Criminal Law-Making: Federal Power Examined

The federal government in the United States can exercise powers granted to it by the Constitution, which limits federal laws to the powers granted to Congress. The federal government has jurisdiction over crimes committed on federal property and those affecting multiple states, such as drug trafficking and child sex-related offenses. Federal laws also apply to offenses that occur in areas owned or administered directly by the federal government or under its authority. The Commerce Clause in Article I, Section 8, gives Congress the authority to regulate commerce among the states, which has been the basis for substantial criminal legislation. The federal government's role in criminal law is distinct from civil law, which addresses non-criminal disputes.

Federal government's jurisdiction over crimes

The federal government's jurisdiction over crimes in the United States is derived from the Constitution, which vests Congress with the authority to enact criminal laws. Federal courts have jurisdiction over federal crimes, while state courts handle state crimes. However, there are instances where a crime can fall under both federal and state jurisdiction, leading to concurrent jurisdiction.

Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution grants the federal government, through Congress, exclusive authority over specific issues, including bankruptcy, immigration, patents, postal services, and currency-related matters. Federal courts thus have subject matter jurisdiction over criminal cases involving these areas, such as fraud, mail fraud, immigration offences, and money counterfeiting. Additionally, the Fourteenth Amendment gives the federal government jurisdiction over civil rights violations, and the Commerce Clause enables federal jurisdiction over crimes affecting interstate commerce or crossing state lines.

Federal criminal jurisdiction also extends to crimes committed on federal property, such as national parks, federal courthouses, federal prisons, the District of Columbia, and Indian reservations. It also covers temporary jurisdictions like airplanes and ocean-going vessels. The federal government has the authority to regulate commerce and establish federal penalties for crimes, which traditionally fell under state jurisdiction.

In the context of Indian Country, the Bureau of Indian Affairs and the Department of Justice provide law enforcement services to tribes subject to federal criminal jurisdiction. The Federal Bureau of Investigation and the United States Attorneys' Offices handle felony crimes occurring in Indian Country, including homicides, aggravated assaults, sex offences, and large-scale theft.

Furthermore, federal jurisdiction can be invoked when a crime involves a national or federal interest. For example, if a crime occurs on federal land or is committed against the United States or a federal agency, such as sedition or violating federal laws. The federal government may also prosecute cases that involve significant resources, such as large sex trafficking rings, or crimes that cross state lines, like kidnapping or transporting illegal substances.

Federal government's authority to enact criminal law

The federal government's authority to enact criminal law in the United States is derived from the Constitution, which vests Congress with explicit authority to create and enforce criminal statutes. This authority is limited to the powers granted by the Constitution, and federal laws cannot exceed the scope of these powers.

The Commerce Clause, found in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution, is a significant source of congressional authority in criminal law. It grants Congress the power "to regulate Commerce... among the several States," enabling the federal government to legislate on matters that involve interstate commerce or cross state lines. This includes crimes such as drug trafficking, possession, and distribution, as well as firearms regulations. The Controlled Substances Act, for example, relies on the Commerce Clause to regulate controlled substances traded across state lines.

Federal criminal law also extends to areas of national security and international affairs. The Constitution's Military Clauses permit Congress to criminalize overseas assaults by Defense Department foreign contractors. Additionally, federal appellate courts have recognised customary international law in cases involving piracy and offences against the law of nations.

In matters involving Indian Country, the Department of Justice has primary jurisdiction over most felonies that occur on Indian lands in most states. The Federal Bureau of Investigation and the United States Attorneys' Offices are responsible for investigating and prosecuting serious felony crimes, including homicide, aggravated assault, sex offences, and large-scale theft or embezzlement.

While the federal government has the authority to enact criminal law in specific areas, it is important to note that the United States has two primary systems of criminal law: state criminal law and federal law. State governments have direct authority over most criminal matters, and city, county, and state laws apply unless an alleged offence falls under the federal government's subject matter jurisdiction.

