Biden's Legal Troubles: Did He Break The Law?

President Joe Biden has been at the center of several controversies during his term in office. One such controversy involves the mishandling of classified documents, which were found at his Washington think tank office and his personal residence in Wilmington, Delaware. While Special Counsel Robert Hur determined that Biden willfully retained and disclosed classified materials, he did not bring charges against the president, citing Biden's cooperation and the difficulty of securing a conviction. This decision has sparked mixed reactions, with Biden's lawyers criticizing Hur for overreach, while Trump and his allies have seized on the report to underline concerns about Biden's age and cognitive fitness for office.

Biden retained classified documents

In February 2024, Special Counsel Robert Hur released a report concluding that President Joe Biden "willfully" retained classified documents after his vice presidency. The investigation, which lasted around a year, was initiated in January 2023 by Attorney General Merrick Garland, who appointed Hur to determine whether any laws were violated in the mishandling of records from Biden's time as vice president.

The report found that Biden kept classified documents in an unlocked drawer, including "documents about military and foreign policy in Afghanistan" and "handwritten entries about issues of national security and foreign policy implicating sensitive intelligence sources and methods." Additionally, Biden read classified information from his notebooks to his ghostwriter on at least three occasions. However, Hur determined that the evidence did not establish Biden's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, and therefore, no charges were filed.

The White House, while pleased with the outcome, disagreed with some of the characterizations in the report, particularly those related to Biden's memory and mental state. They asserted that Biden takes classified information seriously and has always protected it. Biden himself stated that his "memory is fine" and that he cooperated fully with the investigation.

The report highlighted key differences between Biden's case and the ongoing prosecution of former President Donald Trump for mishandling classified documents. Unlike Trump, Biden returned the documents, cooperated with the investigation, and did not resist or attempt to conceal the records.

The findings sparked political controversy, with critics questioning Biden's fitness for reelection due to concerns about his age and memory. However, the decision not to prosecute Biden underscored the distinction between his handling of classified documents and the more serious offenses allegedly committed by Trump.

No charges were filed

The White House expressed pleasure at the investigation's conclusion and maintained that Biden takes classified information seriously. Biden's lawyer, Bob Bauer, stated that criminal charges were unwarranted and criticized the special counsel for investigative excess. White House lawyer Richard Sauber also disagreed with some comments in the report but affirmed that the decision not to prosecute was firmly based on the facts and evidence.

Biden himself pushed back against the suggestion of a poor memory, stating that his "memory is fine." He brimmingly denied the accusation of willfully keeping classified material, calling it "just plain wrong." Biden's lawyers also defended him, stating that memory lapses during the interview were not unusual for someone recalling events from years ago.

The decision not to prosecute drew criticism from some, including Trump ally Alex Pfeiffer, who commented, "If you're too senile to stand trial, then you're too senile to be president." However, Democrats saw the outcome as a sign that Trump could have avoided charges by cooperating with prosecutors.

Biden's memory was deemed poor

On February 8, 2024, Special Counsel Robert Hur released a report concluding that President Joe Biden would not face criminal charges for mishandling classified documents. However, the report described Biden as a "well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory," sparking intense political controversy.

Biden, who was 81 years old at the time, vehemently denied having memory issues and rebuked the suggestion that he had forgotten when his son, Beau, had died. He asserted that his "memory is fine" and that the special counsel's report included "extraneous commentary" on his mental state. The White House also pushed back on the characterizations of Biden's memory, with his lawyers arguing that his "inability to recall dates or details of events that happened years ago is neither surprising nor unusual."

The report noted that Biden struggled to recall significant personal milestones, such as the death of his son and the years he served as vice president under Barack Obama. During a recorded conversation with a ghostwriter in 2017 and an interview with investigators in 2023, Biden's memory was described as "significantly limited." The transcript of his interview with the special counsel confirmed repeated lapses regarding details of how classified information was handled and other missteps.

Concerns about Biden's age, memory, and mental acuity had been raised throughout his term as president, especially as he headed into the 2024 presidential election. An NBC News poll conducted before the release of Hur's report found that 76% of voters expressed major or moderate concerns about Biden's mental and physical health. The negative portrayal of Biden's memory in the report added to the political controversy, with some comparing it to FBI director James Comey's criticism of Hillary Clinton during the 2016 presidential campaign.

While Biden's memory issues did not result in criminal charges, they raised questions about his fitness for reelection and provided ammunition for his political opponents. Republican critics, such as Alex Pfeiffer, a spokesman for the pro-Trump group Make America Great Again, seized on the report to question Biden's cognitive ability to serve as president.

The controversy surrounding Biden's memory highlighted the ongoing concerns about his age and mental acuity, which had been a source of vulnerability for him politically.

Biden's actions risked national security

President Joe Biden's actions have been deemed to pose "serious risks to national security". Special Counsel Robert Hur, who led a 15-month investigation into Biden's handling of classified documents, concluded that the president "willfully" retained and disclosed classified materials after his vice presidency. These documents included sensitive information related to military and foreign policy, as well as national security and intelligence matters.

While Hur determined that Biden's actions did not warrant criminal charges, he criticised the president's handling of the sensitive records. The report stated that Biden kept the documents in an unlocked drawer and that some were found in a damaged box in his garage. This raised concerns about the potential compromise of classified information.

Biden's actions have sparked embarrassment and raised questions about his fitness to serve as president, especially given his advanced age. Critics have pointed to his memory lapses and confusion during public appearances as further evidence of his declining mental state.

In response to the report, Biden pushed back against descriptions of his recall, stating that his "memory is fine." He also noted that he returned the documents, which sets him apart from his rival, former President Donald Trump, who allegedly declined to do so.

Biden's lawyers criticised Hur's report, stating that it included "inaccurate and inappropriate comments." They argued that Biden's memory lapses were not unusual and that such comments had no place in a Department of Justice report.

No charges due to Biden's cooperation

After a 15-month investigation, Special Counsel Robert Hur determined that President Joe Biden would not face charges for "willfully" retaining and disclosing classified documents. Hur's 388-page report concluded that Biden's actions did not violate any laws, despite criticism of his handling of sensitive records. The White House fully cooperated with the investigation, declining to assert privilege over any portion of the report.

Biden's cooperation with the probe was described as "extraordinary" by White House special counsel Richard Sauber, who also emphasized that the decision not to pursue charges was firmly based on the facts and evidence. Biden himself stated that he "cooperated completely, threw up no roadblocks, and sought no delays," even during a period of international crisis. This level of cooperation stood in stark contrast to that of former President Trump, who has been charged with retaining highly sensitive national security documents at his Florida resort.

While Biden's actions were deemed lawful, Hur's report did raise concerns about the potential risks to national security. The report detailed how Biden kept classified documents and notebooks containing sensitive information in an unlocked drawer and disclosed classified information to his ghostwriter on several occasions. However, the investigation found that some of these documents may have been taken to Biden's home while he was still vice president, when he had the authority to possess them.

The decision not to prosecute Biden was influenced by several factors, including his advanced age and the potential sympathy he could evoke from jurors. Hur noted that Biden presented himself as a "sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory," and that it would be challenging to convince a jury to convict him of a serious felony requiring a willful mental state. Biden's lawyers also criticized Hur's report, arguing that comments about Biden's memory had no place in a Department of Justice report.

In conclusion, while Biden's handling of classified documents sparked controversy and raised national security concerns, his cooperation with the investigation and the specific circumstances of the case led to the decision not to pursue criminal charges against him.

Frequently asked questions