Adverse Possession: Can Any Law Overrule This?

Adverse possession is a legal doctrine that allows a person to claim a property right in land owned by another. This principle of real estate law allows a person who possesses someone else's land for an extended period to claim legal title to that land. The requirements for adverse possession are governed by state statute and may vary significantly between jurisdictions. For example, California requires possession for only five years, while New York requires possession for 10 years to qualify as adverse possession. Generally, a disseisor cannot dispossess land legally owned by a government entity, even if all other elements of adverse possession are met.

Adverse possession and government-owned land

Adverse possession is a legal concept that allows a trespasser or squatter to gain legal title over someone else's land. The concept first developed in early Britain and has been kept alive to achieve a fair result when one owner has neglected or forgotten about a piece of land while another has been using or caring for it for so long that to make that person leave would seem unfair or create hardship. Adverse possession is commonly referred to as "squatters' rights" laws, since they are often invoked by squatters who inhabit land or structures otherwise left unused. The term "adverse" refers to the fact that those claiming land are doing so against the interests of the actual title holders.

In the case of government-owned land, a disseisor cannot dispossess land legally owned by a government entity even if all other elements of adverse possession are met. One exception is when the government entity is acting like a business rather than a government entity. A disseisor will be committing a civil trespass on the property he has taken, and the owner of the property could cause him to be evicted by an action in trespass ("ejectment") or by bringing an action for possession. All common law jurisdictions require that an ejectment action be brought within a specified time, after which the true owner is assumed to have acquiesced. The effect of a failure by the true landowner to evict the adverse possessor depends on the jurisdiction, but will eventually result in title by adverse possession.

In 2008, due to the volume of adverse possession and boundary dispute cases throughout New York City, the New York State Legislature amended and limited the ability to adversely possess government-owned land. Similarly, in the United States, Georgia lost an island in the Savannah River to South Carolina in 1990, when South Carolina had used fill from dredging to attach the island to its own shore. Since Georgia knew of this yet did nothing about it, the U.S. Supreme Court (which has original jurisdiction in such matters) granted this land to South Carolina, although the Treaty of Beaufort (1787) explicitly specified that the river's islands belonged to Georgia.

To prevent a trespasser from gaining ownership of their property, a landowner can take some measures such as identifying and marking their property boundaries, offering to rent the property to the trespasser, granting written permission to someone to use their land, and acting fast by hiring a lawyer as soon as they detect signs of trespassing on their land.

Adverse possession and homesteading

Adverse possession is a principle of real estate law that allows a person who possesses someone else's land for an extended period to claim legal title to that land. It is derived from French law and governs the right of a person to gain possession of immovable property (a home). Colloquially, it is referred to as squatter's rights. However, it is important to note that renters cannot be adverse possessors of the rented property, regardless of how long they possess it.

Adverse possession has certain requirements that need to be met. The possession of the property must be continuous and uninterrupted. The adverse possessor must demonstrate real or planned possession, which means that they must exclude all people from the land, but only by possession rather than ownership. The possession must be obvious to anyone who looks, so as to put the true owner on notice that a trespasser is in possession. The possessor must also prove non-permissive use of the property, which is actual, open, notorious, exclusive, adverse, and continuous for the statutory period. The statutory period varies by jurisdiction, with California requiring five years, New York requiring ten years, and Florida requiring seven years if under colour of title, or 20 years if not.

Homesteading is similar to adverse possession in practice. In homesteading, government-owned land or property with no clear owner on record is granted to new owners provided they are using and improving it. If a homesteader doesn't use the land, they can lose it. Adverse possession can operate in a similar way by freeing up land with an unclear title for productive use. However, adverse possession can be abused in ways that homesteading cannot. For example, if there is an informal easement between two farms, and one farmer’s fence contains an acre of the neighbour’s land, the farmer using it can claim adverse possession of that chunk of land if there is no written easement arrangement.

