Cops And Traffic Laws: Above Or Equal?

While law enforcement officers are not supposed to break traffic laws, they often do. In the US, people cannot make 'citizens' arrests' for infractions, and even documented violations often go unpunished by police departments. In the UK, police cars are often ticketed for parking offences, but these can be challenged if the police were responding to an emergency. In Texas, there is a law that states that the transportation code does not apply to an officer on patrol duty.

Police officers are not supposed to break traffic laws

While police officers are meant to uphold the law, there are instances where they are seen to break traffic laws. This is a concern for many citizens, who feel that officers should not be exempt from the rules that they enforce. In reality, law enforcement officers are not supposed to break traffic laws with impunity, but this does happen, and it can be challenging to hold them accountable.

Instances of police officers breaking traffic laws are not uncommon. Speeding, illegal parking, and unlawful turns are some of the most frequently reported violations. In some cases, officers have been known to speed with their lights off, endangering other drivers and pedestrians. These actions can have serious consequences and cause accidents or injuries.

In certain jurisdictions, there are laws that grant exceptions to police officers on patrol duty, allowing them to disregard certain traffic rules. For example, in Texas, there is a law stating that the regular traffic code does not apply to officers on patrol. This can create a sense of unfairness and lead to questions about the integrity of law enforcement.

Despite these exceptions, police officers are generally expected to comply with traffic laws. They are responsible for directing traffic and ensuring the safe movement of vehicles and pedestrians. This includes taking action against hazardous moving violations, such as speeding or operating unsafe vehicles. Officers are also tasked with enforcing traffic laws for public carriers and commercial vehicles, as well as off-road recreational vehicles.

When police officers break traffic laws, it can undermine public trust and confidence in law enforcement. Citizens can report violations and request disciplinary action through the police department's internal affairs. However, there is no guarantee that action will be taken, and even documented or videotaped evidence may go unpunished. Nonetheless, it is important for citizens to report any violations and hold law enforcement to the same standards that apply to everyone else.

In reality, police officers do break traffic laws

While law enforcement officers are not supposed to break traffic laws, in reality, they do. People cannot make 'citizens' arrests' for infractions, and even documented (videotaped) violations often go unpunished by police departments. In the UK, police cars are often ticketed for parking offences, but these can be challenged if they were responding to an emergency. In Texas, there is a law that states that the transportation code does not apply to an officer on patrol duty, which may be the case in other states too.

There are several accounts of police officers breaking traffic laws, such as speeding, illegal parking, and unlawful turns, when they are not responding to an emergency. This has resulted in people receiving traffic summons, which can be contested in a trial. In some cases, officers have been known to speed past other vehicles without their lights on, which can be dangerous for other drivers.

While it is possible to report these incidents and request disciplinary action, there is no guarantee that any action will be taken against the offending officer. Police officers are human beings just like the rest of us, and their job is definitely not the easiest. However, it is important to note that these occurrences are pretty rare, and most officers are just trying to do their job to the best of their abilities.

Citizens cannot make arrests for these infractions

While citizens' arrests are authorised in all states, there are many restrictions on when and how a citizen can make an arrest. Citizens cannot make arrests for infractions that they did not personally witness, and even then, they must be able to prove that the person they are arresting is the person who committed the crime. Citizens are also not permitted to use deadly force when making an arrest unless it is necessary to protect themselves or others from harm.

In most cases, citizens must find a person in the act of committing a crime or escaping from a person with lawful authority to arrest them. Citizens who make arrests may face lawsuits or criminal charges, and they must contact the police as soon as possible after making an arrest. Citizens are generally advised to leave arrests to trained professionals and to get the police involved as soon as possible.

In some states, citizens are not permitted to make arrests for misdemeanours or summary offences. For example, in Pennsylvania, courts have ruled that a non-law enforcement officer cannot make an arrest for a summary offence. In North Carolina, there is no "citizen's arrest", and instead, the state refers to it as a "detention". The state of Georgia repealed its citizen's arrest law after the murder of Ahmaud Arbery, replacing it with a narrower law that only applies to business owners, inspectors, security guards, and private investigators.

Citizens' arrests are a very serious and potentially dangerous undertaking. Citizens are not trained to apprehend suspected criminals and are not tasked with the duty to preserve and maintain public peace. Therefore, citizens should exercise extreme caution when attempting to make an arrest and be aware of the potential legal consequences, including civil or criminal liability and criminal prosecution.

People can report officers and request disciplinary action

People can take action if they witness an officer violating traffic laws. They can make a complaint or file a report with the officer's department, which is usually the local police department. This can be done by calling the department or filing a formal complaint online. In some cases, individuals may also have the option of private prosecution.

It is important to note that there is no guarantee that a complaint will result in disciplinary action against the officer. The prosecutor is under no legal obligation to press charges, even with evidence of a traffic violation. However, filing a complaint can bring attention to the issue and potentially lead to an investigation.

In the United States, individuals can file a complaint with the Department of Justice (DOJ) if they believe their rights have been violated by a law enforcement officer. The DOJ investigates allegations of criminal misconduct by federal law enforcement officers, such as those from the FBI, Drug Enforcement Agency, or Border Patrol. These investigations cover both criminal and civil statutes and protect all persons in the United States, regardless of citizenship.

Additionally, individuals can contact the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) or the United States Attorney's Office (USAO) in their district to report criminal misconduct by law enforcement officers. The laws enforced by the DOJ also prohibit retaliation against individuals who file complaints or participate in investigations.

In Massachusetts, for example, there is a specific law that upholds the right to secretly record police officers while they are discharging their official duties in public spaces. This law adds an extra layer of protection for individuals who wish to gather evidence of potential misconduct by law enforcement officers.

Police officers direct traffic in certain situations

Police officers are often the first responders to a traffic light malfunction at an intersection and are tasked with directing traffic. To do this, they may treat the intersection as a four-way stop, establish detours, or place signals in flashing mode. Officers are advised to wear bright colours and set down flares or cones to increase their visibility. They must also be clear with hand and flashlight directions, using big motions to ensure they are seen by drivers.

In the case of events, police officers play a crucial role in maintaining order and enhancing the overall experience by directing traffic flow and ensuring safety. They work closely with event organizers and security staff to establish clear routes for emergency vehicles, implement protocols for swift emergency responses, and employ crowd control techniques. Police officers may also implement one-way systems, temporary road closures, or redirect traffic to alternative routes to minimize congestion.

In emergency situations, officers shall establish traffic control detours to continue the orderly flow of traffic and ensure that law enforcement actions are not hindered. They may also use emergency equipment and two-way radios to communicate with other officers and coordinate traffic control efforts.

It is important to note that while police officers are expected to uphold traffic laws, there have been reports of officers breaking these laws, such as speeding, illegal parking, and unlawful turns, particularly when they are not responding to an emergency. In some states, such as Texas, there are laws that exempt officers on patrol duty from adhering to certain traffic regulations.

Frequently asked questions