Federal drug crimes

The United States Constitution vests Congress with the authority to enact criminal laws. Federal drug crimes are offences related to controlled substances or severe drug-related offences. These crimes are investigated by federal agencies like the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and are prosecuted by federal prosecutors. Federal drug crimes often involve large quantities of drugs, a large number of people, or the manufacture or trafficking of drugs across state lines or on federal land.

Drug crimes that are prosecuted at the federal level include possession, distribution, manufacturing, or trafficking of illicit drugs. Federal drug charges can also include conspiracy, money laundering, or violations of the Federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization Act (RICO). The Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) is responsible for enforcing federal controlled substances laws and investigating and prosecuting those who grow, manufacture, sell, or distribute drugs, including the importation of drugs into the United States.

It is important to note that while some states have legalised the possession of certain drugs like marijuana, it remains illegal under federal law and may be prosecuted by federal prosecutors if it does not comply with state statutes. Individuals facing federal drug charges should seek legal counsel from attorneys experienced in federal drug crime defence to protect their rights and freedom.

Federal crimes on Indian lands

The Constitution vests Congress with the authority to enact criminal laws. Federal appellate courts have looked to customary international law for explanations of the power over offenses against the law of nations and piracy. The Constitution's Military Clauses permit Congress to criminalize overseas assaults by Defense Department foreign contractors.

The United States Constitution, treaties, federal statutes, executive orders, and court decisions establish and define the unique legal and political relationship that exists between the United States and Indian tribes. The federal government tries to honor the legal sovereignty of Indian nations regarding crimes committed in their territories. However, the federal government reserves the right to exert jurisdiction over certain types of serious crimes when committed by Indigenous Americans in Indian territories. This law is embodied in Title 18 U.S.C. 1153, which gives the federal government pre-eminent jurisdiction to prosecute certain "major crimes" when committed by Indigenous Americans in these territories.

The Indian Country Crime program of the FBI works closely with tribal police and federal agents from the Bureau of Indian Affairs, as well as the Department of Justice. The Bureau of Indian Affairs provides law enforcement and corrections services to tribes subject to federal criminal jurisdiction but lacking their own law enforcement or corrections programs. The ICSCU manages personnel resources, procures services, funds specialized equipment to enhance FBI investigations, and coordinates with the FBI Office of Victim Assistance and other federal agencies. The ICSCU also provides quality training to law enforcement personnel to ensure that Indian Country criminal investigations are conducted in a consistent manner.

The United States Attorneys' Offices handle the vast majority of criminal prosecutions for felony crimes committed within Indian country. The designated Tribal Liaison within these offices may be contacted regarding issues that arise in Indian Country. The five basic priorities of the United States Attorneys' Offices in Indian country are homeland security, violent crimes, Indian gaming, white-collar crime, and jurisdictional issues.

Federal crimes vs state crimes

The federal government of the United States derives its authority to enact criminal laws from the Constitution. Federal crimes are violations of the U.S. Constitution and always supersede state law. The federal government can interfere and convict individuals of federal crimes even when state and federal laws are not aligned.

State crimes are crimes that break state law and cover the majority of crimes. These include murder, rape, DUI, drug possession, theft, robbery, shoplifting, and assault. Most misdemeanours are state crimes. Each state has its own criminal laws, and state judges and legislatures define sentencing policies. For instance, in North Carolina, state laws cover the majority of criminal charges faced by residents.

Federal crimes are those that the federal government has specifically designated as federal crimes. Examples include terrorism, tax evasion (if the taxes are levied by the IRS), bank robberies and bank fraud, mail fraud, and theft from emails. Federal laws also cover crimes that cross state boundaries, such as kidnapping, and computer crimes like internet pornography and computer hacking. Drug crimes can also be federal crimes if they involve the purchase of drugs in one state and the sale in another, or if they cross national borders.

The judicial procedures and jurisdictions for federal and state crimes are separate. Federal and state courts are physically separate, with different judges, prosecuting attorneys, and procedures. Federal courts follow the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, while state courts follow rules set by state legislatures and courts. Federal courts have three levels: district court, court of appeals, and the Supreme Court.

Frequently asked questions