Daughter-In-Law's Legal Rights To Ancestral Property

In India, the rights of a daughter-in-law to claim a share in ancestral property have been a matter of debate. While daughters have been granted equal rights to ancestral property, the same cannot be said for daughters-in-law. According to the Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) guidelines, a daughter-in-law is considered a member but not a coparcener, and therefore, she cannot claim any rights to ancestral property that exclusively belongs to her in-laws. However, she can claim a share of the property through her husband's share in the HUF property, either willfully transferred by him or received after his demise.

Daughter-in-law's rights to ancestral property

In India, a daughter-in-law does not have any legal rights over properties owned by her father-in-law or inherited properties of her father-in-law. This includes ancestral property.

However, a daughter-in-law does have a right of residence in the matrimonial home under the Domestic Violence Act, even if her husband doesn’t have any ownership rights in the house. This right remains intact until the marriage is dissolved. If the son and daughter-in-law do not live with the in-laws in the self-acquired property, the daughter-in-law cannot claim her right of residence either.

A Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) grants a daughter-in-law the status of a member of the HUF but does not make her a coparcener. The daughter-in-law acquires rights to HUF property through her husband’s share in the HUF property (either willfully transferred by the husband or received after the husband's death). In the case of a deceased mother-in-law, her share will equally devolve among her children, and the daughter-in-law will acquire rights on her husband’s share only.

The rights of a daughter, on the other hand, have been expanded in recent years. In 2020, the Supreme Court held that daughters and sons have equal coparcenary rights in a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF). This ruling applies retrospectively, and not only in cases where the father was alive when the 2005 amendment to the Hindu Succession Act came into force. This means that daughters can claim an equal share of their father's ancestral property, irrespective of the year of their parent's death. However, this ruling only applies to HUF property and does not affect personal or self-acquired assets held individually.

Daughter-in-law's rights to matrimonial home

In India, a daughter-in-law has a right to reside in the matrimonial home. This right is protected under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. The Supreme Court of India has upheld this right in several judgments, including a landmark judgment in 2020. This right to residence is not limited to a specific type of residence, such as a rented or owned property.

The right to reside in a shared household means that a woman has the legal right to live in the home where she resided with her husband or in-laws. This right is protected under the Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and ensures that a woman cannot be evicted or excluded from the shared household by her husband or his family members. The Supreme Court has clarified that a shared household refers to the residence where a woman has lived in a domestic relationship, irrespective of ownership.

It is important to note that the right to residence for a daughter-in-law is dependent on the continuation of the matrimonial relationship with her husband. In the event of the dissolution of the marriage, the daughter-in-law may lose her right to reside in the matrimonial home. Additionally, a daughter-in-law does not have a direct claim to her in-laws' self-acquired property. Her right to the property typically comes through her husband's share in the property.

The Hindu Succession Act, 1956, as amended by the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, grants daughters equal rights as sons in ancestral property. This means that a daughter has a coparcenary right to the ancestral property and can claim her share, regardless of her marital status or whether her father is alive. However, there may be situations where a daughter may not be eligible to claim property, such as if there is a will explicitly excluding her or if the property was transferred before 2005.

In summary, a daughter-in-law in India has the right to reside in the matrimonial home during her matrimonial relationship. This right is protected under the Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and upheld by the Supreme Court. While she may not have a direct claim to her in-laws' self-acquired property, she has rights to the family's property through her husband's share. The Hindu Succession Act and its amendments have also granted daughters equal rights as sons in ancestral property.

Daughter's rights to ancestral property

In India, the laws governing property rights for daughters have undergone significant changes in recent times. The Hindu Succession Act of 1956 is the primary legislation governing succession and inheritance matters for Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs. Under this Act, both sons and daughters are entitled to equal rights to their father's self-acquired and ancestral property.

Before 2005, daughters were not considered coparceners, meaning they had no rights over ancestral property. However, this changed with the 2005 amendment to the Hindu Succession Act, which granted daughters equal rights as sons in ancestral property, irrespective of their marital status. This amendment applies retroactively, ensuring that daughters can claim their share of ancestral property even if their father passed away before 2005.

It is important to note that there are certain situations where a daughter may not be eligible to claim property. For example, if the property is self-acquired and there is a will that explicitly excludes the daughter, she may not be able to claim a share. Additionally, if the property was legally transferred before the 2005 amendment, the daughter may not have rights to it as the amendment is not retrospective.

While the rights of daughters-in-law regarding ancestral property are not entirely clear, the general consensus is that they do not have a direct claim to their in-laws' ancestral property. Their rights to the family's property are typically derived through their husband's share. In the case of a deceased mother-in-law, her share will be divided equally among her children, and the daughter-in-law will only acquire rights to her husband's portion.

In summary, the 2005 amendment to the Hindu Succession Act has been a landmark change, ensuring that daughters have equal rights to their fathers' ancestral property, regardless of their marital status. This amendment has been further supported by Supreme Court rulings, promoting the forward march of women's rights in India.

Self-acquired property

In India, Hindu Law recognises two types of property: ancestral property and self-acquired property. Self-acquired property refers to property that an individual has acquired through their own efforts, skills, or resources, without any inheritance or gift. This can be done in several ways, including:

• Purchasing it with their own resources or earnings
• Inheriting it from their spouse, parents, or relatives
• Receiving it as a gift from their spouse, parents, or relatives

The ownership of self-acquired property depends on how it was acquired. If an individual purchases self-acquired property, they become the absolute owner. However, if the property is acquired through inheritance or gift, the ownership is subject to certain restrictions under Hindu Law.

Under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the rules regarding the devolution of self-acquired property among the legal heirs of a Hindu individual are outlined. The Act applies to all Hindus, including Buddhists, Sikhs, and Jains. According to the Act, if a Hindu male dies intestate (without making a will), his self-acquired property devolves first to his wife and children. If there is no wife or children, the property goes to his parents, and if they are not alive, it devolves to the heirs of the father.

It is important for individuals to ensure that their self-acquired property is distributed according to their wishes after their death. This can be done by making a will and taking other necessary legal steps.

In the context of a married couple, the wife has no right of share in her husband's self-acquired property during his lifetime. However, she can claim a right of residence under the Domestic Violence Act. Additionally, a married daughter has an equal claim to self-acquired property as the male members of the family.

Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) property

A Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) is a legal and tax entity specific to Hindu families in India. It is based on the concept of a joint family that includes all family members across generations, with the eldest male member typically acting as the head or "Karta" of the family. A HUF can be formed by a family upon marriage and must consist of at least two members. The Karta has the authority to sign relevant documents and make decisions on behalf of other family members.

The HUF typically has assets that come from ancestral property, gifts, property acquired from the sale of joint family property, a will, or property donated to the common pool by members of the HUF. These assets are pooled together, and the HUF is taxed separately from its members. The HUF has its own PAN and files tax returns independently of its members.

In the context of ancestral property, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, as amended by the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, grants daughters equal rights as sons in ancestral property by birth. This means that a daughter has a coparcenary right to the ancestral property and can claim her share irrespective of whether her father is alive or deceased.

Regarding the rights of a daughter-in-law in ancestral property, the general judicial opinion is that she does not have a direct claim to her in-laws' ancestral property. Her right to the property typically comes through her husband's share in the property, either willfully transferred by the husband or received after his demise. In the case of a deceased mother-in-law, her share will be equally divided among her children, and the daughter-in-law will acquire rights to her husband's share.

It is important to note that the information provided here may not be exhaustive and that specific cases may have unique considerations. For definitive legal advice, it is always recommended to consult a qualified professional.

Frequently asked questions