Expunged Records: Can Law Enforcement Still Access Them?

While expungement laws vary by state, certain individuals and organizations can access expunged records. Law enforcement agencies, including police, can access sealed records in most states. Courts, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies can also use expunged records for criminal investigations, charging and sentencing decisions, and future criminal proceedings. In some states, such as Mississippi and North Carolina, expunged records are accessible to law enforcement for specific purposes. Additionally, certain government agencies, such as those involved in child protection, corrections, and public health, may have access to expunged records during background screening for sensitive positions.

Law enforcement can access sealed records

While expunged records are hidden from public view and cannot be seen by law enforcement, sealed records are accessible by law enforcement agencies. This includes the police, the courts, states' attorneys, and other people involved in the criminal justice system.

In the United States, expungement laws vary by state, but generally, expunged records are not completely destroyed. Instead, they are sealed and hidden from public view, with certain government agencies retaining access. These agencies include courts, law enforcement, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies, who can access sealed records for future criminal investigations, charging decisions, and sentencing. For example, in North Carolina, state judges have access to expunged records and can consider them during trials for subsequent offenses. In Mississippi, expunged records must be disclosed when applying for jobs with law enforcement agencies. In Utah, both state law enforcement and federal authorities have access to expunged records.

Additionally, certain types of employers can access sealed records, such as those in the military and some healthcare fields. Agencies reviewing applications for professional licenses in fields like law, pharmacy, or medicine may also have access. Furthermore, sealed records may be accessible during background screening for positions in law enforcement, child protection, corrections, public health, elections, and auditing.

It is important to note that the process of expungement gives former offenders a second chance by allowing them to apply for jobs or housing without their criminal record being a hindrance. While expunged records are not visible to the general public, it is crucial to understand the specific expungement laws in each state to know who can access sealed records.

Courts, prosecutors and judges can access expunged records

While expungement offers a chance to move forward with your life, it does not completely erase your criminal record. Certain government agencies, including courts, law enforcement, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies, can access expunged records for various purposes.

Courts, prosecutors, and judges can access expunged records in specific situations. For example, in North Carolina, state judges can access expunged records during sentencing for a subsequent offense. In such cases, the court may consider the expunged offenses when determining the appropriate punishment. Similarly, prosecutors can use expunged records to enhance future charges and sentences. They can also use them to impeach a witness or discredit them by introducing evidence of their past convictions.

In some states, like Mississippi, individuals must disclose their expunged records when applying for specific licenses or jobs, such as in law enforcement or with the military. Courts and prosecutors can access these records during background checks for such positions. Additionally, when seeking government jobs or professional licenses, expunged records may be disclosed to criminal justice agencies and state licensing boards.

It is important to note that expungement laws vary by state, and each state has its own rules regarding the types of criminal convictions eligible for expungement. While expunged records may not be visible to private employers or landlords, they can still impact future opportunities, especially those involving sensitive work or vulnerable populations. Therefore, it is advisable to consult with legal professionals specializing in expungement issues to understand the specific laws and limitations in your state.

Employers can access expunged records in certain circumstances

While expungement seals or destroys an individual's criminal record, preventing it from appearing on most employer background checks, there are certain circumstances in which employers can access expunged records.

In most states, individuals working with vulnerable populations, such as children, the elderly, or individuals with physical or behavioural impairments, are required to disclose expunged records on employment applications. This includes anyone working in schools, childcare facilities, hospitals, clinics, or nursing homes. Additionally, those who work in a fiduciary capacity, handle confidential or financial records, or provide in-home services, such as plumbers or electricians, may also have their expunged records accessed by employers.

Furthermore, certain government agencies, including courts, law enforcement, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies, typically retain access to expunged records. This access is often utilised for future criminal investigations, charging decisions, and sentencing enhancements. Similarly, some state professional licensing agencies, such as the Board of Education, can access expunged records, particularly when an individual applies for a concealed weapons permit.

