Did Florida's House Bill 7125 Become Law?

House Bill 7125, also known as the ELITE Act of 2020, was introduced to the House Committee on Armed Services on June 8, 2020, by Rep. Anthony G. Brown [D-MD-4]. The bill aimed to reform Florida's criminal justice system by increasing the theft threshold for felonies, cutting mandatory driver's license suspensions, and expanding the eligibility of pretrial diversion programs and drug-treatment courts. It also addressed issues such as juvenile justice, access to therapeutic treatment courts, and support for inmates re-entering society. The bill was passed in the Florida House Judiciary Committee on April 9, 2019, and signed by the Governor, becoming law.

Raising the felony threshold for grand theft

The felony threshold for grand theft is the minimum monetary value of stolen property that qualifies the crime as a felony. In the US, the threshold varies by state, typically ranging from $500 to $5,000.

In May 2019, the Florida Legislature approved House Bill 7125, which included a provision to raise the state's felony theft threshold from $300 to $750. This change brought Florida more in line with other states, though the threshold still falls short of that of Texas, which is set at $2,500.

The distinction between grand theft and petty theft is significant as it determines the severity of the charges and subsequent penalties. Grand theft, being a felony, carries more severe consequences, including longer jail sentences, larger fines, and more significant long-term impacts on an individual's record.

The value of the stolen property is a critical factor in determining whether a theft qualifies as grand theft. This value is not always easy to determine and may involve considering factors beyond just the market price or original cost of the item. The condition, age, and personal significance of the item to its owner can also play a role in assessing its value.

In addition to the value of the property, the intent behind the act is another crucial aspect of grand theft. To qualify as grand theft, there must be a deliberate intention to permanently deprive the owner of their property. This means that the accused must have knowingly and willfully taken the property with no intention of returning it.

Grand theft can take many forms, from shoplifting expensive items to complex acts of embezzlement. Regardless of the specific scenario, the pivotal factor is always the value of the property involved.

By raising the felony threshold for grand theft, House Bill 7125 made a small step towards comprehensive criminal justice reform in Florida. However, critics argue that more substantial reforms are needed to address issues such as over-incarceration, excessive sentencing, and systemic racial bias in the state's criminal justice system.

Reforming the juvenile justice practice

House Bill 7125, which was passed in 2019, includes a wide range of criminal justice reform measures. One of the key focuses of the bill is reforming the juvenile justice practice, specifically the mandatory direct file for juvenile defenders. Here are some key details on how the bill aims to achieve this:

• Repealing mandatory direct file for juvenile defenders: This reform gives judges more discretion in handling cases involving juvenile offenders. Instead of automatically processing juvenile cases in adult criminal court, judges can now consider the specific circumstances and explore alternative options.
• Revising juvenile offender sentencing eligibility: The bill allows those who commit offenses when they are under 21 to be sentenced under more lenient guidelines. Previously, individuals were sentenced as adults if they were over 21 at the time of sentencing, even if they were under 21 when the offense occurred. This change ensures that youthful offenders are treated differently from adult offenders.
• Expanding access to therapeutic treatment courts: The bill provides more opportunities for juvenile offenders to access therapeutic treatment courts, which can help address the underlying issues that may have contributed to their involvement in the criminal justice system.
• Authorizing circuit courts to create community courts: This provision enables the establishment of community courts to handle certain misdemeanors, offering an alternative approach to traditional criminal justice processing.
• Boosting training and education: By increasing access to training and education, juvenile offenders have a better chance of successful rehabilitation and reintegration into society.
• Automatic sealing of criminal records: House Bill 7125 allows for the automatic sealing of criminal records in cases where charges were not filed or were dismissed. This helps reduce the long-term impact of a criminal record on an individual's future opportunities.
• Expanding eligibility for pre-trial diversion programs: This aspect of the bill provides juvenile offenders with more options for diversion and alternative sentencing, which can help them avoid the immediate consequences of a criminal conviction.

Overall, House Bill 7125 represents a significant step towards reforming the juvenile justice practice in Florida, offering a more nuanced approach to handling juvenile offenders and providing opportunities for rehabilitation and a reduced impact on their future prospects.

