Cops And Traffic Laws: Private Property Jurisdiction

Whether police officers can enforce traffic laws on private property is a complex issue that varies depending on the jurisdiction and the specific circumstances involved. In the United States, for example, it has been argued that traffic stops on private property may be illegal, as the police typically have the right to enforce traffic citations on streets or highways, which are defined as publicly maintained roadways open to public use. However, there may be exceptions, such as when the private property owner allows law enforcement to enforce violations or when certain violations, such as driving under the influence, occur. Understanding the extent of police power on private property is crucial for both law enforcement and citizens to ensure that the rights of all parties involved are respected and that public safety is maintained.

Traffic laws on private property vary by state

Traffic laws on private property vary across different states in the US. In California, for instance, the vehicle code only applies to "highways", which are defined as publicly maintained roadways open to public use. Most parking lots are considered private property, and the vehicle code does not apply unless there is a sign posted indicating that the vehicle code is enforced there.

In Florida, a similar case exists where an apartment parking lot was deemed not to meet the definition of a "street or highway" and therefore was not subject to the same traffic laws. However, there are some violations that can be enforced on any private property, including driving under the influence, hit and run, and exhibition of speed.

In other states, such as Illinois, the application of traffic laws on private property may depend on specific ordinances or resolutions enacted by the city or county. These laws can apply to privately owned and maintained roads, but the department is generally not required to enforce them unless certain conditions are met, such as the presence of appropriate signage.

Therefore, it is important to understand the specific laws and regulations of each state when considering the enforcement of traffic laws on private property, as they can vary significantly.

In California, vehicle codes apply to conduct on private property

On the other hand, private driveways, individually owned lots, or those solely for use by a private person or firm's customers (e.g., a doctor's office) are generally exempt from such enforcement. In these cases, only certain violations, such as DUI, reckless driving, hit-and-run, and handicap parking, are typically enforceable.

Additionally, cities or counties can adopt their own muni codes relating to traffic on private property. For example, Los Angeles has a muni code for speeding on private property without the owner's permission, which can be enforced on school service roads. Similarly, in Washington, officers can enforce speed laws on private roads within an HOA if the majority of the HOA has approved it and other requirements are met.

It's important to note that even if a police officer is hiding on private property, any tickets or arrests made are still valid and cannot be challenged based on that fact alone. However, if a property owner asks an officer to leave, the officer must comply.

In summary, while vehicle codes can apply to conduct on private property in California, the specifics vary depending on the location, the nature of the property, and any local regulations or agreements in place.

Traffic citations can be issued on private property with appropriate signage

In California, most parking lots are considered private property, and the vehicle code does not apply. However, traffic citations can be issued on private property with appropriate signage indicating that the vehicle code is enforced in that area. Officer Thomas Olsen, a spokesman for the California Highway Patrol, stated that while the vehicle code typically applies only to "highways," defined as publicly maintained roadways open to public use, there may be a sign at the entrance of a private parking lot indicating that the vehicle code is enforced there. This allows law enforcement to enforce violations, including all those listed in the California Vehicle Code.

According to California law, vehicles parked in private lots must meet specific requirements, such as being properly licensed and equipped with major parts, to ensure safe operation on public streets and highways. This helps prevent accidents and keeps unlicensed or abandoned vehicles off the property.

While the vehicle code generally does not apply to private property, there are a few exceptions. Officer Olsen mentioned that there are three violations that can be enforced on any private property: driving under the influence, hit and run, and exhibition of speed. These violations are considered serious and can result in legal consequences regardless of the location.

It's important to note that the enforcement of traffic citations on private property can vary depending on the state and local regulations. In the case of Nemeth v. State, an officer pulled over an individual for driving without headlights in an apartment complex parking lot, which led to a DUI conviction. The court determined that the apartment parking lot did not meet the definition of a "street or highway" and, therefore, the officer may have been outside of their jurisdiction in making the stop.

To summarize, while private property owners generally have the right to post signage and enforce the vehicle code on their premises, it is always advisable for drivers to exercise caution and adhere to traffic laws and signage to avoid citations and ensure the safety of others.

Specific violations can be enforced on private property, including DUI and hit-and-run

In the US, the authority of the police to enforce traffic laws on private property varies across states and the type of private property in question. While most parking lots are considered private property, police officers may enforce traffic laws in these areas under certain conditions.

DUI on Private Property

In some states, such as Kentucky and Mississippi, DUI laws apply everywhere within state borders, including private property. In other states, DUI laws apply only to public property and private property that is open to the public. This includes parking lots of restaurants, shopping malls, schools, office buildings, hospitals, parks, trailer parks, apartment complexes, and condominiums.

Hit-and-Run on Private Property

In Arizona, police may cite or arrest drivers who fail to stop after an accident, regardless of whether it occurred on private or public property. This is considered a hit-and-run and is enforceable on private property.

Other Violations on Private Property

In addition to DUI and hit-and-run, other violations such as reckless driving and exhibition of speed can also be enforced on private property in Arizona. The enforcement of these laws on private property may vary depending on the specific state and local regulations.

It is important to note that, in some states, the presence of signage indicating the enforcement of traffic laws on private property may be a factor in determining whether a driver can be cited for a violation.

Private property owners can request enforcement of public traffic regulations

In most cases, parking lots are considered private property, and the vehicle code does not apply. However, private property owners can request enforcement of public traffic regulations by posting appropriate signage. For instance, in California, Officer Thomas Olsen of the California Highway Patrol stated that while the vehicle code only applies to "highways", there can be a sign at the entrance of a parking lot indicating that the vehicle code is enforced there. Similarly, in Florida, a written agreement between the landowner and law enforcement is required for traffic citations to be issued on private property.

In certain cases, police can enforce some traffic violations on private property, such as driving under the influence, hit and run, and exhibition of speed. These violations are considered serious and can be enforced regardless of the location. For example, in Washington State, the RCW (Rules of the Road) specifies that the chapter applies exclusively to vehicle operations on highways, but there are exceptions for streets within a Home Owner Association.

To request enforcement of public traffic regulations on private property, the owner must post conspicuous signage at the entrance of the property. The signs should be of a specific size, shape, and color to be readily legible during daylight hours from a distance of 100 feet. This signage indicates that the property is subject to public traffic regulations and control.

It's important to note that the enforcement of public traffic regulations on private property may vary depending on the state and local laws. While some states may allow enforcement with the owner's permission, others may require a written agreement or specific signage. Therefore, it is advisable to review the specific laws and regulations applicable to the relevant state or jurisdiction.

Frequently asked questions