Dole's Banana Business: Lawful Or Unethical?

Dole plc, previously known as Dole Food Company, is an Irish-American agricultural multinational corporation and one of the world's largest producers of fruit and vegetables. The company has a long history of legal controversies, including lawsuits related to the use of the pesticide DBCP, which was banned in the US in 1977. In 2007, the company was ordered by a Nicaraguan court to pay banana workers $489.4 million in compensation for health issues caused by the pesticide, but Dole refused to pay the fine. In the same year, Chiquita, one of Dole's main competitors, pleaded guilty to making payments to the paramilitary group United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia (AUC) and was fined $25 million. In 2009, Dole was sued by families of banana workers in Colombia, who alleged that the company had funded militias that killed thousands, including trade union organisers. The suit was dismissed the following year.

Dole's use of the pesticide DBCP

Dole plc, previously named Dole Food Company, is an Irish-American agricultural multinational corporation and one of the world's largest producers of fruit and vegetables. In 2001, the company was sued by Nicaraguan banana plantation workers who alleged that they had suffered adverse health effects as a result of exposure to the pesticide DBCP, which had been banned in the USA in 1977. The pesticide was manufactured by Dow Chemical and supplied to Dole, who continued to use it in their Latin American plantations until 1982.

DBCP, or 1,2-Dibromo-3-chloropropane, is a dense, colorless liquid that is the active ingredient in the nematicide Nemagon, also known as Fumazone. It was formerly used as a soil fumigant and nematocide in American agriculture, and it is highly effective in fighting pests that attack the roots of fruit trees and boosting harvest weights by 20%. However, it was discovered that high levels of exposure to DBCP caused male sterility, with workers at Dow Chemical's plant producing DBCP experiencing reproductive issues. Animal experiments also showed that DBCP sterilized rabbits.

Despite warnings from Dow Chemical about the health effects of DBCP, Dole threatened to sue Dow if it stopped DBCP shipments. As a result, Dow shipped half a million gallons of DBCP to Dole, much of which was reclaimed from other users. Plantation workers who became sterile or suffered other health issues subsequently sued Dow and Dole in Nicaraguan courts, and under a special law passed specifically for DBCP litigation, the courts ruled in favor of the plaintiffs and awarded them over $600 million in damages. However, when the plaintiffs' lawyers tried to enforce the judgment in the United States, the U.S. District Court in Florida held that there was no scientific evidence to support the claims and that the defendants were not at fault.

The use of DBCP by Dole has been the subject of numerous lawsuits and negative publicity, including a documentary film titled "Bananas!" by Fredrik Gertten, which followed the story of the Nicaraguan banana workers' lawsuits. In the film, Dole's chief executive, David Delorenzo, publicly admitted that the company continued to use the banned pesticide, ignoring the potential health impact on its workers. As a result of the film and the lawsuits, Dole has faced significant criticism and embarrassment, with the story highlighting the power dynamics between industrialized and less industrialized nations in the global food industry.

Dole's involvement in Colombian paramilitary groups

Dole Food Company, one of the world's largest producers of fruits and vegetables, has been accused of involvement with paramilitary groups in Colombia. In 2009, the company was sued by families of banana workers in Colombia, who alleged that Dole bankrolled militias that killed thousands of Colombians, including trade union organizers. While this suit was dismissed the following year, Dole's association with these groups has been further evidenced by the testimony of Salvatore Mancuso, a leader of illegal paramilitary groups, who stated that Dole paid his men one US cent for each box of bananas they exported.

Mancuso's allegations were supported by his lawyer, Hernando Benavides, and Jesús Vargas, a lawyer for victims of paramilitary violence. According to Mancuso, it was common practice for Colombian businesses to pay paramilitaries a "war tax", which served as a form of extortion and protection against attacks. While a spokesman for Dole denied any involvement with illegal organizations in Colombia, the company has faced similar accusations in other countries, including the Philippines, where workers on supply plantations reported being harassed, intimidated, and held at gunpoint by the military due to their union activities.

In addition to the allegations of funding paramilitary groups, Dole has also been implicated in other controversial practices, such as the use of banned pesticides and the exploitation of child labor. These accusations highlight ongoing concerns about human rights abuses and unethical labor practices within the banana industry, particularly in Latin America.

Dole's exploitation of workers

Dole plc, previously named Dole Food Company, is an agricultural multinational corporation with a long history of exploiting its workers. The company, which is among the world's largest producers of fruit and vegetables, has been accused of engaging in harmful labour practices that prioritise profit over the well-being of its employees.

One of the most notable examples of Dole's exploitation of its workers occurred in Nicaragua, where banana plantation workers filed a lawsuit against the company for exposing them to a banned pesticide, DBCP, which caused sterility and other adverse health effects. Despite initially losing the case, Dole employed a litigation strategy to discredit the workers, arguing that a conspiracy had been orchestrated to defraud the company. This counter-attack, known as the 'kill step', successfully overturned the original verdict, highlighting the company's willingness to prioritise its reputation and financial interests over the health and well-being of its employees.

Dole has also been accused of exploiting child labour in the Philippines and Ecuador, with children as young as eight working in dangerous conditions, handling sharp tools and pesticides without adequate protection. Additionally, workers on Dole's supply plantations in the Philippines reported being harassed, intimidated, and held at gunpoint by the military due to their union activities.