Expanding access to therapeutic treatment courts

House Bill 7125, which was passed in the Florida House Judiciary Committee on April 9, 2019, includes a provision to expand access to therapeutic treatment courts. This expansion of access is part of a wide-ranging set of criminal justice reform measures, which also includes helping inmates find jobs after leaving prison, reducing direct filing of juveniles in adult criminal court, and increasing the amount necessary for a felony theft charge. The bill was introduced and championed by Rep. Paul Renner, chair of the House Judiciary Committee.

The therapeutic treatment courts are designed to provide treatment and support for individuals with mental health and substance abuse issues. By expanding access to these courts, the bill aims to increase the availability of treatment and support services for a larger number of individuals in need. This expansion is expected to have a positive impact on the well-being and rehabilitation of those struggling with mental health and substance abuse issues, offering them a chance to access the necessary resources for recovery.

Additionally, the bill authorizes circuit courts to establish community courts to address certain misdemeanors. This provision further contributes to the goal of providing alternative avenues for justice and support, particularly for individuals facing misdemeanor charges. It allows for a more tailored approach to addressing lower-level offenses, potentially reducing the burden on the traditional court system and offering more appropriate resolutions for these cases.

The expansion of therapeutic treatment courts is also aligned with the bill's goal of promoting rehabilitation and reducing recidivism rates. By providing individuals with access to treatment and support, the bill aims to address the underlying issues that may have contributed to their involvement in the criminal justice system. This approach has the potential to foster long-term positive change and reduce the likelihood of reoffending, ultimately contributing to safer communities and a more effective justice system.

Furthermore, the bill includes provisions to boost training and education programs for inmates, as well as measures to ease the process of obtaining professional licenses for those with criminal records. These steps are intended to enhance the employability of formerly incarcerated individuals, reducing barriers to their successful reintegration into society. By addressing the challenges faced by individuals with criminal records in obtaining employment, the bill promotes personal growth and contributes to a more inclusive and productive community.

Cutting mandatory driver's license suspensions

House Bill 7125, which was passed in the Florida House Judiciary Committee on April 9, 2019, includes a variety of measures aimed at reforming the state's criminal justice system. One of the key provisions of the bill is the reduction of mandatory driver's license suspensions.

Currently, in Florida, there are numerous infractions, many of which are unrelated to driving offenses, that can result in a driver's license suspension. This means that a person may lose their driving privileges for reasons that have nothing to do with their driving abilities or safety record. This can have significant negative impacts on an individual's life, limiting their ability to commute to work, school, or other important activities.

The bill aims to address this issue by cutting down on the number of infractions that can lead to a mandatory suspension. While the specific details of the changes are not yet clear, the overall goal is to reduce the instances of unnecessary and burdensome license suspensions. This will help ease the process of reinstating driving privileges for those who have had their licenses suspended for non-driving-related offenses.

Additionally, the bill includes a provision requiring clerks of court to hold at least one annual event aimed at assisting individuals with suspended licenses in getting their driving privileges back. This will provide a structured pathway for people to regain their driving privileges and move forward with their lives.

By cutting mandatory driver's license suspensions, House Bill 7125 takes a significant step towards a more fair and just approach to licensing regulations in Florida. This change will help alleviate the difficulties faced by those with suspended licenses and provide them with greater opportunities for rehabilitation and reintegration into society.

Making significant occupational licensing reforms

House Bill 7125, which was passed in the Florida House Judiciary Committee in April 2019, includes significant reforms to occupational licensing. The bill makes it easier for people with criminal records to obtain professional licenses under the jurisdiction of the Department of Business and Professional Regulation.

The bill's supporters argue that it will help reduce barriers to employment for those with felony convictions, allowing them to successfully re-enter society and rebuild their lives. This aspect of the bill is particularly aimed at helping those who have already paid their debt to society and completed their sentences.

The bill also addresses the needs of crime victims and improves the rule of law by eliminating arbitrary juvenile mandatory direct file requirements. It aims to achieve proportionality in sentencing and ensure that punishment fits the crime.

In addition to these licensing reforms, the bill includes a range of other criminal justice reforms, such as raising the felony threshold for grand theft, expanding access to therapeutic treatment courts, and reducing mandatory driver's license suspensions.

Frequently asked questions