Tennessee's Abortion Bill: Law Or Political Stunt?

Abortion in Tennessee is illegal from the point of fertilization, except in a few rare cases. The state's abortion ban, considered one of the strictest in the US, came into effect on August 25, 2022, thirty days after the overturning of Roe v. Wade. The ban, known as the 'Heartbeat Bill', prohibits abortions after a heartbeat is detected, which is usually around 6 weeks into a pregnancy. However, in October 2024, a Tennessee court blocked the enforcement of the abortion ban in certain emergencies, ruling that the medical emergency exception was unclear and violated a pregnant individual's right to life. This has created some confusion around the legality of abortion in the state.

Tennessee's abortion ban

The abortion ban in Tennessee includes an "affirmative defense" for doctors, which means that the onus is on the physician to prove that an abortion was medically necessary, rather than requiring the state to demonstrate the opposite. This has raised concerns among medical professionals, reproductive rights activists, and Democratic lawmakers, who argue that the law does not adequately protect doctors and pregnant patients.

In response to these concerns, Republican Governor Bill Lee signed a bill into law in October 2024, creating a narrow exemption to the abortion ban. This exemption allows doctors to use their "reasonable medical judgment" to determine if an abortion is necessary to prevent the death of a pregnant patient or irreversible severe impairment of a major bodily function. It also permits abortion services for ectopic pregnancies and miscarriages but does not include an exception for cases of rape or incest.

The original bill proposed by supporters of abortion rights included broader exemptions, such as allowing abortions for "medically futile pregnancies" and lethal fetal anomalies. However, these provisions were removed after pressure from the influential anti-abortion lobby group Tennessee Right to Life, which warned lawmakers of potential political retribution if they advanced the bill without the group's endorsement.

While the recent exemption provides some clarity and protection for doctors and pregnant patients, it is still criticized by some as insufficient. The Tennessee Medical Association, a nonprofit health advocacy group, expressed disappointment that the bill did not exempt fatal fetal anomalies from the criminal statute and felt that the legal standard for doctors fell short of providing adequate protection.

Tennessee's Heartbeat Bill

Tennessee's abortion ban, known as one of the strictest in the United States, includes an extremely narrow exemption under legislation signed into law by Republican Gov. Bill Lee. The law, known as the "Heartbeat Bill", was passed in 2020 and bans abortions after a heartbeat can be detected, which usually occurs at around six weeks of gestation. This is often before many people realize they are pregnant.

The "Heartbeat Bill" makes it a felony for health providers to perform abortions after six weeks. It includes an affirmative defence for medical emergencies, allowing abortions to be performed prior to six weeks if they are life-saving. However, it does not exempt cases of rape or incest.

The bill was applauded by Governor Lee, who called it "the strongest pro-life law in our state's history." However, it has been criticised by reproductive rights activists and health care officials who argue that it does not go far enough to protect doctors and pregnant patients.

The American Civil Liberties Union, the Center for Reproductive Rights, and women's health provider Planned Parenthood filed a joint lawsuit in federal court challenging the bill. They argue that the bill is "unacceptable" and that "politicians should not be deciding what is best for women and certainly not making reproductive health care decisions for them."

Tennessee's "Heartbeat Bill" is part of a wave of similar strict anti-abortion measures passed by Republican-majority legislatures in an effort to prompt the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade, the landmark 1973 case that guarantees a woman's constitutional right to abortion. In 2022, the federal 6th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated a lower court's injunction blocking the law, allowing the "Heartbeat Bill" to take effect.

Tennessee's Trigger Law

Tennessee's abortion ban, regarded as one of the strictest in the United States, came into effect in 2022. The state's so-called "trigger law" was allowed to go into effect after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the constitutional right to abortion. The law not only banned all abortions but also included an "affirmative defence" for doctors, meaning that the onus was on the physician to prove that an abortion was medically necessary.

