Witnesses, Law, And Order: Cast's Take

In the 2004 episode of *Law & Order*, Can I Get a Witness?, a boy is murdered in a park in front of two witnesses. The witnesses are threatened, and one of them is killed. The episode stars Jesse L. Martin, S. Epatha Merkerson, and Hazelle Goodman. It also features the last appearance of ADA Alexandra Cabot until season 13.

Explore related products

Law & Order: The Complete Series (Seasons 1-20 Bundle) DVD

$109.99 $124.65

Law & Order: The Complete Series

$399.95 $699.99

Law & Order: Season 8 [DVD]

$17.31 $22

Law & Order SVU: Confidential: Everything We Love about the Show We Can't Stop Watching

$21.49 $24.99

Law & Order Los Angeles: The Complete Series [DVD]

$14.99 $19.98

Law & Order: Criminal Intent - The First Year

$18.78 $36.98

The cast of 'Can I Get a Witness'

The cast of "Can I Get a Witness?" from the long-running crime drama "Law & Order" includes Jesse L. Martin, S. Epatha Merkerson, Hazelle Goodman, and Hernandez. The episode aired on February 25, 2004, and is rated TV-14.

In this episode, a boy named Henry, also known as "Big Boy," is murdered in a park by a man on a bicycle, and the case unfolds as the witnesses are threatened and one of them turns up dead. The story focuses on the difficulty of obtaining crime information in certain areas, highlighting the challenges faced by witnesses who may be afraid to come forward or testify openly.

Jesse L. Martin portrays a detective in the show, while S. Epatha Merkerson takes on the role of Mrs. Gordon, the mother of one of the witnesses. Hazelle Goodman, who plays another witness's mother, Mrs. Gordon, and Hernandez, who plays Shayna Rosario, one of the young witnesses, are also part of the cast.

The episode "Can I Get a Witness?" is known for its intense and emotional subject matter, shedding light on the complexities of witness intimidation and the impact it can have on a criminal investigation. It explores themes of fear, justice, and the pursuit of truth in the face of adversity.

Explore related products

Law & Order: The Third Year

$23.94 $36.98

Law & Order UK: Season 2

$16.98

Law & Order: The Second Year

$24.36 $36.98

Law & Order: Season 12 [DVD]

$15.04 $16.88

Law & Order: The Thirteenth Year [DVD]

$26.06 $36.98

Law & Order: The First Year [DVD]

$42.93

The witness's story

In the Law & Order episode "Can I Get a Witness?", a witness to a murder is killed before they can identify the killer. The episode follows the story of two witnesses to the murder of a boy in a park by a man on a bicycle. The witnesses are repeatedly threatened, and one of them, nineteen-year-old Henry, also known as "Big Boy", ends up dead.

The remaining witness, Shayna Rosario, is convinced by McCoy and Southerlyn to testify, and they are able to re-arrest the suspects, Keyes and Duggan. However, Shayna panics on the stand and refuses to name the killers directly. She explains to the judge that Duggan tried to "convince" her not to talk by taking her to see his lawyer, Wills, who is now complicit in the intimidation. Despite this, the jury finds Rivers guilty of Jimmy's murder, but Keyes and Duggan are acquitted of all charges.

In another Law & Order episode, a woman, Lainie McAlister, is raped in her apartment building's stairwell. Nardalee Ulah, the witness to the attack, disappears out of fear of being deported to her home country, the Republic of the Congo, where she experienced repeated rape and violence. After Nardalee is found, she shares her story, and her testimony leads to the rapist, Kelton, being found guilty. As a result, Nardalee is granted permanent residence in the U.S. with a specialized visa.

Explore related products

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit - The Eighth Year

$21.83

Law & Order Special Victims Unit - The First Year

$38.56

Law & Order: The Tenth Year [DVD]

$36.99

Law & Order: Criminal Intent - Season Four

$16.9 $36.98

Witness

$5 $5.99

Witness for the Prosecution [DVD]

$9.99

The verdict

In the Law & Order episode "Can I Get a Witness?", the verdict is delivered by the jury, who find the defendants either guilty or not guilty on multiple charges. The episode follows the murder of a young boy, Henry, also known as "Big Boy," who is shot by a man on a bicycle. Two witnesses, Shayna Rosario and Jimmy Gordon, identify Foster Keyes and Ronald Duggan as the potential killers.

During the trial, Keyes and Duggan are accused of witness intimidation and murder. Despite Shayna's testimony, where she describes feeling intimidated by Duggan, the jury finds them not guilty on all charges. However, another defendant, Rivers, is found guilty of Jimmy's murder.

