Banning Assault Weapons: Can Congress Pass Such A Law?

The Federal Assault Weapons Ban, a United States federal law prohibiting the manufacture of certain semi-automatic firearms for civilian use, expired in 2004. Since then, there have been multiple attempts to renew the ban, including the Assault Weapons Ban of 2022 and 2023, but none have succeeded. This paragraph will explore the potential for Congress to pass a law banning assault weapons, examining the challenges and impact of previous legislation.

The Federal Assault Weapons Ban expired in 2004

The Federal Assault Weapons Ban, passed in 1994, expired on September 13, 2004, due to its sunset provision. This provision meant that the ban would automatically expire after 10 years unless it was renewed with another vote. The ban prohibited the manufacture, transfer, or possession of "semiautomatic assault weapons", as defined by the Act, and included more than a dozen specific firearms and guns with certain features. It also banned "transfer or possession" of large-capacity ammunition devices that could carry more than 10 bullets.

Since the ban's expiration, there have been efforts in Congress to enact a new assault weapons ban, but these attempts have failed. This includes an attempt by former President Clinton to reinstate the ban in 2019 following deadly shootings in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio. In 2021, President Biden called on Congress to pass gun control legislation, including a ban on assault weapons, after shootings in Boulder and Atlanta.

The impact of the Federal Assault Weapons Ban has been debated, with some studies suggesting a reduction in the homicide rate during its implementation, while others found inconclusive evidence of an effect on total homicides. However, a 2013 study showed that the expiration of the ban led to immediate violence increases in areas of Mexico close to American states where sales of assault weapons became legal.

While the Federal Assault Weapons Ban has expired, some states, like California, have their own laws banning certain assault weapons by specific type, series, and model, as well as the firearm's general characteristics. California law also prohibits the sale of large-capacity magazines, defined as those able to accept more than ten rounds.

Congress has failed to pass a new assault weapons ban since

Congress has failed to pass a new federal assault weapons ban since the previous ban expired in 2004. The Federal Assault Weapons Ban, enacted in 1994, prohibited the manufacture, transfer, and possession of certain semi-automatic firearms and large-capacity ammunition magazines. However, due to a 10-year "sunset" clause, the ban expired on September 13, 2004.

Since then, there have been multiple efforts to enact a new assault weapons ban, but none have been successful. In 2013, following the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, Senator Feinstein introduced the Assault Weapons Ban of 2013 (AWB 2013). This bill was similar to the 1994 ban but did not include an expiration date and used a one-feature test to qualify a firearm as an assault weapon. Despite approval from the Senate Judiciary Committee, the bill ultimately failed to pass in the Senate.

In 2021, President Joe Biden proposed a new ban on assault weapons after the Atlanta spa shootings and the Boulder shooting. This led to the introduction of the Assault Weapons Ban of 2022 in Congress, which aimed to prohibit the importation, sale, manufacture, transfer, or possession of semiautomatic assault weapons. However, this bill also failed to become law.

The most recent attempt is the Assault Weapons Ban of 2023, which seeks to criminalize the import, sale, manufacture, transfer, or possession of semiautomatic assault weapons or large-capacity ammunition feeding devices. The outcome of this bill remains to be seen.

The failure to pass a new federal assault weapons ban has resulted in a lack of nationwide restrictions on certain semi-automatic firearms. While some states, like California, have implemented their own bans on assault weapons, the absence of a federal ban allows for the lawful possession of previously banned firearms in many parts of the country.

California law bans certain assault weapons

California has some of the strictest gun laws in the United States. The California Supreme Court has maintained that most of these laws are constitutional as the state's constitution does not explicitly guarantee private citizens the right to purchase, possess, or carry firearms.

California law currently bans certain assault weapons by specific type, series, and model, as well as by the firearm's general characteristics. These are divided into three categories. Category One bans assault weapons by type, series, and model, including the Beretta AR-70, Springfield Armory BM59 and SAR-48, Steyer AUG, Sterling MK-6, and the Bushmaster Assault Rifle. Category Two bans firearm models that are variations of the AK or AR-15, with only minor differences from those two models. Category Three bans assault weapons by general characteristics, including any semi-automatic, centerfire rifle that does not have a fixed magazine but has specific features such as a pistol grip, a thumbhole stock, or a grenade launcher.

