Can Ex-Felons Practice Law? Redemption And Legal Practice

A criminal record can be a significant barrier to finding employment, and in some cases, it can even prevent people from entering certain professions. For those with a felony conviction, the path to becoming a lawyer is challenging, but it is not necessarily a bar to a career in law. While some states have stringent requirements for felons who want to become lawyers, and others maintain an absolute ban, most states do not have a blanket ban on ex-felons taking the bar exam and becoming licensed attorneys. Ultimately, each applicant is reviewed on an individual basis, and the character and fitness of the applicant are considered.

State-specific requirements

While most states do not prohibit ex-felons from practicing law, they may impose certain requirements that aspiring lawyers with a criminal history must meet. These requirements vary from state to state. For instance, in Florida, the governor must restore your civil rights by petition before you can sit for the bar exam. In Washington, bar examiners must determine that an applicant has the appropriate character and fitness to practice law before they may sit for the bar exam.

Connecticut, for example, does not prohibit felons from becoming attorneys, but a felony conviction creates a presumption that the applicant lacks "good moral character and/or fitness to practice law." Such applicants must prove otherwise by "clear and convincing evidence." Similarly, California and North Carolina consider only crimes involving moral turpitude as grounds for barring an ex-convict from becoming a lawyer.

Some states have stringent requirements for persons convicted of felony offenses who want to become lawyers. For instance, Maryland, Ohio, and Tennessee have stricter standards for applicants with felony convictions.

Only three states—Texas, Kansas, and Mississippi—have been consistently reported to ban felons from becoming lawyers.

Expungement of felony convictions

The expungement of felony convictions varies across different states and jurisdictions. In the common law legal system, expungement refers to the sealing or destruction of records relating to an individual's arrest or conviction, making them inaccessible to the general public. While expungement deals with underlying criminal records, it is a civil action where the individual petitions the court to have their records expunged.

In Tennessee, for instance, the process of expungement involves filing a petition with the court clerk, paying any required fees, and providing necessary information about the case. The court then orders state agencies, including law enforcement and corrections departments, to remove the records. Tennessee law allows for the expungement of juvenile records and certain types of offenses, such as nonviolent offenses, under specific conditions.

Other states, like California, permit the expungement of most types of convictions, including some felonies, as long as the individual has completed probation, satisfied financial obligations, and is not facing charges or under supervision. In Washington, D.C., the Second Chance Act of 2022 will automatically seal and expunge felony records for certain felons starting in 2027.

Maryland has also passed legislation allowing for the expungement of certain misdemeanors and felonies, such as assault and theft, after a specified time frame. The expungement statute in Maryland prevents licensing boards from denying licenses based on expunged offenses.

While expungement can help remove the barriers to employment and other opportunities for ex-felons, it is important to note that the process and eligibility criteria vary across jurisdictions, and not all felony convictions may be eligible for expungement in every state.

Moral character examination

The American Bar Association has documented more than 25,000 state restrictions on occupational licenses, and a felony conviction can be a significant barrier to becoming a lawyer. However, there is no definitive answer to whether an ex-felon can practice law, as it depends on various factors, including the state, the nature of the felony, and the individual's rehabilitation and character assessment.

The character and fitness of an individual are critical factors considered by bar examining committees when evaluating an applicant's eligibility to practice law. This assessment is subjective and loosely defined, and each state may have its own approach to determining if someone with a criminal record meets the standard for obtaining a law license. The worst criminal offenses for admission are those that reflect a lack of truthfulness (e.g., theft, fraud) and moral turpitude (e.g., murder, manslaughter, kidnapping, rape).

Bar examining committees may conduct an extensive review of an applicant's character and fitness, including contacting references, requesting the applicant's appearance at an investigative hearing, and examining the applicant's life before and after incarceration. The focus is on understanding the individual's rehabilitation, remorse, and fitness to serve as an attorney.

