Hoa Vs City Law: Who Has The Final Say?

Homeowners' associations (HOAs) have rules and regulations in place to ensure community cohesion and safety, as well as to maintain property values. However, these rules cannot override federal, state, county, or city laws and ordinances. While HOAs have some power over their residents, they cannot take away citizen rights given by the government. For example, an HOA rule may state that homeowners cannot park on the street overnight, but if the city ordinance allows for street parking during certain hours, the local ordinance takes precedence. In another instance, an HOA might try to prevent members from expressing their political opinions or putting up American flags on their property, but the Constitution protects freedom of speech and the right to display the American flag. Therefore, while HOAs can regulate the size and placement of flags, they cannot outright ban them.

HOA rules cannot overrule city ordinances

HOA rules and regulations are an effective way to ensure community cohesion and maintain property values. However, they must comply with local laws and cannot overrule or contradict city ordinances. For example, if an HOA rule prohibits overnight street parking, but the city ordinance allows it during certain hours, the local ordinance takes precedence. Similarly, if an HOA rule bans solar panel installation on rooftops, but state law gives homeowners the right to install them, the state law would prevail.

Homeowners must understand the hierarchy of laws governing their community. The Constitution is at the top of the hierarchy, followed by federal laws, state laws, county laws, and city laws. HOA rules are below these in the hierarchy and are subject to state laws governing non-profit corporations. These laws outline the procedures for establishing and operating an HOA and the rights and duties of its members.

HOA rules cannot force residents to violate local laws. For instance, an HOA might stipulate that homes on the north side of a street can water their lawns on even-numbered days, but if municipal law states that homes on that side should water on odd-numbered days, the city law takes precedence. Additionally, an HOA cannot infringe on citizen rights granted by the government, such as the right to free speech. While an HOA cannot ban flying the American flag outside a home, it can regulate the flag's size and location.

If an HOA is believed to be violating local laws or exceeding its authority, homeowners should first review the HOA's CC&Rs (Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) to determine if the rule in question aligns with local laws. If the HOA board refuses to address the issue or the violation is significant, seeking legal advice from an HOA attorney is recommended. An attorney can help clarify rights, assess the situation, and develop a strategy to address the problem.

HOA rules must comply with local laws

HOA rules and regulations can be an effective way to ensure community cohesion and maintain property values. However, they must comply with local laws and cannot override state or federal laws. This means that HOA rules cannot contradict city or county ordinances and are subject to a hierarchy of laws. For example, if a city ordinance allows street parking during certain hours, this local ordinance takes precedence over an HOA rule that prohibits overnight parking. Similarly, if state law mandates that homeowners have the right to install solar panels, this right supersedes any HOA rule prohibiting their installation.

The Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) outline the rules and restrictions that homeowners must follow within an HOA. While the HOA board has the authority to create these covenants, it does not have absolute power. The board must ensure that its rules do not contradict local, state, or federal laws and that they do not violate residents' legal rights. For instance, the federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination against members based on race, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability.

In addition to complying with higher-level laws, HOA rules must also respect the rights of homeowners. For example, the Freedom to Display the American Flag Act of 2005 gives homeowners the right to hang the American flag on their property, and while the HOA can set standards for the size and placement of the flag, it cannot prohibit its display. Similarly, HOA rules regarding holiday decorations and religious practices cannot violate a homeowner's rights, though the board may set restrictions on noise levels and the duration of decorations.

To ensure compliance with local laws, HOA management should regularly review and update their rules and regulations. Changes in state, federal, or local laws may occur, and it is important for HOA rules to reflect these changes to avoid becoming unenforceable or inadvertently breaking the law. Homeowners who believe their HOA is violating local laws or overstepping its bounds can review the HOA's CC&Rs to determine if the rule in question aligns with local laws and, if necessary, seek legal counsel from an experienced HOA attorney.

HOA rules cannot contradict state laws

Homeowners' associations (HOAs) are private organisations that are generally subject to state laws governing non-profit corporations. While HOA rules and regulations can be an effective means of ensuring community cohesion and maintaining property values, they must also comply with local laws. In other words, HOA rules cannot override state or federal laws, nor can they contradict the city or county ordinances that govern the area in which the HOA is located.

For example, if an HOA rule states that homeowners cannot park on the street overnight, but the city ordinance allows for street parking during certain hours, the local ordinance would take precedence. Similarly, if an HOA rule prohibits the installation of solar panels on rooftops, but state law mandates that homeowners have the right to install solar panels, the state law would take precedence.