Furthermore, Dole has been criticised for its treatment of adult workers, who are often rehired on short-term contracts to avoid providing legally mandated benefits and to prevent them from organising and bargaining for better working conditions. This practice allows the company to dismiss employees without technically firing them, as their contracts are simply not renewed. Both Dole and its competitor, Del Monte, have engaged in this tactic, rehiring workers with new contracts featuring reduced benefits, longer work hours, and significant pay cuts.

The company's response to criticism and attempts by workers to unionise further exemplifies its exploitative nature. In addition to using litigation to silence critics, Dole has been accused of using physical violence to repress unionisation attempts.

In conclusion, Dole's exploitative labour practices, including the use of child labour, repression of unionisation, and prioritisation of profit over employee well-being, have had detrimental effects on the lives and health of its workers. These practices have been enabled by the company's financial power and the lack of effective regulation and labour law enforcement in the regions where it operates.

Dole's use of child labour

Dole plc, previously known as Dole Food Company, is one of the world's largest producers of fruit and vegetables, with 38,500 full-time and seasonal employees and operations in 75 countries. The company has faced criticism and legal action for its use of child labour in its supply chain, particularly in the Philippines and Ecuador, where it is a major producer of bananas.

In the Philippines, child labour is defined as the illegal employment of children below the age of fifteen who are not under the sole responsibility of their parents or legal guardian, or whose work endangers their life, safety, health, morals, or impairs their normal development, including schooling. Despite laws and regulations against child labour in the country, it remains a pervasive issue due to widespread poverty and unemployment. In 2012, the National Statistics Office reported that there were around 5.5 million child labourers aged 5-17 in the Philippines, with 2.1 million of them working in hazardous environments, mainly in the agricultural sector. Banana production is one of the industries in the Philippines that relies on child labour, with children as young as eight working on banana plantations.

In Ecuador, where Dole has significant operations, a 2002 Human Rights Watch report found widespread child labour on banana plantations, with children working 12-hour days and performing dangerous and physically demanding tasks. These children often lacked access to education, adequate drinking water, and bathroom facilities. They were paid just over half the legal minimum wage and were exposed to agrochemicals without proper protective equipment, suffering various negative health effects as a result.

Dole has been criticised for its role in perpetuating child labour in its supply chain and for failing to take full responsibility for the conditions on the plantations from which it sources its products. The company has also faced lawsuits related to the use of the banned pesticide DBCP, which has caused adverse health effects on workers in its banana plantations in Nicaragua. While Dole has denied wrongdoing and attempted to block media coverage of these issues, it has faced significant legal repercussions, including fines and compensation payments to affected individuals.

Dole's environmental impact

Dole plc, previously named Dole Food Company and Standard Fruit Company, is an Irish-American agricultural multinational corporation. It is one of the world's largest producers of fruit and vegetables, with a broad range of products and markets. As of 2021, the company had approximately 250 processing plants and distribution centres worldwide, in addition to 109,000 acres of farmland and real estate.

Pesticide Use

Dole has been criticised for its use of pesticides, particularly the banned pesticide DBCP, which has been linked to adverse health effects on workers in its banana plantations. The documentary "Bananas!" highlighted the plight of Nicaraguan banana plantation workers who brought a legal case against Dole for the use of DBCP. The pesticide was banned in the USA in 1977 due to its impact on male fertility, but Dole continued to use it in its plantations outside the country until 1982. As a result, workers reported issues with fertility, and women reported losing children. These workers are now involved in an ongoing legal battle in the US to seek compensation.

Environmental Practices

Dole has stated its commitment to environmental responsibility and claims to be constantly improving and enhancing its growing techniques to create food that is "easy on the planet." The company has established environmental practices across its operations and is dedicated to building sustainable farming practices. Dole has invested in renewable energy projects, such as wind turbines and solar panel systems, and has committed to the Science Based Target Initiative, placing climate action as a priority alongside water stewardship, biodiversity, waste management, and packaging reduction.

Water Use and Contamination

Banana production is water-intensive, and Dole has been implicated in water contamination issues. Banana fields require a constant level of moisture, so they are interlaced with channels for irrigation and drainage, which can increase soil erosion and facilitate the flow of agrochemicals and silt into adjacent waterways. This type of runoff has caused damage to estuaries and coral reefs, particularly in coastal plantation areas.

Clear-Cutting and Chemical Use

Dole's banana cultivation has been associated with clear-cutting tracts of primary rainforest to make way for banana monoculture. These plantations are abandoned once factors like soil depletion or pest infestation lower yields, and vast quantities of pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, and synthetic fertilizers are used to maintain the monoculture. The use of these chemicals poses a threat to workers and the surrounding environment, including nearby rainforests and wildlife.

Social Responsibility

Dole has expressed its commitment to social responsibility and claims to support its worldwide employees with healthy and safe work environments. The company has established programmes such as CR&S (Corporate Sustainability Policies) to guide its operations and improve the lives and livelihoods of its farmers and workers. However, there have been reports of human rights abuses and labour issues on Dole's plantations, including the repression of worker attempts to unionize and the exploitation of child labour.

In summary, Dole's environmental impact has been a subject of scrutiny, with criticisms regarding pesticide use, water contamination, clear-cutting rainforests, and chemical usage. At the same time, the company has made efforts to improve its environmental practices, invest in renewable energy, and establish sustainability frameworks. The complex nature of Dole's environmental impact highlights the challenges faced by large-scale agricultural companies in balancing economic interests with ecological sustainability and social responsibility.

Frequently asked questions