Arizona's Law: Contradicting The Us Constitution?

The United States is a Union of sovereign States, and Arizona, like other States, has its own state laws, including the Arizona Constitution, laws passed by the Arizona legislature, and decisions by courts that interpret Arizona laws. However, the US Constitution is the supreme law of the land to which all government, state and federal, is subject. This means that Arizona cannot pass a law that contradicts the US Constitution. Arizona's laws and constitution are often interpreted by the Arizona Supreme Court and the Arizona Court of Appeals, and ultimately, the US Supreme Court may review a case that has been appealed from the Ninth Circuit or the Arizona Supreme Court.

Arizona's sovereignty to exclude people from its territory

Arizona, like other states, is a part of the indivisible "Union of sovereign States" that form the United States. This means that while Arizona is subject to the US Constitution, the supreme law of the land, it also has the inherent power to exclude persons from its territory. This power is subject to limitations imposed by the Constitution or Congress.

In the case of Arizona v. United States, the state of Arizona moved to protect its sovereignty, arguing that it was not contradicting federal law but rather enforcing federal immigration restrictions more effectively. Arizona's SB 1070 law made it a state misdemeanour for an illegal immigrant to be in Arizona without carrying registration documents and penalised those found to be knowingly sheltering, hiring, and transporting illegal immigrants. This sparked constitutional concerns over potential civil rights violations and the encouragement of racial profiling.

The United States Justice Department challenged Arizona's law, arguing that it usurped the federal government's authority to regulate immigration laws and enforcement. The Department of Justice also argued that certain provisions conflicted with federal law enforcement objectives. However, the Supreme Court upheld Section 2(B) of the law, which stated that law enforcement officers "may not consider race, colour or national origin in implementing the requirements of this subsection except to the extent permitted by the United States or Arizona Constitution."

Justice Scalia, in his dissent, supported Arizona's inherent power to exclude persons from its territory, a characteristic of sovereignty. He also noted that the States would not have agreed to ratify the Constitution if it included a provision that prevented them from taking action to defend their borders. This case highlights the ongoing debate over state sovereignty and the enforcement of immigration laws, with several other states jointly filing a brief in support of Arizona.

Arizona's contradiction of federal law

The Constitution of the United States is the supreme law of the land, to which all government, state and federal, is subject. This means that Arizona cannot pass a law that contradicts the US Constitution.

However, Arizona, like other states, has its own state laws, which include the Arizona Constitution, laws passed by the Arizona legislature, and decisions by courts that interpret Arizona laws. The Arizona Constitution was drafted in 1910, two years before Arizona became a state, and it has been the only constitution in the state's history.

While Arizona cannot directly contradict federal law, it does have some powers of sovereignty. For example, Arizona has the inherent power to exclude persons from its territory, subject to limitations expressed in the US Constitution or imposed by Congress. In the case of Arizona v. United States, the Supreme Court considered whether Arizona contradicted federal law by enforcing applications of the Immigration Act that the President declined to enforce. The Court's opinion suggested that if Arizona could give itself independent authority to prosecute federal registration violations, it would undermine federal authority.

Despite this, Arizona and other states have the power to propose and pass measures and amendments to their constitutions, which can include laws that differ from federal laws as long as they do not directly contradict the US Constitution.

Arizona's state laws

Arizona, like other states, has its own state laws. The Arizona Constitution was drafted in 1910, two years before Arizona officially became a state. It is the only constitution in the state's history and has been updated to include revised sections from the 55th Legislature, 1st Regular Session.

The Arizona Constitution is the foundation of the state's legal system, and it outlines the rights and responsibilities of the state government and its citizens. It provides the processes for amending it, which include ballot initiatives, amendments proposed by the state legislature, and constitutional conventions. Before an initiative petition can appear on a ballot, it must be signed by qualified electors totalling at least 15% of the votes cast for governor candidates in the previous election. If an amendment is proposed by the state legislature, a majority of each chamber must approve it before placing it on a statewide ballot.

The Arizona Revised Statutes contain the laws passed by the Arizona Legislature, and these laws are periodically updated and codified. The Arizona Supreme Court and the Arizona Court of Appeals, consisting of two divisions, often interpret these statutes and the provisions of the Arizona Constitution. The federal Arizona District Court also issues decisions that affect Arizona residents.

In the case of a conflict between Arizona state laws and the US Constitution, the US Constitution takes precedence as the supreme law of the land. Arizona, as a sovereign state, has the power to exclude persons from its territory, but this power is limited by the constraints expressed in the US Constitution or imposed by Congress.

Arizona's constitution

The United States Constitution is the supreme law of the land, and all government, state and federal, is subject to it. However, as a sovereign state, Arizona has the power to pass laws that contradict federal laws, as long as they do not violate the US Constitution or laws passed by Congress. This power of the state is recognised as inherent in sovereignty.

The Arizona Constitution is the state constitution of Arizona, which outlines the state's framework for governance, including the powers, structure, and limitations of the state government, individual and civil rights, and other matters. Arizona's constitution has been amended far more frequently than the federal Constitution because it was designed to be responsive to the wishes of local citizens. The current constitution was adopted in 1912 and has been amended 161 times since then. The most recent amendment was approved by voters on November 5, 2024.

The Arizona Constitution provides for three methods of amending the document: a citizen-initiated process, a legislative process, and a state constitutional convention. A simple majority is required to approve constitutional amendments, while a 60% vote is needed to pass ballot measures related to taxes. The constitution also includes provisions for the removal of members from office, the powers and privileges of the legislature, and the rights of citizens, such as the right to engage in industrial pursuits and the prohibition of discrimination in certain areas.

While Arizona has the power to pass laws that contradict federal laws, it is important to note that the US Constitution and federal laws take precedence over state laws. In the case of a conflict between federal and state laws, the US Supreme Court has the authority to determine which law prevails.

Arizona's governor's role in passing a bill

The United States Constitution is the supreme law of the land, and all government, state, and federal laws are subject to it. While Arizona, as a sovereign state, has the power to pass laws that contradict federal laws, these laws cannot contradict the US Constitution.

The Arizona State Legislature is a bicameral body with 30 members in the Senate and 60 members in the House of Representatives. The Arizona governor is elected by popular vote to a four-year term and can serve a maximum of two consecutive terms. The governor's duties include signing bills into law or allowing them to become law without signing them. Every bill passed by the legislature must be presented to the governor for approval. If the governor approves, they sign the bill, and it becomes a law. If the governor disapproves, they return the bill to the originating house, along with their objections.

The governor also has the authority to sign executive orders and call the Legislature into Special session for urgent action. They can grant reprieves, commutations, and pardons (except in cases of treason and impeachment). The governor is also the Commander in Chief of Arizona's National Guard and is responsible for informing the budgeting process, appointing state directors and justices, and replacing vacated Senate seats.

Frequently asked questions