Executive Lawmaking: Exploring Powers And Limits

The ability to propose laws is a complex process that varies across different political systems. In bicameral legislatures, the right to initiate legislation may be restricted to the lower house, or the upper house may introduce bills to the lower house. In almost all countries, the right of legislative initiative is granted to members of parliament, either as individuals or as part of a group. However, the executive branch, which includes the president or monarch, can also propose laws in certain systems. For example, in Belgium, the executive has the right of initiative, while in France, ministerial bills are called law projects. In the US, the president can propose measures to Congress during the State of the Union address, and the House of Representatives and the Senate can initiate tax and revenue-related legislation, respectively.

The executive can suggest laws to backers in the legislature

While the executive branch cannot directly propose laws, it can certainly influence the legislative process. In most countries, the executive can suggest the introduction of laws to their supporters in the legislature, who can then formally propose them. This is known as the "right of initiative", and it is held by members of the executive in many nations. For example, in Belgium, the executive (officially the king and his ministers, although the king has no actual power) has the right of initiative, and in France, ministerial bills are called "law projects".

In some systems, members of the executive may even introduce laws themselves if they hold simultaneous membership in the legislature. For instance, in Belgium, members of the executive can introduce laws by themselves. Similarly, in the Czech Republic, members of the upper house, who may also be members of the executive, can introduce bills to the lower house.

The right of initiative is not limited to the executive branch. In almost all countries, members of parliament also have the right of legislative initiative, either as individuals or as part of a group. In the US, for example, a bill can be proposed by a sitting member of the Senate or House of Representatives, or even be suggested during their election campaign. Furthermore, any citizen or citizen group can petition their representative to propose a new or amended law.

While the executive branch may not have the power of direct law proposal, its ability to suggest laws to backers in the legislature provides it with a significant degree of influence in the law-making process.

Executive members can introduce laws themselves in some systems

In most parliaments, the ability of members to introduce legislation is common practice because parliament and government are constructed as antagonists under the system of separation of powers. The executive can propose laws in some systems, either by suggesting the introduction of certain laws to their backers in the legislature or by executive members introducing laws themselves in systems that allow simultaneous membership in the executive and the legislature. For example, in Belgium, the executive, along with members of the Senate and the Chamber of Representatives, has the right of initiative. If the executive submits a bill, it must be sent to the Legislation Department of the Council of State for advice. Non-compliance with this requirement can lead to the annulment of the law. In France, ministerial bills are called 'law projects', and parliament's bills are called 'law proposals'.

In the US, while the ability of members to introduce legislation is common practice, only the House can initiate tax and revenue-related legislation, and only the Senate can draft legislation related to presidential nominations and treaties. In the UK, the ability of members to introduce legislation is insignificant compared to other countries. In Israel, the ability of members to introduce legislation is quite significant.

Bicameral legislatures may restrict the right of initiative to the lower house

The right of legislative initiative refers to the power to propose a new law (bill) in a legislature. In most cases, the government takes the lead in drafting a law, with over 95% of laws being proposed by the government. The right of initiative is usually given to both the government (executive) and individual legislators. However, in bicameral legislatures, the right of initiative may be restricted to the members of the lower house only.

Bicameral legislatures are those that have two chambers, typically an upper house and a lower house. The upper house is usually seen as a more deliberative body, while the lower house is more responsive to the needs and demands of the people. By restricting the right of initiative to the lower house, it ensures that legislation is introduced in a more responsive and agile manner, reflecting the current needs and desires of the populace.

In some cases, the upper house may be given the right to introduce bills to the lower house. For example, in the Czech Republic, members of the upper house can initiate legislation in the lower house. This adds a layer of complexity and potentially delays the legislative process, as bills must go through additional scrutiny and debate in the upper house before being considered by the lower house.

The restriction of the right of initiative to the lower house in bicameral legislatures can be seen as a way to balance efficiency and responsiveness in the law-making process. It allows for the introduction of legislation that is more in tune with the needs of the people, while still allowing for deliberation and amendment in the upper house. This system also ensures that the executive branch, which typically has the power to initiate legislation, works in collaboration with the legislature, as they must seek support from members of the lower house to introduce new laws.

In summary, bicameral legislatures may restrict the right of initiative to the lower house to streamline the legislative process and ensure that law-making is responsive to the needs and demands of the people. While the upper house may play a role in scrutinizing and amending legislation, the power to initiate laws rests with the lower house, reflecting a balance of power between the executive and legislative branches.

Over 80% of European Commission proposals are requested by other bodies

The executive branch of the government can propose laws. In more than 95% of cases, the government takes the lead in drafting a law. The executive must exercise its right of initiative in the House. If the executive submits a bill, it must be sent to the Legislation Department of the Council of State for advice. The right of legislative initiative is given to members of parliament, either as individuals or as part of a group, in almost every country.

The European Commission (EC) is the primary executive arm of the European Union (EU). It operates as a cabinet government, with a number of members of the Commission (directorial system, informally known as "commissioners") corresponding to two-thirds of the member states. The current number of commissioners is 27, including the president. The Commission was established to act as an independent supranational authority separate from governments. Its members are proposed by their member state governments, one from each, but they are bound to act independently and represent the interests of the EU as a whole rather than their home state.

Over 80% of all proposals by the Commission were initially requested by other bodies. The Commission has a near monopoly on legislative initiative, and it has several responsibilities, including developing medium-term strategies, drafting legislation and arbitrating in the legislative process, representing the EU in trade negotiations, and making rules and regulations. For example, the Commission recently adopted two proposals to strengthen equality bodies to fight discrimination in Europe more effectively. The proposals include enhancing the powers of equality bodies in discrimination cases, raising awareness, and sharing expertise.

In the US, laws are proposed by a member of the Senate or House of Representatives

In the United States, laws are proposed by a member of the Senate or House of Representatives. This is known as the "right of initiative", and it is a common practice in most parliaments. In the US, this is the only way that bills can be introduced in Congress.

The idea for a bill can come from a sitting member of either the Senate or the House of Representatives, or it can be proposed during their election campaign. Bills can also be petitioned by citizens or groups of citizens who recommend a new or amended law to a member of Congress that represents them.

Once a bill is introduced, it is assigned to a committee whose members will research, discuss, and make changes to the bill. The bill is then put before that chamber to be voted on. If the bill passes one body of Congress, it goes to the other body to go through a similar process of research, discussion, changes, and voting.

There are some procedural differences between the Senate and the House. While both are considered equal in how they function, only the House can initiate tax and revenue-related legislation. On the other hand, only the Senate can draft legislation related to presidential nominations and treaties. The House processes legislation through a majority vote, while the Senate does so through deliberation and debate before voting.

In addition to members of Congress, state legislatures can also propose laws by passing resolutions to be transmitted to the House and Senate as memorials. If a member of Congress is favourably impressed by the idea, they may introduce the proposal as-is or redraft it.

Frequently asked questions