The Tennessee Human Life Protection Act, passed in 2019, makes it a Class C Felony for someone to provide abortion services. The law does not, however, punish women who try to get abortion treatments. Doctors can face felony charges under the law, and it places the burden on them to prove that an abortion was necessary to save the life of the pregnant woman or to prevent irreversible impairment of a major bodily function.

The law does not prohibit people from leaving Tennessee to get an abortion. However, if they are prescribed an abortion pill by an out-of-state doctor and that pill is filled by a pharmacist in Tennessee, the pharmacist could be prosecuted. There are no exceptions to the state law, including in cases of rape, incest, or trafficking.

The original bill would have allowed doctors to provide abortion services for "medically futile pregnancies" and lethal fetal anomalies. It would have also allowed doctors to provide abortions based on their "good-faith judgement", which experts say allows more flexibility than the harsher standard of "reasonable medical judgement". However, these provisions were removed after pressure from the state's powerful anti-abortion lobby, Tennessee Right to Life.

The state's "Heartbeat Bill", passed in 2020, bans abortions after a heartbeat can be detected, which usually occurs at around six weeks of gestation. This is often before many people realize they are pregnant. The law includes an affirmative defence for medical emergencies.

Tennessee's Human Life Protection Act

The Human Life Protection Act supersedes Tennessee's Heartbeat Bill, which was passed in 2020 and prohibited abortions after the detection of a fetal heartbeat, which is typically around six weeks of gestation. The Heartbeat Bill included an affirmative defense for medical emergencies.

The Human Life Protection Act is a trigger law, which means it was designed to go into effect after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. This law, along with Tennessee's abortion ban, is considered one of the strictest in the United States. There are no exceptions made for cases of rape, incest, or trafficking, which some other states allow.

While the law does not penalize individuals who leave the state to obtain an abortion, it does prohibit the prescription and dispensation of abortion pills by Tennessee-based doctors and pharmacists, respectively. The law also does not criminalize the removal of a fetus after a miscarriage or surgical treatment to remove fetal tissue from the uterus, as the fetus is already dead in these cases.

The implementation of the Human Life Protection Act has been a subject of discussion and debate among lawmakers, medical professionals, and reproductive rights activists. While some argue that the law successfully protects mothers and children, others believe that it falls short of providing adequate exemptions and legal protections for doctors and pregnant patients.

Tennessee's abortion rights protests

On 24 June 2022, over a thousand women marched through downtown Nashville to protest the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, paving the way for Tennessee's abortion "trigger ban" to take effect. Abortion-rights advocates gathered at the Legislative Plaza to discuss the implications of the decision for thousands of women in Tennessee who may soon be unable to get abortions.

Protesters expressed their anger and disappointment at the Supreme Court's decision, with one protester, Kelsie Hankins Hughes, stating, "It's an emotional day. We knew this was coming, but it still stings." Another protester, Hughes' husband, Mike Hughes, emphasised the importance of speaking out, saying, "It's easy to be silent, but change doesn't happen by being silent when 50 years of rights were revoked."

The protest included young women who felt they had woken up with fewer rights than their parents had at the same age. Two teenage sisters, one dressed in a "Handmaid's Tale" costume, shared their concerns about living in a small town and facing harassment for their pro-abortion views among conservative peers. They chose to remain anonymous due to these concerns. The sisters discussed the lack of separation between church and state in Tennessee and how the Supreme Court's decision disregarded freedom of religion.

Several speakers addressed the crowd, including candidates for political office, who urged people to register to vote and bring about change through the democratic process. Cecilia Prado, Worker's Dignity Director, called the Supreme Court's rulings a move towards fascism and encouraged the crowd to advocate for real change through unions, opposing capitalism, and demanding true democracy.

The protest in Nashville was one of many demonstrations across the country following the Supreme Court's decision, with people demanding access to safe, legal abortion in Tennessee and beyond.

Frequently asked questions