Katey Hill: A Legal Analysis Of Her Actions

Former US Representative Katie Hill was accused of having an affair with a male congressional staffer, which would have been a violation of House rules. However, she denied the accusation and, while admitting to a relationship with a female campaign staffer, maintained that it occurred before she became a Member of Congress. In 2019, nude photos of Hill were published without her consent by the British tabloid Daily Mail and the right-wing political blog RedState. Hill blamed her ex-husband for the leak and vowed to fight revenge porn and cyber exploitation. While Hill's actions sparked an investigation and led to her resignation from Congress, it is unclear if she broke any laws.

Katie Hill's revenge porn lawsuit

In December 2020, Katie Hill filed a lawsuit against her ex-husband, the Daily Mail, and RedState over "nonconsensual porn". The lawsuit came after intimate photos of Hill were leaked to the media in October 2019, which she blamed on her ex-husband.

The photos were published by the Daily Mail and RedState, accompanied by allegations of an affair between Hill and her legislative director, which she denied. Hill admitted to a previous inappropriate relationship with a 22-year-old female campaign staffer.

In April 2021, a judge ruled in favour of the Daily Mail, citing the First Amendment and "public interest" as reasons for the ruling. The judge also ordered Hill to pay $220,000 in legal fees to the media companies. Hill's attorneys planned to appeal the decision.

In July 2022, Hill declared bankruptcy, which would allow her to avoid paying the defendants' attorney fees.

The case received national scrutiny as it pitted California's "revenge porn" law against the First Amendment. While California was an early adopter of revenge porn laws in 2013, the state's laws are relatively weak compared to other states.

In an op-ed for Vanity Fair in April 2021, Hill called for revenge porn to become a federal crime, stating that "victims of cyber exploitation are being let down by our legal system".

Did Katie Hill break any laws?

In October 2019, Katie Hill, a former member of the US House of Representatives, was accused of having an affair with a male congressional staffer, Graham Kelly. She denied the accusation, but admitted to a relationship with a female campaign staffer, Morgan Desjardins, while married to her now-estranged husband, Kenny Heslep.

Intimate photos of Hill were published by the British tabloid newspaper, the Daily Mail, and the right-wing political blog, RedState. The photos were allegedly leaked by Heslep, who later claimed he was hacked. Hill called the publication of the photos an invasion of privacy and an example of "revenge porn".

In California, where Hill resided, it is a crime to "post sexually explicit pictures or video online of another person without his or her permission with the intention of causing emotional distress or publicly humiliating the subject". This is known as the "Revenge Porn" bill, or SB 255, which was signed into law by Governor Jerry Brown in 2013.

It is unclear whether Hill pursued legal action against Heslep, the Daily Mail, or RedState under this law. However, in 2021, a judge ordered Hill to pay $220,000 in legal fees to the Daily Mail and other media outlets for defending themselves against her accusations. Hill's attorneys planned to appeal the decision. In July 2022, Hill declared bankruptcy to avoid paying the defendants' attorney fees.

Katie Hill's resignation

On October 27, 2019, Katie Hill, a Democratic congresswoman from California, announced her resignation from Congress. Hill, who was considered a rising star within the Democratic Party, had been embroiled in a scandal involving allegations of improper relationships with her staffers and possible misuse of her position to grant favours.

The controversy began earlier that month when the conservative website RedState published allegations of Hill being in a polyamorous relationship with her husband and a female campaign staffer, as well as having an affair with her male legislative director. While Hill denied the affair with her legislative director, she acknowledged the relationship with the female staffer, Morgan Desjardins, which occurred before she became a Member of Congress.

Intimate photographs of Hill and Desjardins, as well as nude photos of Hill, were published by RedState and the British tabloid the Daily Mail, sparking an uproar and leading to an investigation by the House Ethics Committee into potential violations of House ethics rules. Hill faced intense scrutiny and criticism, with members of her own party, including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, indicating their lack of support for her.

In her resignation statement, Hill decried the invasion of her privacy, blaming her ex-husband and "hateful political operatives" for a "smear campaign" of "cyber exploitation." She also vowed to use her post-congressional career to fight "revenge porn" and advocate for victims of similar violations.

The speed and circumstances of Hill's resignation sparked debates about slut-shaming, homophobia, and the complex dynamics of power and consent in sexual relationships involving public figures. Hill's case highlighted the challenges of balancing an individual's right to privacy and the public's right to know, especially in an era of digital media and increasing scrutiny of public officials' personal lives.

Following her resignation, Hill continued to face legal and financial repercussions, including a lawsuit filed against her by her ex-husband and the media outlets involved in the scandal. In June 2021, she was ordered to pay significant legal fees to the Daily Mail and other media organisations.

Katie Hill's inappropriate relationships

On October 18, 2019, the conservative blog RedState published allegations that Katie Hill, a Democratic member of the U.S. House of Representatives for California's 25th congressional district, was involved in an extramarital affair with her legislative director, a young male staffer. Hill denied these allegations, stating that her estranged husband was abusive and was doing everything he could to humiliate her, and that her political opponents were exploiting a private matter for political gain.

Five days later, on October 23, Hill admitted in an email to constituents that she had had an inappropriate relationship with a 22-year-old female campaign staffer before becoming a member of Congress. She also confirmed that she had been in a consensual three-way relationship with the same female campaign staffer and her estranged husband, Kenny Heslep.

The House Ethics Committee announced on the same day that it would investigate the allegation that Hill had an affair with her staffer, which would be in violation of House ethics reforms implemented in 2018 in response to the #MeToo movement. Hill vowed to cooperate with the investigation.

On October 27, 2019, Hill announced her resignation from Congress, stating that it was "the hardest thing I have ever had to do, but I believe it is the best thing for my constituents and our country."

In her final speech before Congress on October 31, 2019, Hill decried a "double standard" and "misogynistic culture", stating that:

> "I'm leaving, but we have men who have been credibly accused of intentional acts of sexual violence and remain in boardrooms, on the Supreme Court, in this very body, and worst of all, in the Oval Office... As my final act I voted to move forward with the impeachment of Donald Trump on behalf of the women of the United States of America."

In December 2020, Hill was awarded a restraining order against her ex-husband, who she accused of choking and threatening her during years of abuse and of leaking nude photos and other information that led to her resignation.

Katie Hill's leaked photos

In October 2019, nude photos of former U.S. Representative Katie Hill were published by the British tabloid the Daily Mail. The photos were allegedly leaked by Hill's ex-husband, Kenny Heslep, who claimed that his email had been hacked.

The images showed Hill posing naked while smoking a bong and kissing her female aide, Morgan Desjardins. In one of the photos, a tattoo of what appeared to be a Nazi-era Iron Cross was visible on Hill's bikini line. The tattoo led to accusations of hypocrisy, as Hill had previously criticised racist Facebook posts that included a similar-looking cross.

In addition to the Daily Mail, the conservative blog RedState also published the nude photos of Hill. Jennifer Van Laar, deputy managing editor at RedState and a writer for the Daily Mail, posted the allegations and photos without disclosing her work with Republican opponents of Hill. Van Laar was also a longtime conservative consultant who worked for Republican politicians that ran against Hill.

Following the publication of the photos, Hill resigned from Congress and vowed to combat revenge porn. She filed a lawsuit against her ex-husband, the Daily Mail, and RedState over "nonconsensual porn". However, a judge ruled in favour of the media outlets, finding that the photos were protected under the First Amendment. Hill was ordered to pay approximately $220,000 in legal fees to the Daily Mail and two journalists.

Frequently asked questions