Building Heights And Zoning Laws: Who Decides?

Zoning laws are a critical aspect of construction that govern how and where buildings can be developed. They dictate the maximum height of buildings, the minimum amount of green space, minimum lot sizes, and setbacks from property lines. These regulations can be used to protect the character of a neighbourhood, prevent congestion, or prevent commercial development in residential areas. Height limits are often justified for protection from fire hazards, protection against aviation accidents, protection of views, and preservation of older buildings or landmarks.

Height limits and zoning codes

Determining Height Limits:

Height limits are typically determined by measuring the vertical distance between the average graded ground level on each side of a proposed building and the roof's highest point. This calculation can be complex for buildings on uneven terrain or with unique roof designs. Each zoning code includes specific metrics to address these challenges.

Reasons for Height Restrictions:

Height restrictions serve various purposes, including aesthetic, practical, and safety considerations:

• Aesthetic Values: Height limits can help maintain a city's architectural heritage and protect the character of a neighbourhood. In some cases, restrictions are imposed to preserve views of important landmarks or natural features, such as the Parthenon in Athens or the ridge line in Hong Kong.
• Practical Purposes: Height restrictions may be implemented around airports to ensure flight safety. For example, buildings near Subang International Airport in Malaysia were previously limited to 160-200 feet (50-60 meters) in height.
• Safety: Height limits can also protect against fire hazards and aviation accidents. Additionally, they can influence the design and architectural style of buildings to align with historical zoning laws and preserve a neighbourhood's character.

Impact on Development:

Zoning regulations significantly impact property values and development potential. Well-regulated zones with desirable uses tend to have higher property values. In contrast, restrictive zoning may limit a property's potential use and reduce its market value. For developers, navigating zoning codes is essential to ensure compliance and optimize their projects' value.

Global Perspectives:

Height restriction laws vary globally and are often specific to individual cities or regions. While Europe has no general law restricting building heights, many European cities have height restrictions to protect historic skylines. In contrast, countries like China and Canada have implemented height restrictions based on city population sizes and proximity to airports, respectively.

Height restrictions and aviation safety

Zoning laws often dictate the maximum height of buildings in a given area. These height limits are typically justified for protection from fire hazards, against aviation accidents, protection of view, and preservation of the character of the neighbourhood.

Height restrictions around airports are crucial for flight safety. For example, buildings in Petaling Jaya, Kelana Jaya, were previously capped at 15 floors due to their proximity to Subang International Airport. Similarly, structures in Davao City are restricted to 100 m (330 ft) above mean sea level due to their proximity to Francisco Bangoy International Airport. In Shenzhen Bay, buildings are capped at 400 m (1,300 ft) due to their proximity to Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport.

Height restrictions near airports are essential to ensure safe take-off and landing procedures for aircraft. These restrictions help maintain clear flight paths, prevent obstacles, and minimise potential hazards to aircraft and people on the ground. Additionally, height limits near airports can help reduce noise pollution for nearby residents and ensure that emergency services have unobstructed access to the airport in the event of an accident or incident.

While there are no specific height requirements for pilots in civil aviation, some small aircraft may not accommodate extremely tall individuals. In military aviation, each branch of the US military has its own height specifications based on aircraft design and safety factors. However, exceptions and waivers are available, and skill is generally considered more important than height in aviation.

Building height and zoning laws' impact on property values

Zoning laws, which are established at the local government level, govern how a piece of property can be used or developed based on geographic location. They dictate the maximum height of buildings, the minimum amount of green space, minimum lot sizes, and setbacks from property lines. These laws can have a significant impact on property values.

In some cases, zoning regulations may protect property values by preventing unwanted development. For example, residential areas may be protected from commercial or industrial development, which could otherwise lower property values by increasing noise, traffic, or pollution. Similarly, zoning laws that preserve open spaces, parks, and natural resources can positively impact property values by enhancing the attractiveness and livability of a community.

On the other hand, zoning regulations that limit building heights or require large setbacks can restrict the amount of usable space on a property, reducing its development potential and overall value. Properties with flexible zoning that allows for high-density development or mixed-use often have higher market values due to the potential for increased economic activity and amenities.