In addition to banning certain assault weapons, California law also prohibits the sale of large-capacity magazines, defined as magazines able to accept more than ten rounds. The state also heavily restricts the sale and possession of other items regarded as dangerous weapons, including certain knives, swords, clubs, explosives, fireworks, bows and arrows, slingshots, spears, and nunchucks.

It is unlawful for a California citizen to possess a Title II weapon (NFA firearms) such as a fully automatic firearm or a short-barreled shotgun/rifle without a license issued by the DOJ. Enforcement of the ban varies throughout the state, with authorities in urban areas more likely to prosecute someone for possessing a prohibited firearm regardless of intent, while some rural counties may not enforce the ban at all or only prosecute those with malicious intent.

Methods to obtain firearms similar to assault weapons have been achieved through design changes by gun parts manufacturers. One common modification prior to 2017 was the "bullet button," which modified a rifle so that the magazine could not be removed without the use of a tool. Weapons with this feature were deemed to no longer have a "detachable magazine" and could be exempt from the law. However, if the characteristics that make a firearm a Category 3 assault weapon are removed, it is no longer considered an assault weapon and can be sold or transferred like any other firearm.

The Assault Weapons Ban Act limits access to certain semi-automatic rifles

The Federal Assault Weapons Ban expired on September 13, 2004, due to a ten-year "sunset" clause in the law. Since then, there have been several attempts to pass a new assault weapons ban through Congress, including the Assault Weapons Ban of 2022. However, these attempts have failed. As a result, unless banned by state law, any firearm previously prohibited under the Federal Assault Weapons Ban may now be legally possessed in the United States.

The Assault Weapons Ban Act aims to restrict access to specific semi-automatic rifles. It describes the types of semi-automatic firearms that are considered assault weapons and defines and limits large-capacity ammunition feeding devices. The act outlines restrictions on the manufacturing, sale, ownership, and transfer of these firearms and ammunition devices, with certain exceptions. For instance, it exempts qualified law enforcement officers and retired law enforcement officers from the assault weapon ban.

The act also mandates that any prohibited firearms or ammunition feeding devices manufactured after the law is enacted must bear a printed date. It establishes rules for the secure storage and transfer of any firearms or devices regulated by the law that were owned before its passage. Additionally, it provides for an optional "buy-back" program.

In California, the law bans certain assault weapons by specific type, series, and model, as well as by the firearm's general characteristics. It also prohibits the sale of large-capacity magazines, defined as magazines able to accept more than ten rounds. Similarly, Illinois has the Protect Illinois Communities Act, which is enforced by law enforcement agencies like the ISP, to prevent the illegal possession and use of firearms.

The House of Representatives has passed legislation to reintroduce the ban

The Assault Weapons Ban of 2023, introduced as H.R.698 in the House of Representatives, aims to prohibit the import, sale, manufacture, transfer, or possession of semiautomatic assault weapons (SAWs) and large-capacity ammunition feeding devices (LCAFDs). The bill outlines several exemptions to the prohibition, including firearms that are manually operated by bolt, pump, lever, or slide action, antiques, and those used for law enforcement or authorized testing purposes. It also allows for the continued possession, sale, or transfer of grandfathered SAWs, which must be securely stored.

The bill proposes penalties for violations of the ban, including amendments to Section 924(a)(1)(B) of title 18 of the United States Code. It also emphasizes the importance of background checks for transfers of grandfathered semiautomatic assault weapons to ensure they do not end up in the wrong hands. Secure storage or safety device requirements are mandated for grandfathered SAWs to prevent access by prohibited individuals.

The Assault Weapons Ban of 2023 is a significant step towards tightening gun control measures and addressing the issue of gun violence in the United States. By banning SAWs and LCAFDs, the legislation aims to make it more difficult for individuals to acquire high-capacity, rapid-fire weapons that have been used in numerous mass shootings. The passage of this bill by the House of Representatives demonstrates a commitment to addressing this pressing issue and ensuring the safety and well-being of citizens.

Frequently asked questions