Family Law Privacy: What Can Employers Legally Ask?

Employers must strike a delicate balance between respecting employee privacy and confirming the legitimacy of an absence. While there is no explicit prohibition in employment law against asking for proof of a family emergency, specific laws, such as the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), establish boundaries. For instance, the FMLA permits employees to take up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave annually for qualifying family and medical reasons, allowing employers to request certification from healthcare providers to justify the leave. Furthermore, employers can legally inquire about family emergencies and set conditions or warn employees about the consequences of their absence, even if it is for a legitimate reason. However, it is crucial to approach each case individually, as overly strict requirements may create a negative work environment or lead to legal complaints.

Family emergencies and proof

While it is natural for employers to want clarity when employees request time off for a family emergency, the ability to request proof of a family emergency is not always straightforward. It varies based on company policies, state regulations, and the nature of the absence. In general, employment law does not explicitly prohibit employers from asking for proof of a family emergency. However, there are some nuances to consider.

Firstly, employers can ask for proof of a family emergency before providing leave. However, what constitutes proof is complicated. Employers cannot request information about the family member's diagnosis or treatment, nor can they ask for a doctor's note. They can ask which family member is affected and how they are related to the employee. It is important to note that family emergencies are often sensitive matters, and employers should handle documentation carefully and limit access to this information within their organization to protect employee privacy.

Secondly, specific laws, such as the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), establish boundaries on what employers can request in terms of proof. The FMLA, for example, allows employees to take up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave per year for qualifying family and medical reasons. If an employee qualifies for FMLA leave, employers can request certification from a healthcare provider to substantiate the need for leave. However, the FMLA does not typically cover sudden emergencies, so verifying these types of leave requests can be challenging. In addition to federal law, each state may have unique family and medical leave laws that dictate whether and how employers can request proof. For instance, California state law may provide additional protections for employees, impacting how employers handle leave verification.

Therefore, it is essential for employers to have a clear and well-defined leave policy that complies with applicable labor laws and considers local and state regulations. This policy should be crafted to prevent potential discrimination or retaliation claims and applied consistently to all employees. While employers may have a reasonable interest in confirming the legitimacy of an absence, they should approach each case individually and limit their requests to the necessary information to support the leave request.

Family medical information

In the United States, medical information is considered a private matter between a patient and their doctor or other healthcare professionals. This information is protected by laws such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). While employers can request medical information, they must follow specific guidelines to do so, and they are not entitled to certain information.

Under the ADA, employers are prohibited from requiring medical examinations or asking employees about their disability, past or present medical conditions, or health information unrelated to job duties. An employer may inquire about medical information if it is directly related to an employee's ability to perform specific job functions, such as heavy lifting. However, they cannot request medical information without a specific reason, as this may be considered illegal discrimination. If an employee believes they are being discriminated against due to their disability or medical leave status, they can seek legal advice and discuss their rights with an employment law attorney.

In certain situations, employers may request medical documentation or a doctor's note. For example, if an employee is seeking leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), they may be required to provide a certification from their physician explaining the need for leave, its expected duration, and their ability to work upon returning. Additionally, if an employer has information that reasonably suggests an employee's medical condition could impair their ability to perform essential job functions or pose a direct threat to themselves or others, they may be justified in requesting medical information.

It is important to note that state laws may also impact what medical information an employer can request. For instance, in California, employers cannot ask about certain marijuana convictions that are more than two years old. Employees should review their state's laws and consult with legal professionals if they have specific concerns or questions about their privacy rights in the workplace.

Communication with family members

Communication with an employee's family members is a sensitive issue and should be handled with caution by employers. While there may be instances where an employer needs to communicate with a worker's family, it is important to respect the employee's privacy and maintain a direct line of communication with the employee whenever possible.

In general, employers should avoid discussing employment-related matters with family members unless the employee has given explicit consent or permission. This could be in the form of a signed document or a Power of Attorney, particularly if the employee is unable to handle their own affairs due to incompetence or incapacity. For example, if the employee is an unemancipated minor (under 18 and subject to parental authority), or if the employee is deemed mentally incompetent to manage their affairs and has a court-appointed guardian. In such cases, it is crucial to obtain documentary proof of the minor's status or the adult's guardianship before engaging in any discussions with their family members.

Additionally, it is important to note that family members may sometimes take the initiative to contact an employer or HR department. This could be out of genuine concern for their loved one or due to a misunderstanding of employment matters. In these situations, employers should exercise discretion and be cautious about sharing information. While it is understandable that family members may want to advocate for their loved ones, employers should strive to maintain direct communication with the employee whenever possible.

In the context of family emergencies, employers should refer to their company's leave policy and applicable labor laws. While employment law does not explicitly prohibit employers from asking for proof of a family emergency, specific laws like the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) establish boundaries. For instance, the FMLA allows employees to take up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave annually for qualifying family and medical reasons. If an employee qualifies for FMLA leave, employers can request certification from a healthcare provider to substantiate the need for leave. However, it is important to be consistent in applying leave policies, treat all employees equally, and respect the privacy and confidentiality of employees during these sensitive times.

Discrimination and retaliation claims

While family status discrimination is not illegal in all cases, it often overlaps with other prohibited forms of discrimination, such as gender discrimination or retaliation for taking protected caregiving leave. Family status discrimination occurs when an employer makes stereotypical assumptions about an employee's ability to work due to their status as a caregiver. This can manifest as negative evaluations, heightened scrutiny, or failure to promote employees with caregiving responsibilities.

In California, for example, family responsibilities discrimination claims can be brought under various legal theories, including laws prohibiting retaliation for taking protected leave, discrimination based on association with a disabled person, interference with employee benefits, and non-compliance with gender norms.

Additionally, the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA), an amendment to Title VII, protects women who are pregnant or on maternity leave and addresses potential discrimination due to future pregnancies. The Fourth Circuit has upheld verdicts recognizing discrimination against new mothers, such as negative evaluations and rude remarks. Similarly, the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and its anti-retaliation provisions protect employees who take FMLA-protected leave. If an employee is not covered by the FMLA, they may seek protection under state laws with lower thresholds for protected leave.

Other laws that prohibit retaliation and discrimination include Labor Codes that protect employees from retaliation for participating in national service programs, filing claims or civil actions, taking leave for organ donation, or reporting unsafe working conditions. These laws aim to safeguard employees from adverse employment actions and promote fair and equitable treatment in the workplace.

Employment contract and union agreements

In the United States, there are no minimum requirements for an employment contract, and no federal rules regarding the duration of a fixed-term contract. In most states, no written memorialisation of any terms is required, and a majority of employees are employed on an "at-will" basis, meaning that the employment relationship is terminable by either party at any time, with or without cause or notice.

However, if employees are represented by a labour union, the provisions of the collective bargaining agreement protecting employees against discharge without cause may apply. The National Labor Relations Act forbids employers from interfering with, restraining, or coercing employees in the exercise of rights relating to organising, forming, joining, or assisting a labour organisation for collective bargaining purposes. This includes bargaining in good faith about wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment.

Once a contract is in place, neither party may deviate from its terms without the other party's consent, except in extraordinary circumstances. An employer must observe any employment benefit program or plan that provides greater family or medical leave rights to employees than those established by the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). The FMLA provides job-protected leave for certain qualifying reasons, including caring for an immediate family member with a serious health condition or taking medical leave when the employee is unable to work due to their own serious health condition. While FMLA leave is typically unpaid, employees may choose to substitute paid leave, such as sick leave or vacation time, for their FMLA absence.

Frequently asked questions