Zoning laws can also impact property values by influencing the character and desirability of a neighborhood. For example, strict residential zoning can maintain a quiet, family-friendly environment, enhancing property values. Conversely, allowing mixed-use or industrial activities in a residential area may decrease property values. Additionally, height restrictions may serve aesthetic values, such as preserving the view of important landmarks or maintaining a city's architectural heritage. However, these restrictions can also reduce housing supply and increase costs, negatively impacting property values.

It is important for property buyers and investors to understand the zoning laws in their area, as they can change over time due to shifts in community needs, urban development, or political decisions. Staying informed about potential zoning changes can help individuals make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes.

Height limits and preservation of historical skylines

Height limits are often used to preserve historical skylines and protect important views. In Athens, for example, buildings are limited to twelve floors to protect the view of the Parthenon. Similarly, in Rome, no building can exceed the height of the dome of St. Peter's Basilica. Other cities, like Montreal and Ottawa-Gatineau in Canada, have height limits to protect the view of Mount Royal and the Peace Tower, respectively. In the United States, Washington, D.C., has famously restrictive height limits set by Congress to preserve its iconic skyline, including the view of important landmarks. Boston also has height limits to prevent shadows from being cast on historic landmarks and public parks, such as Boston Common.

Height limits can also be used to protect views of natural features, such as in Hamilton, where buildings cannot exceed the height of the Niagara Escarpment to preserve the view of Lake Ontario. Saskatoon in Canada has a height limit due to a flight path that bisects the downtown core. Similarly, Davao City in the Philippines has a height restriction due to its proximity to Francisco Bangoy International Airport. In some cases, height limits may be lifted if the airport is relocated or closed, as happened in Petaling Jaya, Malaysia, and Edmonton, Canada.

While height limits can help preserve historical skylines and protect views, they can also be a source of contention. Critics argue that they restrict housing supply, increase housing costs, and depress land values. In the case of Philadelphia, historical preservationists have criticized the level of new development, while others have argued that the city's height limits artificially inflate land values, making development too expensive.

Finding a balance between preserving historical skylines and allowing for modern development can be challenging. Some cities, like Paris, London, and Milan, have managed to blend older, iconic buildings with modern skyscrapers. In Paris, for instance, the La Defense district features skyscrapers while preserving the city's historical core. London has also undergone a radical transformation, with St. Paul's Cathedral now just one component of the cityscape.

Ultimately, height limits can be a useful tool for preserving historical skylines and protecting views, but they must be carefully considered in the context of a city's unique characteristics and needs.

Height regulations in residential districts

One of the key factors influencing height regulations in residential districts is the desire to protect the character and aesthetics of the neighbourhood. This includes maintaining views, preserving historic skylines, and ensuring that new developments blend in with the existing housing. For example, height restrictions in places like Athens aim to prevent buildings from blocking views of important landmarks like the Parthenon. Similarly, in Washington, D.C., height limits are intended to protect views of Mount Hood and the West Hills.

Height regulations can also serve practical purposes, such as ensuring flight safety around airports. In the case of Petaling Jaya, Malaysia, height restrictions were previously imposed due to the proximity to Subang International Airport. These restrictions were lifted when the airport relocated, allowing for taller buildings to be constructed. Similarly, Davao City in the Philippines has height restrictions in place due to its proximity to Francisco Bangoy International Airport.

In addition to aesthetic and practical considerations, height regulations in residential districts can also be used to control population density and protect light and air access. In some cases, limiting the number of stories may be suggested as a way to regulate population density. However, in single-family districts, the maximum number of families is more effectively controlled by the number of lots rather than the number of stories. Requirements on lot area per dwelling unit or control of floor area ratios can also establish maximum potential density in multiple-family districts.

Height regulations can also vary based on the slope or terrain of the land. For example, in very low-density agricultural areas, maximum lot coverage on slopes decreases as the slope percentage increases, reducing land occupancy and disturbance of natural terrain. Similarly, in hillside areas, height restrictions may be established to address specific conditions and ensure that buildings do not protrude against the skyline.

Overall, height regulations in residential districts are an essential aspect of zoning laws, aiming to balance practical, aesthetic, and community needs while also taking into account the unique characteristics of the area. These regulations can vary widely depending on the specific location, and they play a crucial role in shaping the development and character of residential neighbourhoods.

Frequently asked questions