Imamate Eligibility: Illegitimate Children In Islamic Law

The status of an illegitimate child in Islamic law has a significant impact on the lives of the child and their parents, particularly the mother. Illegitimacy in Islam is determined by certain conditions, including illicit sexual relations (zina) between unmarried individuals or adultery with both parties being married, provided there are four witnesses. While Muslim law is silent on children born from rape, it is generally accepted that they are considered illegitimate. The question of whether an illegitimate child can be an imam under Islamic law is complex. While some scholars argue that it is makruh (disliked) for an illegitimate child to lead prayers due to concerns about their education and psychological state, others contend that if an illegitimate child is a scholar and distinguished among the congregation, there is no hindrance to them serving as an imam.

Illegitimate children's rights under Islamic law

Illegitimacy in Islam is determined by certain conditions, including zina, which refers to illicit sexual relations between two unmarried parties or adultery with both parties being married, as long as there are four witnesses to the act. If a child is born from zina, they are considered illegitimate and face a range of challenges and restrictions on their rights.

Under classical Muslim law and some modern Islamic jurisdictions, an illegitimate child has no right to inherit property from their father. This is because the child is considered to be a mahram to their mother, inheriting from her and her other children. However, under Hanafi law, the mother and her illegitimate children have mutual rights to inherit property, including from the mother's other relations.

The mother of an illegitimate child may face harsh punishments as a result of zina, and the child may struggle with social stigma and financial insecurities. The treatment and rights of illegitimate children under Muslim law are complex and vary depending on the school of thought. Some schools of thought, like the Shias and Sunnis, may provide limited rights, such as financial support, while others restrict their rights entirely.

The issue of attributing an illegitimate child to their father is a matter of scholarly debate. Some scholars argue that the child should not be attributed to the father, even if he acknowledges the child, while others believe that the child should be attributed to the father to protect the child's interests and ensure they are taken care of.

The role of DNA testing in determining paternity

Under Islamic law, a child born out of wedlock is considered illegitimate. Illegitimacy is determined based on certain conditions, such as illicit sexual relations (zina) between unmarried individuals or adultery with both parties being married, witnessed by four people. In cases without witnesses, only the woman is punished, and the child is still considered illegitimate.

Improvements in DNA technology have increased the accuracy of paternity tests, which is now up to 99.99%. This has expanded the application of testing methods, allowing for paternity determination using DNA from grandparents or cousins. DNA testing is valuable in criminal investigations, civil courts, and immigration cases, where it can provide concrete evidence of biological relationships.

In the context of Islamic law, DNA testing can have significant implications for illegitimate children. While an illegitimate child traditionally has no right to inherit property from their putative father, DNA testing can establish paternity beyond a doubt. This could potentially impact inheritance rights and the child's legal status, as acknowledged by scholars like 'Urwah ibn az-Zubayr and Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah.

However, it is important to note that the acceptance of DNA testing results may vary across different Islamic jurisdictions and schools of thought. While DNA testing provides scientific evidence, the interpretation and legal standing of such evidence may differ based on specific interpretations of Islamic law and local regulations.

The impact of illegitimacy on inheritance

Under classical Muslim law, an illegitimate child has no right to inherit property from their father. This is also the case in some modern Islamic jurisdictions. Illegitimacy in Islam is established when a child is born from illicit sexual relations, or zina, between two unmarried parties or when adultery is committed by married parties, provided there are four witnesses to the act. In such cases, the parties are subject to severe punishment as prescribed in the Quran. If there are no witnesses, only the woman shall be punished.

Under Hanafi law, the mother and her illegitimate children have mutual rights to inherit property. The illegitimate child can inherit not only the property of their mother but also the property of all other relations established through the mother. However, under Shia law, an illegitimate child does not inherit from the mother either and is completely excluded from inheritance from both parents.

Muslim law does not impose any obligation on either parent to provide for or maintain their illegitimate child. However, the father is required to pay for the maintenance of the child under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (previously Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973).