The ABA commission has argued that former offenders should have the opportunity to obtain jobs for which they are skilled and that a conviction should be considered but may not necessarily relate to an individual's ability to practice law. This perspective highlights the aim of modern penology to rehabilitate criminals and facilitate their reintegration into society as productive members.

Some states have stringent requirements for applicants with felony convictions who aspire to become lawyers. For example, in Florida, an individual must first have their civil rights restored by petition to the governor, a lengthy process, before they can even sit for the bar exam. In Washington State, bar examiners must determine that an applicant possesses the requisite character and fitness before they are allowed to take the bar exam.

In summary, while a felony conviction can be a significant obstacle, it may not necessarily preclude an individual from becoming a lawyer. Each case is unique, and the specific circumstances, rehabilitation, and character assessment will play a pivotal role in the bar examining committee's decision-making process.

Nature of the felony

The nature of the felony is a critical factor in determining whether an ex-felon can practice law. While a felony conviction does not necessarily preclude an individual from becoming a lawyer, certain types of felonies can significantly impact an applicant's chances. Offenses that reflect a lack of truthfulness, such as theft or fraud, and those that indicate moral turpitude, including murder, manslaughter, kidnapping, or rape, are often seen as the most detrimental to an applicant's character and fitness evaluation.

The American Bar Association (ABA) and state bar associations recognize the conflict between the high ethical standards expected of lawyers and the goal of rehabilitating ex-convicts. As a result, each applicant's case is reviewed individually, considering the nature and circumstances of their felony conviction. The time passed since the conviction and evidence of rehabilitation and remorse can also influence the evaluation.

Some states have specific requirements and guidelines for applicants with felony convictions. For example, Maryland has passed legislation allowing certain misdemeanor and felony convictions, including assault and theft, to be expunged after a certain period. This expungement process prevents professional licensing boards in the state from denying licenses based on these expunged offenses. Similarly, Texas tends to ignore minor charges that do not involve moral turpitude.

On the other hand, some states have more stringent requirements. For instance, California and North Carolina have stated that only crimes involving moral turpitude would disqualify an ex-convict from becoming a lawyer. Certain felonies, such as selling drugs, shoplifting, or petty larceny, may be explicitly listed as bars to becoming a lawyer in specific states, like Tennessee.

The area of law an ex-felon wishes to practice can also be a factor. Certain convictions may make it more challenging to enter specific legal fields. For example, a fraud or forgery conviction could make it harder to become a bankruptcy or real estate attorney, whereas family law might be more attainable.

While it is challenging for ex-felons to become lawyers, it is not impossible. The nature of the felony, the passage of time, and demonstrating rehabilitation and good moral character can all contribute to an ex-felon's chances of successfully entering the legal profession.

Bar exam and licensing

While a felony conviction does not automatically bar you from taking the bar exam, you will need to pass a moral character examination to become a licensed attorney. This is a rigorous process that requires you to submit extensive documentation of your past life, including your criminal background. The bar will then hold a hearing to determine whether you have rehabilitated yourself and are of good current moral character. They will consider factors such as whether you have tried to restore your civil rights, your recent conduct, and the amount of time that has passed since your conviction. You may also need to provide character references and evidence that you are actively working to improve yourself, such as through volunteer work or therapy.

The specific requirements for passing the moral character examination vary from state to state. For example, in Kansas and Missouri, you must wait five years after finishing your sentence before you can apply for bar admission. In Oregon, you can become a lawyer after a felony unless you were convicted of a crime for which a lawyer could be disbarred. As of 2017, three states (Kansas, Mississippi, and Texas) and one U.S. territory (the Northern Mariana Islands) completely banned felons from becoming lawyers. However, even in these states, it may be possible to obtain a law license if you can demonstrate that you have been fully rehabilitated.

It is important to be honest and truthful when completing your bar application. Concealing your criminal record will only hurt your chances of becoming a lawyer. While the process of obtaining a law license as a felon can be challenging and seemingly arbitrary, it is not impossible. With sincerity and full disclosure, you can maximize your chances of passing the moral character examination and becoming a licensed attorney.

Frequently asked questions