The Legal Double Standard Of Racism Against Blacks

Racism is a highly debated topic, with varying definitions and perspectives. While some argue that racism is defined as prejudice against or hatred toward another race, others believe it involves systemic power dynamics that perpetuate discrimination and exclusion. This raises the question of whether individuals or specific racial groups, such as Blacks, can be legally considered racist. The answer depends on the definition of racism and the broader context of historical and structural power imbalances. While individual Black people can exhibit racial prejudice or discrimination, the broader concept of racism is often understood in the context of institutionalized power dynamics that have disadvantaged specific racial groups.

Black Americans' views on racial inequality

According to a 2021 survey by the Pew Research Center, 65% of Black Americans believe that the increased national attention on racial inequality has not led to changes that have improved their lives. Furthermore, 44% of respondents believe that equality for Black people in the United States is unlikely to be achieved. This is a shift from September 2020, when half of Black adults believed that the heightened focus on racial issues would result in significant policy changes to address racial inequality.

The survey also revealed that Black Americans are concerned about racial discrimination and its impact, with 79% reporting that they have personally experienced discrimination due to their race or ethnicity. Black Democrats are more likely to attribute the difficulties faced by Black people in the US to racial discrimination, with 73% asserting that it is the primary reason many Black individuals cannot get ahead. In contrast, 44% of Black Republicans share this view.

Additionally, Black Democrats are more critical of US institutions, expressing greater dissatisfaction with the prison system (57% vs. 35%), policing (52% vs. 29%), and the courts and judicial process (50% vs. 35%). They are also more inclined to advocate for large-scale changes to the criminal justice system.

Racial inequality in the United States encompasses various aspects of life, including economic inequality and disparities in wealth, education, employment, housing, mobility, health, and rates of incarceration. Black Americans are overrepresented among the population in poverty, and the racial wealth gap has widened in recent decades. Black individuals also face challenges in accessing quality healthcare, as evidenced by higher rates of chronic illness and increased COVID-19 mortality rates compared to their white counterparts.

In terms of legal protections, federal anti-discrimination laws in the United States prohibit discrimination in housing, credit, employment, and "public accommodations" such as restaurants, movie theaters, parks, and trains. Individuals who believe they have been subjected to intentional discrimination can file a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights or seek assistance from local civil or human rights agencies.

Racism as defined by power

The concept of racism and power is a highly debated topic. Some argue that racism is inseparable from power and privilege, implying that only those with power and privilege can be racist. This perspective asserts that racism is deeply rooted in societal structures that advantage certain groups, typically those defined as "white," over others.

From this perspective, racism is not merely individual prejudice but a systemic issue. It involves the widespread acceptance of racist ideologies and the power to exclude or disadvantage other racial groups in economic, cultural, and political institutions. This power dynamic is often referred to as "white power" or "white privilege," which perpetuates the idea that behaviours and values associated with whiteness are superior or more normal than those of other races.

However, others argue that this perspective gives a "free pass" to racial minorities, allowing them to hold prejudices and act in discriminatory ways against those with power and privilege. They argue that racism can exist at the individual level, where anyone, regardless of their race, can hold racist beliefs or engage in racist actions.

The term "internalized racism" describes a situation where a racial group oppressed by racism inadvertently supports the dominance of the oppressing group. This can occur through participation in the attitudes, behaviours, social structures, and ideologies that uphold the power of the dominant group. For example, members of the oppressed group may come to believe that the dominant group knows better or is more competent, leading to a lack of support for each other's authority.

In conclusion, the relationship between racism and power is complex and multifaceted. While some argue that racism is inherently tied to power and privilege, implying that only certain groups can be racist, others emphasize the existence of individual prejudices and discriminatory actions that can occur regardless of one's position in the social hierarchy.

Anti-black racism

In the United States, racism against African Americans has deep roots in the colonial era and the legacy of slavery. Despite the civil rights movement and the gradual outlawing of formal racial discrimination, racism against Black Americans remains widespread. This includes a history of violent racism perpetrated by hate groups such as the Ku Klux Klan, as well as systemic racism in institutions like education, law enforcement, and the legal system. For instance, anti-miscegenation laws, which forbade marriage and even sex between whites and non-whites, existed in many states until 1967. Additionally, the War on Drugs has been criticized as racially motivated, with sentencing guidelines disproportionately impacting African Americans.