Islamic jurisprudence forbids any form of adoption that would grant the adoptee inheritance rights. Instead, Islam offers a unique approach to orphan care, known as Kafalah, which establishes a temporary arrangement where guardians are obliged to provide for the orphan's physical, emotional, and spiritual needs, as well as safeguard their property as trustees. This system ensures that orphans receive love and support while preserving their biological identity and connection to their heritage, including inheritance rights.

The role of the mother in an illegitimate child's life

Under Muslim law, the mother plays a significant role in the life of an illegitimate child. Firstly, it is important to note that the legitimacy of a child in Islamic law is determined by the relationship between the child's parents. Illegitimacy is established when the child is born out of illicit sexual relations, or zina, between unmarried individuals or when adultery is committed by married individuals, provided there are four witnesses to the act. If there are no witnesses, only the woman is punished, and the child is still considered illegitimate.

The mother of an illegitimate child may face harsh punishments for zina. Additionally, the child's status as illegitimate has significant implications for their rights and inheritance. Under classical Muslim law and some modern Islamic jurisdictions, an illegitimate child has no right to inherit property from their father. However, under Hanafi law, the mother and her illegitimate children have mutual inheritance rights. The illegitimate child inherits not only from their mother but also from other relations established through the mother.

In terms of custody and guardianship, Muslim law generally grants custody ("hizanat") to the mother, recognizing her as the best caregiver for the minor child. Guardianship ("wilayat") in Muslim law has four dimensions: wila-e-muhabbat (the right of love and devotion), wila-e-imamat (authority in spiritual guidance), wila-e-ziamat (authority in socio-political guidance), and the right of inheritance. While the biological father of an illegitimate child is not legally obligated to provide financial or emotional support, some scholars encourage him to step up and help, especially if his actions led to the child's birth.

Muslim scholars have differing opinions on the acknowledgment of illegitimate children by their fathers. Some scholars argue that the child should not be attributed to the father (zaani) even if acknowledged, while others support attribution if the father acknowledges the child. The mother, in such cases, becomes the primary figure in the child's life, with the child inheriting from her and being considered a mahram to her, similar to her other children.

Overall, the mother of an illegitimate child in Islamic law faces challenges due to the social and legal implications of zina. She plays a central role in the child's life, with the child inheriting from and being closely associated with her. The mother is also typically granted custody, emphasizing her critical role in the child's upbringing and protection.

The views of Islamic scholars on the matter

Islamic scholars have differing opinions on the matter of illegitimate children and their rights. The status of a child as legitimate or illegitimate has a significant impact on the lives of the child and their parents, especially the mother. Illegitimate children face numerous economic and social issues, including social stigma, lack of financial support, and non-acceptance by parents and families.

The majority view of scholars is that an illegitimate child, whether male or female, is not attributed to the father (zaani) but to the mother. This view holds that the child inherits from the mother and is considered a mahram to her. Fatwas supporting this view have been issued by prominent Islamic scholars. However, there is a difference of opinion among scholars regarding the zaani's acknowledgment of his illegitimate child. Some scholars, including 'Urwah ibn az-Zubayr, Sulaymaan ibn Yasaar, and al-Hasan al-Basri, argue that if the zaani acknowledges the child, the child should be attributed to him. This view considers the biological relationship between the father and the child, stating that there is no clear Islamic evidence to indicate otherwise.

The concept of walad zina in Islamic law refers to a person born out of wedlock or unlawful relationships. The term literally means "child of adultery" or "illegitimate child." While Muslim law does not explicitly address children born from rape, it is generally accepted that they are considered illegitimate. In such cases, the rapist is subject to punishment, and he may be required to pay a dower to the woman for child maintenance.

The rights of illegitimate children under Muslim law are limited. Classical Muslim law and some modern Islamic jurisdictions deny illegitimate children the right to inherit property from their fathers. However, under Hanafi law, the mother and her illegitimate children have mutual inheritance rights, allowing the child to inherit property from the mother and other relations through her.

The scholars Abu Hurayrah and Mujahid, among others, opposed the buying, selling, or freeing of illegitimate children from slavery, favoring participation in a holy war over this option. Additionally, there are differing opinions among scholars regarding the right of illegitimate children to testify, with some initially rejecting their testimony and others believing the circumstances of birth are irrelevant.

Frequently asked questions