Laws Within Laws: Counties And States' Legal Differences

The legal system of a country is an intricate network of laws, regulations, and public policies that govern the behaviour of its citizens. It is important to note that within federal systems like the United States, there exist both federal laws and state laws. All 50 states within the US have their own unique laws, which may vary in areas such as business contracts, real estate, and family law. This dynamic is not unique to the US; Spain, for example, has Autonomous Regional Communities that are granted a degree of autonomy in enacting their own laws. The interplay between federal and state laws adds complexity to the legal landscape, and this complexity is further amplified when considering the diverse legal systems that exist worldwide, including common law, civil law, religious law, and more.

Influence of religious law

The United States has evolved from a historically Christian nation into an "officially monotheistic" one, with the First Amendment stating that the country shall have no official religion. Despite this, Americans are divided on the extent to which the country's laws should reflect religious teachings. For instance, some laws passed in certain states, such as "bathroom bills" and those ensuring wedding planners can refuse service at gay weddings, are supported by their proponents as a way to protect religious beliefs. However, critics argue that such laws are discriminatory, particularly towards the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community.

Additionally, some vetoed bills, such as one in Georgia, would have protected organizations that refused to employ or provide services to individuals because of "sincerely held religious beliefs." Major US companies like Coca-Cola, the NFL, and Disney put pressure on the governor to veto this bill, threatening to pull their business from the state.

While some Americans argue that the Bible should influence US laws, others disagree, with 19% saying it shouldn't influence laws much, and 31% saying it shouldn't at all. This divide highlights the ongoing debate in the US about where to draw the line between religion and government.

State laws vs. federal laws

In the United States, laws are made by either the federal government or state governments. Federal laws apply to everyone in the US, while state laws apply to people who live or work in a particular state, commonwealth, or territory. There are 50 states, and each has its own system of laws and courts. These laws are generally concerned with matters of state and not federal law, such as family law, divorce, child custody, and guardianships.

The federal government's powers are listed in the US Constitution at Article I, Section 8. These include immigration, bankruptcy, the postal service, intellectual property, and the military. Federal laws are also enacted in furtherance of the US Constitution, which states that they are the "supreme law of the land." This means that federal laws take precedence over state laws and constitutions.

Some areas of law are governed by both state and federal law, such as when federal funds are offered to a state for general welfare programs. In these cases, an element of federal law is involved. Historically, federal courts only heard cases related to the interpretation of the US Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and topics authorized by the Constitution.

While the US has a clear distinction between federal and state laws, other countries have different systems. For example, Spain has "Autonomous Regional Communities" that are allowed to enact their own laws within certain legal areas.

Common law systems

Many countries around the world, including the US, Canada, India, and Australia, rely heavily on common law when resolving legal disputes.

Civil law systems

A civil law system is a legal system characterized by a vast network of codified laws, with an emphasis on the study of codes and statutes in legal education. Civil law systems are rooted in the Roman Empire, with the earliest known codification being the Code of Hammurabi, written in ancient Babylon during the 18th century BC. However, the codification typical of modern civil law systems first appeared in the Justinian Code, which served as the basis for the later Napoleonic Code (1804) in France and the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (1900) in Germany.

Civil law is often contrasted with common law, which originated in medieval England and is practiced in countries like Ireland, the United States, the United Kingdom, South Africa, and Australia. Common law relies heavily on judicial precedent and case law, while civil law systems emphasize codified laws as the primary source of law. However, it's important to note that even in countries with a single system of law, there is often an influence from the other system, and the two traditions of legal education can differ significantly.

Country constitutions

When examining country constitutions, it is worth noting that some countries, like the United States, have federal systems where power is shared between the national government and states. Within such systems, states possess a degree of autonomy and can establish their own laws within their jurisdictions, provided they do not contradict federal laws. This dynamic allows for variations in laws across different states within the same country.

In contrast, other countries may have a more centralized system of governance, where the national government holds the majority of legislative power. In these cases, while there might be regional or local governments, their authority to create distinct laws is more limited, and they primarily enforce and implement the laws established by the central government.

It is important to recognize that the relationship between national and regional laws can vary significantly from country to country. For instance, Spain, which does not have states but instead has "Autonomous Regional Communities," grants these regions considerable autonomy in enacting their own laws within specific legal areas. This example showcases how the degree of legal independence afforded to regional entities can differ internationally.

Understanding country constitutions is crucial for several reasons. Firstly, it empowers individuals to comprehend their rights and responsibilities as citizens. Secondly, it provides insight into the organization and functioning of a country's government and legal system. Lastly, it helps foster awareness of the legal landscape when travelling or conducting business in a foreign country, ensuring compliance with local laws and regulations.

Frequently asked questions