Executive Veto Power: Can They Stop A Law?

The ability to veto legislation is a significant power granted to the executive branch in many countries. In the United States, the President has the authority to veto bills passed by Congress, either by refusing to sign a bill within ten days or by using a pocket veto, where the bill is vetoed by default if Congress is no longer in session. This power is also held by state governors and some mayors and county executives. While a veto can be overridden by a two-thirds vote in both the Senate and the House of Representatives, the pocket veto is an absolute veto with no option for override. The legislative branch, on the other hand, has the power to nullify actions taken by executive agencies, although this was deemed unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in 1983.

The President can veto a bill within 10 days, after which it automatically becomes law

In presidential and semi-presidential systems, the veto is a legislative power of the presidency, as it involves the president in the process of making laws. The president can only veto a bill after it has been passed by the legislature. Once both chambers of Congress have agreed on a bill, it is prepared in its final official form and presented to the president. From midnight at the end of the day of presentment, the president has ten days, excluding Sundays, to sign or veto the bill.

If the president signs the bill within this ten-day period, it becomes law. If the president does not act on the bill in any way within the ten days, it becomes law without their signature, except when Congress has adjourned under certain circumstances. This is called a "pocket veto" and cannot be overridden by Congress.

If the president vetoes the bill, it is returned to the congressional chamber in which it originated. This chamber may then attempt to override the president's veto, but this requires a vote in support by at least two-thirds of those voting. If this vote is successful, the other chamber can then decide whether to attempt its own override vote, which again requires at least two-thirds of the voting members to be in support. If both chambers vote to override the veto, the bill becomes law.

A suspensory veto, also called a suspensive veto, can be overridden by a simple majority and therefore only serves to delay the law from coming into force. A package veto, or "block veto", vetoes a legislative act as a whole, while a partial veto, or line-item veto, allows the executive to object to only a specific part of the law while allowing the rest to stand. Amendatory vetoes give greater power to the executive than deletional vetoes, as they allow the executive to move policy closer to their preferred state.

A pocket veto is when the executive takes no action, and the bill dies

The executive has the power to veto a law, and this power is often ranked as comparatively "strong" or "weak". There are different types of vetoes, such as a suspensory veto, a package veto, and a partial veto. A suspensory veto, also called a suspensive veto, can be overridden by a simple majority, thus serving only to delay the law from coming into force. A package veto, also called a "block veto" or "full veto", vetoes a legislative act as a whole. A partial veto, also called a line-item veto, allows the executive to object to only some specific parts of the law while allowing the rest to stand.

One type of veto is a pocket veto, which occurs when the executive takes no action, and the bill dies. A pocket veto is a unique form of veto that takes effect simply by the executive or head of state taking no action. In the United States, the pocket veto can only be exercised near the end of a legislative session. If the deadline for presidential action passes during the session, the bill will become law. A pocket veto occurs when a bill fails to become law because the president does not sign it within ten days and cannot return the bill to Congress because Congress is no longer in session. The Constitution limits the president's period for deciding whether to sign or return any legislation to ten days (not including Sundays) while Congress is in session.

If Congress adjourns within the ten-day period and the president does not sign the bill, it is automatically vetoed, and this veto is absolute. This means that the bill is effectively killed, and the only way for Congress to circumvent the pocket veto is to reintroduce the legislation as a new bill, pass it through both chambers, and present it to the president again for signature. The pocket veto is a powerful tool that can significantly impact the legislative process, as it allows the executive to block a bill without taking any formal action.

A suspensory veto can be overridden by a simple majority, delaying the law

The executive can veto a law in presidential and semi-presidential systems, as the veto is a legislative power of the presidency. However, not all vetoes are equal, and some are stronger than others. For example, a package veto, also called a "block veto" or "full veto", vetoes a legislative act in its entirety. On the other hand, a partial veto, or line-item veto, allows the executive to object to only a specific part of the law while allowing the rest to stand.