If you believe your HOA is violating local laws or overstepping its bounds, the first step is to review your HOA's CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) to determine whether the rule in question is in line with local laws. If it is not, you can bring the matter to the attention of your HOA board and request that they revise the rule accordingly. If the HOA board refuses to address the issue or you believe that the violation is egregious, you may need to seek legal counsel from an experienced HOA attorney.

It's important to note that HOA rules and regulations can have a significant impact on the community's appearance and cohesion. They can dictate the maintenance of community members' lawns, including mowing, edging, weed removal, and watering. Additionally, they can enforce rules regarding parking, the types of vehicles that can be stored on the property, and the care, noise level, and maintenance of pets. However, these rules must always be in compliance with local, state, and federal laws.

HOA rules cannot violate resident rights

HOA rules and regulations can be an effective way to ensure community cohesion and maintain property values. However, they must comply with local, state, and federal laws and cannot override or contradict them. HOA rules that violate resident rights are unenforceable and can lead to costly litigation. Here are some key points to understand why and how HOA rules cannot violate resident rights:

• Compliance with Laws: HOAs must ensure that their rules comply with the relevant state and federal laws. For example, the Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits HOAs from discriminating based on race, colour, national origin, religion, disability, gender identity, familial status, and sexual orientation.
• Non-Discrimination: HOAs cannot adopt rules that are discriminatory. State and federal laws prohibit discrimination on various grounds, including race, ethnicity, gender, and family status. Any form of discrimination, whether explicit or subtle, is a violation of resident rights.
• No Facilitation of Fraud or Selective Enforcement: HOAs must refrain from adopting rules that promote or facilitate fraud or selective enforcement. This includes discriminatory enforcement or disproportionately targeting individual homeowners for personal reasons.
• Respecting Property Owners' Rights: While HOAs can impose certain restrictions, they must respect property owners' rights. For example, the Freedom to Display the American Flag Act of 2005 allows residents to display certain flags, and the Telecommunications Act of 1996 grants homeowners the right to install satellite dishes and communication devices on their property.
• Right to a Hearing: Homeowners have the right to a hearing before the HOA takes disciplinary action, such as fines or suspension of privileges. This right to a fair hearing exists even if the homeowner has clearly violated the association's rules.
• Review of Alterations: HOA management should allow for the review of alterations made to homes and provide some control over improvements to maintain the community's desired image. This balance helps preserve order while allowing reasonable modifications to residents' homes.
• Compliance with CC&Rs: The Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) are a crucial set of rules that govern the operation of an HOA. They outline the rights and responsibilities of the HOA and the limitations and requirements for homeowners. Adherence to CC&Rs is essential to ensure compliance with resident rights.

In conclusion, while HOAs have the authority to make and enforce rules, they must always respect and observe the rights of residents. Homeowners who believe their rights have been violated by the HOA can seek legal counsel and take appropriate action to protect their rights.

HOA rules can be more restrictive than city laws

HOA rules and regulations are designed to ensure community cohesion and maintain property values. However, they must comply with local laws and cannot override or contradict city ordinances. While HOAs can have more restrictive rules than city laws, they cannot enforce rules that are contrary to federal, state, or local laws. For example, an HOA rule prohibiting overnight street parking would be overridden by a city ordinance that allows it within certain hours. Similarly, if an HOA rule bans solar panel installation, but state law gives homeowners the right to install them, the state law prevails.

HOA rules are outlined in the Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), provided to homeowners when purchasing property within the HOA. The CC&Rs cover various aspects of community living, including lawn maintenance, parking, vehicle storage, and pet ownership. They also address issues such as outside decor and lawn ornamentation, and the presence of firearms at community events or in communal areas.

While HOAs have a degree of autonomy in creating rules, they cannot infringe on residents' legal rights. For instance, they cannot prevent members from expressing their opinions or displaying political signs on their property, although they can regulate the timing, size, and placement of such signage. Similarly, while the HOA cannot prohibit residents from owning firearms, it can establish rules regarding firearms in communal areas.

To avoid potential legal issues, HOAs should partner with management companies or attorneys to ensure their rules are fair, enforceable, and compliant with federal, state, and local laws. It is crucial for HOAs to stay updated on changing laws and periodically review their rules to maintain compliance. By doing so, HOAs can maintain the balance between enforcing community standards and respecting the rights of their residents.

Frequently asked questions