City Council Vs State Law: Who Has The Final Say?

In the United States, local laws may be able to override state laws in certain circumstances, depending on the jurisdiction and the specific legal issues involved. For example, a state may have a minimum wage law, but allow cities within the state to set a higher minimum wage if they so choose. In this situation, the local ordinance would effectively override the state law within that particular jurisdiction. However, a city cannot pass a law that overrides a state or federal law. Instead, a city might decide to simply not make enforcement of certain laws a priority.

Local laws can override state laws in certain circumstances, depending on the jurisdiction and the specific legal issues involved

In some cases, state law explicitly grants local governments the authority to adopt ordinances that are more stringent than state law. However, a city cannot pass a law that overrides a state or federal law. For instance, if a state without the State Supremacy style were to write an anti-abortion law, they would likely write it so the law was absolute and did not allow cities to skirt around it.

In other cases, a city might decide to simply not make enforcement of certain laws a priority. Marijuana is a great example of this. It's illegal in the federal system and in many states, however, there are cities where the police will, for the most part, turn a blind eye to it and focus enforcement on other areas considered more important. So long as the city doesn't come out and say "it is our policy to defy state or federal law", it would be hard to prove that lack of enforcement is not simply a matter of limited resources at the city level.

State law may explicitly grant local governments the authority to adopt ordinances that are more stringent than state law

In some cases, state law may explicitly grant local governments the authority to adopt ordinances that are more stringent than state law. For example, a state may have a minimum wage law, but allow cities within the state to set a higher minimum wage if they so choose. In this situation, the local ordinance would effectively override the state law within that particular jurisdiction.

However, it is important to note that a city cannot pass a law that explicitly overrides a state or federal law. Instead, a city might decide to simply not make the enforcement of certain laws a priority. For example, marijuana is illegal in the federal system and in many states, but there are cities where police will, for the most part, turn a blind eye to it and focus their enforcement efforts on other areas. As long as the city does not come out and say "it is our policy to defy state or federal law", it would be hard to prove that the lack of enforcement is not simply a matter of limited resources at the city level.

Ultimately, the ability of local laws to override state laws depends on the jurisdiction and the specific legal issues involved. If a state were to write an anti-abortion law, for instance, they would likely write it so that the law was absolute and did not allow cities to skirt around it.

A city might decide not to enforce certain laws, such as marijuana laws, without explicitly defying state or federal law

In some cases, state law explicitly grants local governments the authority to adopt ordinances that are more stringent than state law. For instance, a state may have a minimum wage law but allow cities within the state to set a higher minimum wage if they so choose. In this situation, the local ordinance would effectively override the state law within that particular jurisdiction. However, it is important to note that a city cannot pass a law that overrides a state or federal law.

A state without the State Supremacy style would likely write an anti-abortion law so it was absolute and not allow cities to skirt around it

In the US, local laws may have the ability to override state laws in certain circumstances, depending on the jurisdiction and the specific legal issues involved. For example, a state may have a minimum wage law, but allow cities within the state to set a higher minimum wage if they so choose. In this situation, the local ordinance would effectively override the state law within that particular jurisdiction.

However, a city cannot pass a law that overrides a state or federal law. For example, a city might decide to simply not make enforcement of certain laws a priority. Marijuana is illegal in the federal system and in many states, but there are cities where the police will turn a blind eye to it and focus enforcement on other areas.

If a state without the State Supremacy style were to write an anti-abortion law, they would likely write it so the law was absolute and not allow cities to skirt around it. This means that cities within the state would not be able to override the state law and would have to enforce it.

New York state allowed individual counties to choose whether to legalise fireworks, which appeared to override state law

In some cases, state law explicitly grants local governments the authority to adopt ordinances that are more stringent than state law. For example, a state may have a minimum wage law, but allow cities within the state to set a higher minimum wage if they so choose. In this situation, the local ordinance would effectively override the state law within that particular jurisdiction.

In New York State, the only types of fireworks that are legal are "sparkling devices". These generate coloured sparks and other displays without making any sort of loud explosion or launching into the air. This includes things like ground spinners, fountains, and sparklers. Sparkling fireworks are among the least dangerous types of fireworks. However, even though sparkling devices are permitted by state law, each county has the discretion to determine whether or not to permit them. Counties like New York County, Columbia, Westchester, Nassau, Bronx, Richmond and Suffolk Queens have banned sparklers. Wayne and Ontario Counties have also legalised the purchase, sale, and usage of sparklers. In Rochester, if you are holding a special event or a block party that utilises fireworks, you must apply for a special event permit before a certain deadline.

In some cases, a city might decide to simply not make enforcement of certain laws a priority. Marijuana is a great example of this. It's illegal in the federal system and in many states, however, there are cities where the police will for the most part turn a blind eye to it and focus enforcement on other areas considered more important. So long as the city doesn't come flat out and say "it is our policy to defy state or federal law" it would be hard to prove that lack of enforcement is not simply a matter of limited resources at the city level.

Frequently asked questions