Protecting Ideas: Can Intellectual Property Law Help?

Ideas are the foundation of business ventures, and entrepreneurs often seek to protect their ideas through intellectual property law. Intellectual property law (also known as IP law) protects creations of the human mind, including inventions, brands, original works of authorship, and valuable secret information. While ideas alone cannot be protected, the specific aspects and applications of an idea can be. This includes technical solutions to problems, names and logos of products, product forms, and literary works, art, and computer programs. Four types of intellectual property rights can be used to protect ideas: patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets. Each of these rights offers distinct protections for different types of intellectual property.

Patents, copyrights, trademarks, and trade secrets

Ideas can be protected by intellectual property law, but only in certain circumstances. Intellectual property law protects creations or ideas of the human mind that are given legal property rights. There are four main ways to protect an idea: patent law, copyright law, trademark law, and trade secret law. Each of these has a specific purpose and important limits to consider.

Patents are granted by the federal government, giving inventors the right to exclude others from making, using, or selling their inventions. However, patents do not protect "ideas"; they only protect the technological methods and processes of the idea as incorporated into an invention. To be eligible for a patent, an invention must be "novel" and "nonobvious", meaning it cannot be identical to prior or existing inventions. Patents are valid for a year, after which the information becomes public knowledge.

Copyright law protects specific expressions of an idea. It applies to original works fixed in a tangible medium, such as photographs, books, or music files. Copyright gives the owner the exclusive right to reproduce, prepare derivative works, distribute copies, perform, and display the work publicly. Copyright protection requires a minimal degree of creativity and does not extend to exact copies or replications of existing works. Copyrights can also protect computer programs and testing materials that contain trade secrets.

Trademarks are names, symbols, or logos that identify the maker of a product and distinguish it from others. They assist in advertising, promoting, and selling products by providing a consistent association with the product's characteristics and quality. Trademarks can be protected under both state and federal law, with federal registrations valid for 10-year renewable terms.

Trade secrets protect information that provides a competitive advantage to a company, such as client lists, secret formulas, and market strategies. Trade secrets are protected by law without the need for formal filing, as long as the company can show that it is using the secret and taking reasonable steps to maintain its secrecy. Trade secrets can be protected for much longer than patents, sometimes lasting for generations.

Trade secrets and confidentiality agreements

While ideas cannot be protected by intellectual property law, trade secret law is one of the four main ways to protect one's intellectual property, the other three being patent law, copyright law, and trademark law. Trade secrets are often protected by non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). NDAs are contracts in which the involved parties promise to protect the confidentiality of any disclosed secret information. They can be mutual, with both parties exchanging secrets, or one-way, where confidential information is disclosed to an employee to develop a product or grow a business.

NDAs can be used in a variety of situations, such as when a business is developing an invention but has not yet applied for a patent. They are also used when businesses share their trade secrets or confidential information with employees or third parties, such as franchisees, joint venture partners, or potential buyers. It is a sound business practice to have an experienced attorney draft an NDA, as they can anticipate how a court will view the agreement and make the language as strong as possible.

There are three basic approaches to defining the information covered by an NDA: providing a general description, a specific description, or marking/designating each item covered. Using a general description provides broad and flexible coverage, but may make enforcement more difficult in the event of a dispute. On the other hand, specific descriptions eliminate any debate about what is covered but are inflexible and require an amendment if a different type of confidential information is involved.

NDAs should state that they cover confidential and proprietary information, as well as trade secrets, to ensure the broadest protection of the information. The party receiving the information must agree to maintain the trade secrets in confidence and not breach the confidential relationship or induce others to acquire the secret through improper means. Additionally, NDAs often require the receiving party to limit the use of the information to specific situations authorized by the other party.

Five years is a common time period to maintain the confidentiality outlined in an NDA, although this is sometimes negotiated, especially when foreign companies are involved. Most NDAs also exclude certain information from protection, such as information created or discovered by the receiving party before receiving the trade secret or trade secrets learned from another company through a separate NDA.

Specific aspects and applications of an idea

While ideas cannot be protected by intellectual property law, the specific aspects and applications of an idea can be protected. This means that the idea itself is not subject to protection, but the concrete form or expression of the idea can be protected under patent law, copyright law, trademark law, or trade secret law.

