an aunt or uncle and their niece or nephew, is viewed differently by various religious groups. In Judaism, marriage between an aunt and her nephew is forbidden, but marriage between an uncle and his niece is allowed. The Talmud and Maimonides encourage marriages between uncles and nieces, though some Jewish religious communities, like the Sadducees, believe that such unions are prohibited by the Torah. The Sadducean approach, for instance, outlaws avunculate marriage entirely, attributing this prohibition to the Bible. On the other hand, the Rabbinic position is that avunculate marriage is permitted by Biblical law, and there are even Biblical precedents for allowing such marriages, such as the marriages of Abraham and Nahor to their respective nieces. However, the Rabbis do limit the circumstances under which one may marry his niece, forbidding marriage to one's fraternal niece to avoid conflict with the commandment of Levirate marriage.

Among medieval and early-modern Christians, marriages between a woman and the sibling of her parent were not always seen as violating Leviticus 18, especially among European royalty and nobility. In Catholic countries, a papal dispensation could be obtained to allow such a marriage.

In Islam, marriage between an uncle and his niece is forbidden if they are blood relatives. Avunculate marriages were common among South India's Hindus and were prominent in the House of Habsburg, where they were used to consolidate power and maintain control within the family.

In terms of legality, avunculate marriages are prohibited by law in some countries, while they are permitted in others, including Norway, Denmark, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, the Czech Republic, Chile, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Finland, Macau, Thailand, Malaysia, the Netherlands, Cuba, and Russia. In the United States, avunculate marriages are permitted in certain circumstances in two states: New York and Rhode Island.

Genetic risks of avunculate marriage

Avunculate marriage is a marriage between an aunt and her nephew or an uncle and their niece. If the partners in an avunculate marriage are biologically related, they would normally have the same genetic relationship as half-siblings or a grandparent and grandchild, meaning they share approximately 25% of their genetic material. This is a higher coefficient of inbreeding (F) than marriages between first cousins, where the F is 0.0625. A 1990 study in South India found that the incidence of malformations was slightly higher in uncle-niece progeny (9.34%) compared to the first cousin progeny (6.18%).

Consanguineous marriages, or marriages between close relatives, are deeply rooted in one-fifth of the world's population, especially in the Middle East, West Asia, and North Africa, as well as among emigrants from these communities now residing in North America, Europe, and Australia. While there are potential social and economic benefits to consanguineous marriages, there are also increased genetic risks to the offspring. In first cousin marriages, the fertility rate is slightly higher, but the stillbirth and infant mortality rates are also higher, and the birth defects frequency is estimated to be around 2-3% points more than the background rate among newborns in the general population. Consanguineous unions can also lead to an increased expression of autosomal recessive disorders.

Due to the potential health risks associated with avunculate marriages, many young couples planning to have children seek preconception genetic counseling. It is important that primary health care providers, especially in highly consanguineous communities, have clear evidence-based guidelines for counseling consanguineous couples to help them make informed decisions regarding their reproductive choices.

Avunculate marriage is permitted in several countries, including Norway, Denmark, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, the Czech Republic, Chile, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Finland, Macau, Thailand, Malaysia, the Netherlands, Cuba, and Russia. In the United States, it is permitted in some circumstances in two states: New York and Rhode Island. However, it is prohibited in several other countries, including New Zealand, Brazil, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Hungary, Peru, Mexico, Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, and the United Kingdom.

Avunculate marriage in medieval Europe

Avunculate marriage refers to a marriage between an aunt or uncle and their niece or nephew. In medieval Europe, avunculate marriage was not always interpreted as violating religious law. This was especially true among the royal houses of Europe, and in Catholic countries, a papal dispensation could be obtained to allow such a marriage. For example, Charles II of Spain was the son of an avunculate marriage between Philip IV and Mariana of Austria.

Avunculate marriage was also a preferred type of union in some pre-modern societies, including Ancient Egypt, where marriages between close relatives were frequent among royalty. In medieval Europe, avunculate marriage was likely influenced by the social and political dynamics of the time. Marriage was often a political arrangement, with the bride and groom's families involved in the matchmaking process, and the exchange of dowries further complicating the dynamics.

The specific regulations and views on avunculate marriage in medieval Europe varied across different regions and time periods. While some societies prohibited such marriages due to consanguinity, or close genetic relationships, others allowed them under certain conditions. For instance, in the New York Court of Appeals, a marriage between a woman and her mother's half-brother was upheld, demonstrating a degree of flexibility in legal interpretations.

It is worth noting that the church played a significant role in enforcing marriage laws during the medieval period. While Christians in western Europe had the freedom to marry without the need for parental consent or a priest's presence, they still had to adhere to the church's guidelines, which included prohibitions on consanguinity. However, the church also upheld freely given consent as the foundation of marriage, which could have influenced the acceptance of avunculate marriages in certain contexts.

In summary, avunculate marriage in medieval Europe was shaped by a complex interplay of social, political, and religious factors. While some societies permitted such marriages, especially among royalty, others prohibited them due to concerns about close genetic relationships. The church's role in enforcing marriage laws, along with the influence of families and social networks, further complicated the dynamics of avunculate marriage during this period.

Countries where avunculate marriage is permitted

An avunculate marriage is a marriage between an aunt or uncle and their niece or nephew. Such marriages were common in pre-modern societies, especially among royalty in Ancient Egypt. Avunculate marriages were also common among South India's Hindus and are currently mostly practised in rural and small to medium-sized cities. In medieval and early-modern Christian societies, marriages between a woman and her parent's sibling were not always seen as violating Leviticus 18, especially among the royal houses of Europe. In Catholic countries, a papal dispensation could be obtained to allow such a marriage.

In Judaism, marriage between an aunt and her nephew is forbidden, but marriage between an uncle and his niece is allowed and even encouraged by the Talmud and Maimonides. In Islam, marriage between an uncle and his niece is forbidden if they are blood relatives.

Avunculate marriage is permitted in the following countries:

• Norway
• Denmark
• Germany
• Switzerland
• Austria
• Czech Republic
• Chile
• Argentina
• Australia
• Canada
• Finland
• Macau
• Thailand
• Malaysia
• The Netherlands
• Cuba
• Russia

In the United States, avunculate marriage is permitted in some circumstances in two states: New York and Rhode Island. In New York, a marriage between a woman and her mother's half-brother was upheld by the New York Court of Appeals. Rhode Island has an exception to the general prohibition against "kindred marriages" for Jewish marriages allowed by that religion. Avunculate marriage is not permitted in New Zealand, Brazil, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Hungary, Peru, Mexico, Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, or the United Kingdom. In France and Indonesia, avunculate marriage is allowed under certain circumstances. In Sweden, avunculate marriage is permitted, but only with permission.

Frequently asked questions