In Britain, Black people have faced racist violence from far-right groups and racist chanting at football matches. While racism in Britain is considered to have declined over time, it continues to shape the experiences of Black immigrants and their sense of identity. Similarly, in Australia, Indigenous Australians, including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, have endured explicit and implicit racial discrimination since colonization. They continue to face racist government policies and community attitudes, contributing to socioeconomic inequality.

The fight against anti-black racism requires a commitment to anti-racism, which involves actively striving for equality for all races and working to undo racism in institutions and societal norms. This includes recognizing the impact of historical injustices and addressing the underlying structures that perpetuate racial inequality. By understanding the complex interplay of individual prejudices, institutional practices, and societal attitudes, we can begin to dismantle anti-black racism and create a more just and equitable world for all.

Racial prejudices

Racism is a form of prejudice that includes negative emotional reactions, acceptance of negative stereotypes, and discrimination against individuals. Discrimination involves negative, hostile, and injurious treatment of members of rejected groups. Racial prejudice is defined as the belief in the inherent inferiority of non-White racial groups, particularly Black individuals, accompanied by support for segregation and discrimination. Old-fashioned racism, which prevailed among Whites until a few decades ago, is based on the assumption of the inherent inferiority of non-White racial groups. Blacks, in particular, were assumed to be inferior in intelligence and other characteristics. This belief was accompanied by support for racial segregation and discrimination.

While old-fashioned racism has become relatively uncommon, it has been replaced by contemporary forms of racism, including ambivalent racism, aversive racism, and symbolic racism. Contemporary racists believe that African Americans violate American values such as individualism and self-reliance. They acknowledge that racial discrimination existed in the past but claim that it is no longer an issue. As a result, they attribute any economic disadvantages experienced by Blacks to their cultural inferiority.

Some scholars argue that blacks and other racial minorities cannot be racist because they lack the power and privilege to systematically exclude others from opportunities and rewards in major institutions. However, others argue that individuals of all races can hold racial prejudices and act in discriminatory ways.

In terms of legality, federal anti-discrimination laws in the United States prohibit discrimination in housing, credit, employment, and "public accommodations" like restaurants, movie theaters, parks, and trains. Discrimination can be intentional or unintentional and can take many forms, including disparate impact, where policies cause unjustified and disproportionate harm to specific racial groups. Individuals who believe they have been discriminated against can file complaints with government agencies or civil rights organizations, which may result in monetary damages, opportunities for reconsideration, or policy changes.

Federal laws against discrimination

Federal laws in the United States prohibit discrimination based on race, colour, religion, disability, sex, national origin, age, and familial status. These laws are enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and make it illegal for employers, housing or credit providers, and public accommodations to discriminate against individuals on the basis of these protected characteristics.

The Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, protects employees and job applicants from employment discrimination based on race, colour, religion, sex, and national origin. It covers the full spectrum of employment decisions, including recruitment, selections, terminations, and other terms and conditions of employment. Federal anti-discrimination laws also prohibit discrimination in housing, credit, and "public accommodations" such as restaurants, movie theatres, parks, and trains.

The Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended, protects employees and job applicants from employment discrimination based on disability. This law requires federal agencies to make reasonable accommodations for individuals with known disabilities, unless doing so would cause undue hardship. Additionally, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits discrimination against individuals with disabilities in all areas of public life, including employment, transportation, public accommodations, communications, and access to public services.

The Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice enforces federal laws that prohibit discrimination in education, employment, housing, lending, public accommodations, law enforcement, and voting. If an individual believes they have been discriminated against because of their race, colour, religion, disability, sex, national origin, or familial status, they can file a complaint with the Civil Rights Division or seek assistance from the National Origin Working Group, which helps citizens and immigrants understand and exercise their legal rights.

Frequently asked questions