Felons And Law Practice: New York's Stance

A felony conviction in New York can have serious consequences, including hefty fines, jail time, and a criminal record that can impact various aspects of one's life. While the specific effects of a felony conviction can vary, they often include difficulties in finding employment, obtaining professional licenses, renting an apartment, and social stigma. In the context of practicing law, a felony conviction raises questions about an individual's good moral character, which is a requirement for admission to the New York State Bar. This criteria has sparked debates, as illustrated by a case in 2012, where a convicted violent felon who had served their sentence, completed college and law school, and passed the New York State Bar Exam faced uncertainty about their eligibility to practice law due to the nature of their offense.

Felony convictions result in a criminal record that can impact career prospects

A felony conviction will result in a criminal record, which can have a significant impact on an individual's career prospects. The consequences of a felony conviction can be severe and long-lasting, affecting various aspects of one's professional life.

One of the immediate impacts of a felony conviction is the potential loss of current employment. Employers often have strict policies regarding criminal records, and even if imprisonment is not involved, the mere presence of a felony on an individual's record can lead to termination. This is especially true for positions that require a high level of responsibility or trust, or in sensitive industries like healthcare, education, and government, where maintaining a safe and trustworthy environment is a priority.

Even securing new employment after a felony conviction can be challenging. Most employers conduct background checks during the hiring process, and a criminal record can be a significant barrier. Employers often associate individuals with criminal records with negative traits such as absenteeism, tardiness, drug or alcohol issues, and poor relationships with colleagues and supervisors. This stigma can result in hesitations or concerns from potential employers and reduce the likelihood of hiring, even when qualifications and interview performance are otherwise strong.

The impact of a felony conviction can also extend beyond employment to affect educational opportunities, which are often crucial for career advancement or shifting career paths. Many educational institutions perform background checks and may deny admission based on a criminal record, particularly for programs leading to licensed professions. Even if admitted, individuals with felony convictions may face barriers in accessing financial aid, scholarships, or internships, further limiting their career prospects and reinforcing a cycle of limited opportunities.

The effects of a felony conviction on career prospects are profound and multifaceted, but they are not insurmountable. Strategies such as seeking legal aid for expungement, seal records, or reduced charges, engaging in skill development programs, and leveraging community support networks can help mitigate these challenges. Additionally, initiatives like "ban the box" aim to reduce bias by removing questions about criminal history from initial job applications, and fair hiring practices by employers can create opportunities for second chances.

Felons are barred from certain public offices

In New York, a felony conviction can have a significant impact on an individual's rights and future prospects. While the specific consequences vary depending on the nature and circumstances of the felony, certain restrictions are typically imposed on those with a felony record. One of the key areas affected is the eligibility to hold specific public offices.

The state laws in New York regarding felons' ability to run for public office have evolved over time, reflecting a growing recognition of the importance of providing a pathway for rehabilitation and reintegration into society. According to current New York state law, individuals with a felony conviction are not barred from all public offices. Unless the felony involves bribery of a government official, fraud, or corruption, individuals with a felony record are eligible to hold office in New York. This eligibility extends to both elected and appointed offices, such as governor, judge, legislator, local supervisors, and commissioners.

However, it is important to note that certain public office positions remain off-limits to individuals with a felony conviction. For example, a felony conviction can impede one's ability to obtain the necessary professional licenses for specific fields, such as law or medicine. The professional licensing board may take disciplinary action, including suspending or revoking the license, which would effectively bar felons from practicing in these professions.

Additionally, specific public office roles, such as police officer, corrections officer, parole or probation officer, and district attorney, may be restricted for individuals with a felony record. These positions often require a high level of trust and responsibility, and a felony conviction may be seen as a disqualifying factor. Nevertheless, New York recognizes the importance of facilitating the reintegration of individuals with a felony record into society and encourages their participation in other aspects of civic life.

A felony conviction may result in deportation for non-US citizens

A felony conviction can have serious consequences for non-US citizens in the United States, including deportation. In New York, a conviction for a felony may trigger deportation proceedings for non-US citizens. This is in addition to other potential consequences, such as jail time, fines, and the loss of certain rights and opportunities.

The impact of a felony conviction on a non-US citizen's immigration status can vary depending on their specific situation. If a non-citizen has lawful immigration status, such as a current visa or green card, a felony conviction can result in the loss of that status and make it difficult to change or renew it in the future. It may also impact their ability to become a US citizen.

Even those without lawful immigration status may face additional challenges. A conviction can prevent them from obtaining immigration status in the future, including permanent residence or asylum. It can also lead to detention or deportation by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). ICE may issue a detainer, or "immigration hold," which instructs the local jail to hold the individual in custody, even if they would normally be released.

The specific crimes committed can also impact the likelihood of deportation. Aggravated felonies, certain drug-related crimes, and crimes of "moral turpitude" are all grounds for deportation and can put a lawful permanent resident's immigration status at risk. However, there are some exceptions, such as cases involving minor drug possession for personal use.

It is important for non-US citizens facing criminal charges or convictions in New York to seek legal advice as soon as possible. While a conviction can have significant consequences, there may be legal strategies available to challenge deportation or mitigate its impact on immigration status.

Felons can face challenges in renting apartments and opening bank accounts

While there is no explicit information on whether felons can practice law in New York, they can face challenges in other areas of their lives, such as renting apartments and opening bank accounts.

Renting Apartments as a Felon

Finding housing can be challenging for individuals with a felony on their record. Landlords often conduct background checks as part of the rental application process, and a criminal history may lead to rejection. Some landlords may have a “no-felony-ever” policy, refusing to rent to anyone with a felony conviction. However, this stance has been relaxed in recent years, with guidelines suggesting that landlords should consider applicants who have remained crime-free for a certain period, typically seven years.

When renting to felons, landlords often consider the type of offense and the time spent in society after imprisonment. Sexual offenses, for example, are often a reason for landlords to deny applications due to the perceived difficulty of reforming offenders. To increase their chances of securing housing, felons can provide character references and demonstrate their trustworthiness and positive outlook.

Opening Bank Accounts as a Felon

Opening a bank account as a felon can be challenging, especially if the felony is financial in nature, such as money laundering or check kiting. Banks may access an applicant's bank history report, which reveals if a previous account was closed due to mishandling. A history of financial crimes or a negative perception of felons as dishonest can hinder their ability to open new accounts.

To successfully open a bank account, felons must be honest about their background. Failing to disclose a felony on an application and having it discovered later constitutes fraud, which is punishable by law. Expunging their criminal record can give felons a fresh start and improve their chances of opening a bank account.

The right to vote may be revoked in the case of felony disenfranchisement

In the United States, a person may have their voting rights suspended or withdrawn due to the conviction of a criminal offense. The right to vote may be revoked in the case of felony disenfranchisement, which is one of the consequences of a criminal conviction. In 2022, 4.4 million Americans were banned from voting due to a felony conviction.

The actual class of crimes that result in disenfranchisement varies between jurisdictions, but they are most commonly classed as felonies, or may be based on a certain period of incarceration or other penalty. In some jurisdictions, disenfranchisement is permanent, while in others, suffrage is restored after a person has served their sentence, completed parole, or probation.

New York introduced felony disenfranchisement laws in 1847. Today, New York is among the 23 states where disenfranchisement ends after incarceration is complete. This means that in New York, the right to vote may be revoked in the case of felony disenfranchisement, but only during incarceration.

The long-term effects of a felony conviction can be serious, impacting a person's career and their ability to obtain professional licenses and business permits. This can make it challenging to find a decent job with high earning potential, as many companies run background checks and are less likely to hire those convicted of a felony.

Frequently asked questions