Although expunged records are generally hidden from private employers, there are rare exceptions. For instance, if an individual undergoes a fingerprint background check, which is typically conducted for federal employment or certain industries working with vulnerable populations, their expunged records may be accessible through the federal database. Additionally, some third-party organisations collate public arrest and conviction records, providing background check information to employers, which may include expunged records from public databases.

Expunged records can be used in future criminal proceedings

While expungement laws aim to give people a better chance at becoming productive citizens, they do not wipe the slate clean in most instances. In most states, expunged records are sealed, not destroyed. This means that certain government agencies, including law enforcement, will almost always have access to expunged records.

Courts, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies can access expunged records for future criminal investigations, charging and sentencing decisions, and impeachment (discrediting) of a witness. For example, a prosecutor can use evidence of a prior conviction after another drunk driving arrest for a second DUI offense. If you are arrested again for another crime, law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, and the criminal court may still be able to see your expunged records and use them against you. The court can use your prior conviction as allowed by state and federal law. Many states will allow previous criminal convictions that have been expunged to be used in the prosecution or sentencing of a later arrest or conviction. An expunged conviction can be used during the prosecution of the crime as evidence of prior behavior or a pattern of criminal behavior.

Additionally, expunged records can impact individuals in some legal proceedings. For example, if you are facing deportation proceedings, an expunged conviction can be used as evidence to support your removal from the country. Similarly, in some states, expunged records must be disclosed when applying for certain government jobs, such as positions in law enforcement or with vulnerable populations like children or the elderly. In these cases, expunged records can be used to determine an individual's suitability for the position.

It is important to note that expungement laws vary by state, and there may be instances where an expunged record will still follow you. Therefore, it is advisable to consult with a criminal defense attorney to understand the specific laws and limitations in your state.

Expungement laws vary by state

While expungement laws vary by state, there are a few general rules. For the most part, private employers, landlords, and others who perform a background check will not find your expunged records. After your record is expunged, in most states, you are legally permitted to answer "no" when asked about criminal records on employment or rental applications.

However, certain government agencies will almost always have access to expunged records. Courts, law enforcement, prosecutors, and other criminal justice agencies can access expunged records for future criminal investigations and charging and sentencing decisions. If you're seeking employment with the government or in a position involving sensitive clients or work, you'll likely need to disclose certain expunged convictions. Many states and the federal government require disclosure of an expunged record when applying for government jobs where the position could involve access to confidential or sensitive records, require security clearances, or place workers in contact with vulnerable individuals.

In North Carolina, state judges have access to expunged records. If you are arrested for a subsequent offense, the court will have your expunged offenses to consider during your trial. In Mississippi, if you obtain expungement of your conviction, you are legally required to disclose it if you apply for a job with the military or law enforcement agency or request any professional license (such as attorney or physician). In Utah, state law allows both law enforcement agencies and federal authorities access to expunged records. State professional licensing agencies (such as the Board of Education) can get access to your records, and your record will be disclosed to the Bureau of Criminal Identification if you apply for a concealed weapons permit.

In Oklahoma, "expungement" means "sealed". When a record is sealed, it's hidden from public view, but it isn't destroyed. Law enforcement agencies can still find your criminal history. In Alabama, the law allows for expungement for multiple situations, with application fees, court fees, and lawyers' fees to be paid by the applicant. However, convictions are not eligible for expungement. Arizona's expungement equivalent is "setting aside" a conviction, allowing a defendant to petition the court to have a conviction set aside after the terms of the sentence are met. In Connecticut, individuals within a certain age group are defined as "Youthful Offenders", and most of those convicted within the defined age limitations may have their criminal record erased. In Florida, a Certificate of Eligibility from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement is required prior to petitioning the court for an order to seal or expunge a record. In Maryland, expungement may be available after 10-15 years without subsequent offenses for many misdemeanors and certain types of felonies, such as drug crimes and theft crimes.

Frequently asked questions