Jesus And The Law: Did He Break Rules?

Jesus of Nazareth is a central figure in the Christian faith, seen as the epitome of purity and goodness. However, the question of whether Jesus broke the law has been a source of debate. While Jesus did not break any civil laws, he was accused of breaking religious laws, specifically the laws concerning the Sabbath. The Pharisees and other religious leaders of his time took issue with Jesus's interpretation of the laws of the Old Testament, which they saw as a violation. Jesus challenged the religious authorities by prioritising love and compassion over strict adherence to rules. He denounced the religious rulers for their burdening of the people with rules and traditions, arguing that they neglected more important matters such as justice, mercy, and faithfulness. Jesus's commitment to non-violence, forgiveness, and compassion often put him at odds with the religious leaders of his time. Ultimately, Jesus's interpretation of the law and his willingness to break religious rules to show that people mattered more than rules led to his condemnation and death.

Jesus broke religious laws, not Roman civil laws

Jesus is often depicted as being on the wrong side of the religious leaders of his time, with the Pharisees and scribes accusing him of breaking the law. However, Jesus did not break Roman civil laws, but rather the religious laws of the Jews.

Jesus challenged the Jewish religious leaders' interpretation of the laws of the Old Testament, which they took as a violation of the law. The Pharisees and scribes took the law at face value, whereas Jesus had a deeper and more nuanced understanding of the law. For instance, Jesus was accused of breaking the Sabbath law on several occasions. However, he did not break the Sabbath as outlined by God under the Old Covenant. Jesus did not abolish the Law or the Prophets but came to fulfil them.

Jesus' response to the accusations of breaking the Sabbath law was that he was working just as his Father was working. This angered the religious leaders, as they believed that Jesus was equating himself with God. Jesus also referred to himself as the Lord of the Sabbath, proclaiming that he is greater than the law and has authority over the Sabbath day.

In addition to breaking the Sabbath law, Jesus was also accused of breaking other religious laws, such as touching a leper, eating with "sinners", and overturning the money tables at the temple. However, Jesus always proved that he was not breaking any laws and was sinless.

Jesus broke religious laws to demonstrate that love and compassion are more important than following rules blindly. He set himself against the religious rulers to teach and demonstrate a better way, showing that people mattered more than rules.

Jesus challenged the Pharisees' interpretation of the Sabbath

Jesus and his disciples were once walking through a field of grain on the Sabbath when they became hungry. As they began to pluck and eat the grain, the Pharisees accused them of breaking the Sabbath. The Pharisees' oral tradition held that plucking grain was a form of reaping, and therefore work, which was forbidden on the Sabbath. However, Jesus argued that the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath, and that satisfying a person's hunger was more important than strict adherence to religious rules.

In another instance, Jesus entered a synagogue on the Sabbath, where there was a man with a withered hand. The Pharisees asked him, "Is it lawful to heal on the Sabbath?", intending to accuse him of breaking the Sabbath. Jesus responded by asking if they would not help a sheep that had fallen into a pit on the Sabbath. He argued that if they would relieve the suffering of a sheep, how much more should they relieve the suffering of a fellow human being, who is more valuable? Jesus then healed the man's hand.

Jesus' actions and teachings challenged the Pharisees' interpretation of the Sabbath by prioritising mercy, compassion, and love over strict adherence to religious rules and traditions. He argued that the Sabbath was made for the benefit of man and that it was lawful to do good and relieve suffering on the Sabbath.

Jesus broke the Jewish law by touching a leper

Jesus is often depicted as a figure who broke Jewish laws, but not the civil laws of Rome. In the Gospels, he is accused by Jewish religious leaders and biblical scholars of being a lawbreaker and a sinner. However, Jesus himself would have disagreed with the notion that he broke any biblical laws. Instead, he is seen as breaking the "traditions of men" that had been layered on top of the Torah.

Jesus broke Jewish law by touching a leper. According to Leviticus 5:3, "If he touches human uncleanness, of whatever sort his uncleanness may be with which he becomes unclean, and it is hidden from him, and then he comes to know it, he will be guilty." Jesus, being God, was not at risk of being infected with leprosy, but he did break the letter of the law. Jesus touched the leper so that the cure could be spread. He replaced the ceremonial law.

Jesus was aware that the man's needs were emotional as well as physical. The man mattered more than the rules, and Jesus needed to touch him to demonstrate this. Jesus did not disobey the rules to be rebellious but to show that love transcends rules.

Jesus also broke Jewish law by healing on the Sabbath. The Jewish leaders saw a man who had been paralysed for 38 years and said to him, "It is the Sabbath; the law forbids you to carry your mat." Jesus responded by prioritising the needs of the man over the observance of the law. He argued that God is always working, and that he, too, was working by healing the man.

Jesus broke Jewish laws to demonstrate that people mattered more than rules. He showed that love transcends rules and that the purpose of the law is to lead people to love.

Jesus broke the Oral Torah by healing on the Sabbath

Jesus broke the Oral Torah, or the Pharisees' interpretation of the law, by healing on the Sabbath. The Sabbath was a day of rest, and no work was to be done. The Oral Torah, or the Mishnah, defined how the Sabbath was to be observed and specifically forbade carrying things.

Jesus, however, prioritised healing over the strict observation of the Sabbath. He healed a paralysed man, telling him to "Get up! Pick up your mat and walk" (John 5:8). The Jewish leaders were outraged, saying, "It is the Sabbath; the law forbids you to carry your mat" (John 5:10). Jesus provoked the Jewish leaders by healing on the Sabbath and even went out of his way to do so, as he "could have easily waited one day to heal the man".

Jesus defended his actions, saying, "My Father is always at his work to this very day, and I too am working" (John 5:17). This outraged the religious leaders even further, as Jesus was equating himself with God.

Jesus broke the Oral Torah, or the Pharisees' interpretation of the Sabbath, by carrying out healings on that day. He did this to provoke the Jewish leaders and to show that people's needs were more important than strict adherence to the law.

Jesus broke the law by overturning the money tables at the temple

Jesus's actions can be interpreted as a reaction to the practice of money changers routinely cheating people. By overturning the tables, Jesus symbolically disrupted the economic systems that had perverted the worship of God. This act also demonstrated his authority and his desire to protect the vulnerable.

However, some scholars question the historicity of the incident, given the vastness of the temple complex and the likelihood that thousands of pilgrims would have been present during the great festivals such as Passover.

It is worth noting that Jesus's anger was directed at both the sellers and buyers in the temple, indicating that the issue was not just the cheating practices but also the location of the commercial activities. Jesus wanted to preserve the sanctity of the temple as a place of worship, not a marketplace.

Overall, Jesus's overturning of the money tables at the temple can be seen as a symbolic act of righteous anger against the exploitation of the poor and the corruption of religious practices.

Frequently asked questions