A suspensory veto, also known as a suspensive veto, is a type of veto that can be overridden by a simple majority, delaying the law from coming into force. In other words, it is a veto that merely suspends a law until it is reconsidered by the legislature, and it becomes a law if repassed by an ordinary majority. This type of veto has been used in various contexts, including by the Ancients, who had a suspensory veto but no initiative in legislation.

An example of a suspensory veto being used effectively is the case of Estonian President Lennart Meri in 1993. President Meri issued a suspensory veto of the proposed Law on Aliens and successfully obtained amendments to the bill based on expert opinions on European law. This example demonstrates how a suspensory veto can be a powerful tool for the executive to stop or modify legislation, even if it can be overridden by a simple majority.

It is important to note that the strength of executive veto powers can vary, and they are often ranked as comparatively "strong" or "weak". Additionally, the legislative veto, which was common in the US beginning in the 1970s, was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, as it did not meet the constitutional requirements of presentment and bicameralism.

A package veto, or block veto, vetoes the legislative act as a whole

The executive or head of state has the power to veto a legislative act as a whole through a package veto, also known as a block veto or full veto. This type of veto gives the executive the authority to reject a proposed law or policy in its entirety, without allowing for any parts of it to be implemented. It is an all-or-nothing approach to vetoes, and it requires a supermajority, usually two-thirds, to override.

The package veto is a significant power that can be used to shape legislation and ensure that it aligns with the executive's interests and priorities. While it does not allow for specific objections to individual parts of a legislative act, it provides a strong negotiating position for the executive. By wielding the package veto, the executive can send a clear message about their stance on the proposed law or policy.

In some countries, the package veto is a standard tool for the executive. For example, the president of El Salvador has the power of a package veto, which must be exercised within eight days of the legislation being passed by the Legislative Assembly. Similarly, the president of Mexico has the same power, with a ten-day timeframe to use it after legislation is passed by the Congress of the Union.

The package veto is distinct from other types of vetoes, such as the suspensory veto or the partial veto. A suspensory veto, also known as a suspensive veto, can be overridden by a simple majority and only serves to delay a law from taking effect. On the other hand, a partial veto, or line-item veto, allows the executive to object to specific parts of a law while allowing the rest to stand. This provides the executive with more flexibility and a stronger negotiating position than a package veto.

Amendatory vetoes give greater power than deletional vetoes, allowing executives to move policy closer to their preference

The veto is a legislative power of the presidency, involving the president in the process of making laws. It is a reactive power, as the president cannot veto a bill until the legislature has passed it. Executive veto powers are often ranked as comparatively "strong" or "weak". An amendatory veto, also known as an amendatory observation, returns legislation to the legislature with proposed amendments, which the legislature may either adopt or override. This type of veto gives the executive a stronger role in the legislative process, allowing them to move policy closer to their preference. For instance, in Estonia in 1993, President Lennart Meri successfully obtained amendments to the proposed Law on Aliens after issuing a suspensory veto of the bill and suggesting changes based on expert opinions on European law.

A partial veto, also known as a line-item veto, allows the executive to object to a specific part of the law while allowing the rest to stand. An executive with a partial veto has a stronger negotiating position than an executive with only a package veto power. A package veto, or "block veto" or "full veto", vetoes a legislative act as a whole. Partial vetoes are less vulnerable to override than package vetoes, and they are generally considered to give the executive greater power.

A reduction veto, found in several US states, gives the executive the authority to reduce budgetary appropriations that the legislature has made. A pocket veto, meanwhile, takes effect by the executive or head of state taking no action. In the US, a pocket veto can only be exercised near the end of a legislative session; if the deadline for presidential action passes during the session, the bill will become law.

The veto power can be used in different ways. In some cases, it can only be used to prevent changes to the status quo. In other cases, it can also include the ability to make or propose changes. For example, the Indian president can use an amendatory veto to suggest amendments to vetoed bills. The veto is most commonly found in presidential and semi-presidential systems. In parliamentary systems, the head of state often has either a weak veto power or none at all.

Frequently asked questions