For example, under patent law, the technical solutions to a problem can be protected. The exact instructions for arriving at the solution to a technical problem can be protected, as long as they meet the requirements of being "novel" and "nonobvious". This means that the invention must be unique and not identical to prior or existing inventions. Additionally, the instructions for the solution must be accurately described and cannot simply be an idea on paper or in one's mind.

Copyright law protects specific expressions of an idea rather than the idea itself. For instance, two artists painting the New York City skyline at dawn would be expected to have similar elements in their paintings, such as buildings and bridges, but the differences in their artistic choices, such as colours and shading, would be protected by copyright law. This law applies to literary works, art, and computer programs, where each artist or author has copyright protection over their unique creative work.

Trademark law protects the name of a product or a logo by associating it with the maker of the product. For example, the name "Coca-Cola" and its logo are protected trademarks that consumers can rely on to identify the maker and expect a certain level of quality.

Trade secret law protects valuable information that is not publicly known, such as business plans, customer lists, and research and development ideas. To establish trade secret protection, reasonable steps must be taken to maintain the secrecy of the information, such as allowing access only to those with a need to know and requiring nondisclosure agreements.

Technical solutions to a problem

While ideas alone cannot be protected by intellectual property law, there are several ways to protect the technical solutions to a problem. Here are some strategies to consider:

Patents

Patent law can protect the technological methods and processes of an idea as incorporated into an invention. To obtain a patent, the invention must be "novel" and "nonobvious," meaning it is not identical to prior or existing inventions and offers a unique solution to a technical problem. The exact instructions for arriving at the solution must be accurately described. It is important to note that patents are granted by the federal government and provide the right to exclude others from making, using, or selling the invention.

Trademarks

A trademark protects the name or logo associated with a product or service. It helps customers associate the product or service with its maker and provides information about its characteristics and quality. Trademarks can be protected under both state and federal law, and registration can be renewed every 10 years.

Copyrights

Copyright law protects specific expressions of an idea rather than the idea itself. It applies to literary works, art, and computer programs, among other creative works. To be valid, a copyright must contain a minimal degree of creativity and cannot be an exact copy of someone else's work.

Trade Secrets

Trade secret law protects valuable information that is not publicly known and has been reasonably maintained as confidential by its owner. This can include business plans, customer lists, and research and development ideas. To establish a trade secret, only those with a need to know should have access to the information, and disclosures should be made under nondisclosure agreements.

By utilizing these technical solutions, entrepreneurs and inventors can effectively protect their ideas and prevent others from stealing or exploiting their intellectual property.

Product name, logo, and design

Ideas and concepts can be protected under a number of different branches of intellectual property law. Copyright law, for instance, protects original works of authorship, such as novels, music, and works of art, but it does not protect names, phrases, logos, ideas, facts, systems, or methods of operation. Trademarks, on the other hand, protect names, products, services, and/or logos that are used to identify and distinguish goods and services from those of competitors. In the US, designers automatically own the copyright to their work, except in work-for-hire situations.

A product name can be protected by trademark law, which is intended to protect established businesses from infringers who want to trick consumers into buying their products or services by capitalizing on a stronger brand name. Trademarks can be registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, though it is not mandatory to trademark a business name, logo, URL, or other assets to start doing business. However, it can be challenging to make a case against copyright infringers if a trademark has not already been established.

A product logo can be protected by trademark law, which, as mentioned, protects names, products, services, and/or logos that distinguish goods and services. Trademarks can be registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, but they do not have to be to be used exclusively. However, registering a trademark is generally a good idea, as it ensures that a company name and all other pieces of branding are legally recognized as belonging to that company within the United States. To protect a logo abroad, a trademark must be registered in each country where business is conducted.

A product design can be protected by a design patent, which safeguards the ornamental design of a product, or its aesthetics, including its shape, appearance, looks, etc. Design patents can overlap with copyright law when functional objects have a distinctive appearance. Additionally, a product that is protected under patent law may also be protected under trademark if it is used to distinguish and identify the product from competitors.

Frequently asked questions