Adverse possession and intellectual property rights

Adverse possession is a principle of real estate law that allows a person who possesses someone else's land for an extended period to claim legal title to that land. The concept is derived from French law and governs the right of a person to gain possession of immovable property. Adverse possession laws are not static and vary by jurisdiction. While the common law requirements have evolved over time, a typical statute requires possession for 7 years if under colour of title, or 20 years if not. However, this duration varies by jurisdiction, with California requiring 5 years and New York requiring 10 years.

Adverse possession has been proposed as a possible solution to discourage abuses of intellectual property rights, such as cybersquatting, excessive copyright, and patent trolling. By applying adverse possession to intellectual property, abusers would be forced to actively use their portfolio of trademarks and patents rather than waiting for innovators to enter their territory. This proposal recognises that adverse possession, or squatter's rights, can be applied to other intellectual or digital/virtual property.

The dynamic nature of adverse possession and its potential relevance to intellectual property rights highlight the importance of understanding the historical roots, legal definitions, and real-world implications of this concept. While adverse possession has traditionally been associated with physical property, its extension to intellectual property rights underscores the evolving nature of property law and the need for proactive measures by landowners to protect their assets.

To prevent adverse possession of intellectual property rights, landowners can take similar measures as those for physical property, including identifying and marking their territory, inspecting their property regularly for signs of trespassers, and maintaining clear boundaries. Additionally, landowners can grant written permission for the use of their land and obtain written acknowledgment from the other party. These steps can help deter trespassers and strengthen the landowner's claim to their intellectual property rights.

In conclusion, adverse possession is a relevant and evolving aspect of property law that has implications for both physical and intellectual property rights. By understanding the historical context, legal definitions, and real-world applications of adverse possession, landowners can take proactive steps to safeguard their intellectual property rights and prevent adverse possession claims.

Adverse possession and squatters' rights

Adverse possession is a principle of real estate law that allows a person who occupies someone else's land for an extended period to claim legal ownership of that land. Colloquially, it is often referred to as squatter's rights, although the term "squatter's rights" lacks a precise and fixed legal meaning. In some jurisdictions, it refers to temporary rights that prevent squatters from being removed from a property without due process.

The requirements to prove adverse possession vary between jurisdictions. In many states, proof of payment for property taxes and a deed is required for a successful claim. Each state has a period during which the landowner of record can invalidate the claim at any time. For example, California requires possession for only five years, while New York requires possession for 10 years to qualify as adverse possession. The adverse possessor must also prove that their possession of the property is non-permissive, actual, open, notorious, exclusive, adverse, and continuous for the statutory period. The statutory period may vary from three to 30 years, depending on the state.

To prevent adverse possession, landowners can take several measures, including identifying and marking property boundaries, regularly inspecting their land for signs of trespassers, and blocking entrances with gates. Additionally, granting written permission or offering to rent the property to a trespasser can help establish the owner's control over the property and prevent adverse possession claims.

Adverse possession may also apply to territorial rights, as seen in the case of Georgia losing an island in the Savannah River to South Carolina due to adverse possession. It can also be applied to intellectual or digital/virtual property to prevent abuses of intellectual property rights.

Adverse possession and preventing trespassers from claiming ownership

Adverse possession is a legal process that allows a non-owner occupant of a piece of land to gain title and ownership of that land after a certain period of time. This principle of real estate law is derived from French law and governs the right of a person to gain possession of immovable property. Colloquially, it is known as "squatter's rights".

To claim adverse possession, a trespasser must meet specific legal requirements, such as continuous and hostile occupation, open use, and exclusive possession for a statutory period. The statutory period varies by jurisdiction, with California requiring possession for five years and New York requiring ten.

To prevent trespassers from claiming ownership through adverse possession, landowners should take proactive measures such as monitoring and maintaining their property boundaries, addressing trespassers promptly, and ensuring clear agreements with others using their land. Posting "no trespassing" signs, blocking entrances with gates, and keeping records of property tax payments can also help deter trespassers and protect against potential claims.

Additionally, granting written permission to someone to use your land and obtaining their written acknowledgment can be an effective strategy. This demonstrates that the land is yours and that the other person is only using it with your consent, which can defeat adverse possession claims. In some cases, offering to rent the property to a trespasser with a proper rental agreement in place can also prevent them from claiming adverse possession.

Frequently asked questions