In a separate but related case, the episode also explores the rape of Lainie McAlister, which is investigated by Benson and Stabler. They discover an eyewitness, Nardalee Ulah, who has disappeared due to fears of deportation. Nardalee is eventually found and testifies in court. The jury finds the accused, Bryce Kelton, not guilty of witness tampering and murder but guilty of rape.

Explore related products

Witness 4k Ultra HD [Standard Edition] [4K UHD]

$24.99 $5.99

Witness (Special Collector's Widescreen Edition)

$9.89 $12.99

Witness (1985)

$13.47

Witness For The Prosecution

$18.32 $19.99

Witness

$12.83

Witness For the Prosecution [DVD]

$15.19

The investigation

The detectives working on the case, Lennie Briscoe and Ed Green, discover cocaine on the victim's body, leading them to suspect that the murder was drug-related. They trace the bicycle used in the murder to Foster Keyes, and find him hiding at his girlfriend, Jannette Richards', house. Despite Keyes' denial of the murder, Briscoe and Green arrest him, along with Ronald Duggan, for the murder of Henry.

The prosecution team, consisting of McCoy and Southerlyn, face challenges as they attempt to prosecute Keyes and Duggan. They encounter witness intimidation and illegal intimidation tactics employed by the defendants. Shayna Rosario, one of the key witnesses, initially refuses to testify, but McCoy and Southerlyn are able to convince her by promising protection. During the trial, Shayna explains the intimidation tactics used by Duggan and his lawyer, Gerald Wills, which included slipping her money and making indirect threats. Despite their efforts, Keyes and Duggan are found not guilty on all charges, while another defendant, Rivers, is found guilty of Jimmy's murder.

In a separate but related development, the episode also follows the story of Nardalee Ulah, an eyewitness in a rape case. Nardalee had previously experienced rape and violence in her home country, the Republic of the Congo, and fears being deported back there. She is tracked down by detectives Benson and Stabler, who are investigating the rape of Lainie McAlister. Despite Nardalee's testimony, the rapist, Bryce Kelton, is found not guilty of witness tampering and murder but is convicted of rape. After the case, Benson delivers the news that Nardalee has been granted permanent residence in the U.S., and Nardalee shares her plans to return to her homeland to support other Congolese women who have endured similar experiences.

Explore related products

Cast Away Stones: An Eyewitness Account of 9/11 and Memoir of a Survivor, Soldier, Citizen

$13.99 $15.99

WITNESS FOR THE PROSECUTION

$16.13 $34.99

Clouds of Witness by Dorothy L. Sayers: A Classic Murder Mystery Featuring Lord Peter Wimsey (Grapevine Edition)

$0.56 $14.95

Witness [Blu-ray] (Japanese Import - Region A)

$21.5 $5.99

I Witness

$5.87

Witness

$9.26

The challenges faced by witnesses

Witnesses play a crucial role in the criminal justice system, providing information, evidence, and testimony that can significantly impact the outcome of a case. While their participation is essential for delivering justice, witnesses often face various challenges and risks.

One of the primary challenges faced by witnesses is the potential risk to their safety and well-being. In certain cases, particularly those involving high-profile individuals, organised crime, or violent offenders, witnesses may be subjected to threats, intimidation, or even physical harm. This risk can deter witnesses from coming forward or cooperating with law enforcement, as seen in the "Law & Order" episode "Can I Get a Witness?", where two witnesses to a murder are repeatedly threatened, and one is killed.

Another challenge for witnesses is the emotional and psychological toll of the process. Testifying in court can be a daunting and stressful experience, leading to feelings of confusion, frustration, fear, and anger. The scrutiny and cross-examination they face can be intense, and any inconsistencies or perceived biases in their testimony can affect their credibility. Witnesses may also struggle with the moral dilemma of balancing their desire to do the right thing by sharing crucial information with their fear of potential repercussions.

Additionally, witnesses may encounter challenges related to their memory and accuracy of recollection. The stress of the event, leading questions, and the passage of time can all contribute to errors or discrepancies in their testimony. Eyewitness testimonies, in particular, are prone to these fallibilities, and false memories or misleading interpretations can inadvertently impact the course of the trial.

Furthermore, witnesses may face practical challenges, such as the time commitment and inconvenience of participating in legal proceedings. This may include taking time off work, arranging childcare, or travelling to court appearances. These demands can be especially burdensome for witnesses who are also victims of the crime, as they navigate their own recovery and healing process.

To mitigate these challenges, witness protection programs, support services, and victim-witness coordinators play a vital role in ensuring the safety, well-being, and fair treatment of witnesses throughout the criminal justice process.

Frequently asked questions