Trump's Legal Troubles: Did He Break The Law?

Former US President Donald Trump has been involved in a number of legal cases, including criminal and civil suits, which have raised questions about the extent of presidential immunity and the rule of law in the country. Trump has faced allegations of sexual assault, defamation, mishandling classified documents, and attempting to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election. The outcome of these cases has had significant implications for Trump's political career and the US legal system.

Did Trump break the law by mishandling classified documents?

In August 2022, the FBI searched former US President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago residence, seizing over 13,000 government documents, including 300 classified documents. This led to a federal criminal case against Trump, his personal aide Walt Nauta, and Mar-a-Lago maintenance chief Carlos De Oliveira. The case marks the first federal indictment of a former US president.

Trump was charged with 40 felony counts, including 32 counts under the Espionage Act for willfully retaining national defence information. The remaining eight charges included making false statements and engaging in a conspiracy to obstruct justice. Trump pleaded not guilty to all charges.

The case was dismissed by a Florida judge in July 2024, who ruled that the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith, who was overseeing the prosecution, was unconstitutional. Smith appealed the decision, but following Trump's reelection in November 2024, he announced he would seek to dismiss the appeal against Trump, while retaining it for Nauta and De Oliveira.

The conclusion of the case was expected due to the long-standing Justice Department policy that a sitting president cannot be prosecuted.

While Trump avoided prosecution in this case, he still faces three other criminal cases: one related to hush money payments, another concerning election interference in Georgia, and a third regarding his efforts to overturn the 2020 election results.

Did Trump break the law by trying to overturn the 2020 election result?

After Joe Biden won the 2020 US presidential election, Donald Trump, the then-incumbent president, made an unprecedented attempt to overturn the election result. Trump and his allies used the "big lie" propaganda technique to promote false claims that the election was stolen from him through rigged voting machines, electoral fraud, and an international conspiracy.

Trump pressured the Department of Justice leaders to challenge the results and publicly declare the election corrupt. However, these claims were dismissed by the attorney general, director of National Intelligence, and director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, as well as some Trump campaign staff, state and federal judges, election officials, and state governors.

Trump's efforts to overturn the election results included targeting state legislatures to change the results or delay electoral vote certification at the Capitol, promoting the idea that Vice President Mike Pence could refuse to certify the results, and filing 63 unsuccessful lawsuits, including Texas v. Pennsylvania, which was declined by the Supreme Court.

Trump's actions have resulted in various legal consequences and investigations. In June 2022, the House Select Committee on the January 6 Attack stated that it had enough evidence to recommend that the Department of Justice indict Trump, and on August 1, 2023, a grand jury indicted him on four charges, to which he pleaded not guilty.

Legal experts have weighed in on whether Trump broke the law by trying to overturn the 2020 election results. Some argue that Trump may have violated federal and state laws against election tampering and soliciting election fraud. They claim that Trump's phone call with Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, in which he asked him to "find" enough votes to overturn his loss, amounted to using threats to push Raffensperger to alter a legitimate vote count.

However, others question whether Trump actually requested that Raffensperger fabricate votes or was merely offering his opinion on the election results. Trump has denied any wrongdoing and claimed that he genuinely believed the election was rigged against him.

While Trump's actions may have violated the law, the chances of him being prosecuted are slim, especially considering the logistical, security, and political questions surrounding the jailing of a former president.

Did Trump break the law by inciting or aiding an insurrection?

On January 6, 2021, supporters of former President Donald Trump stormed the US Capitol building in Washington, DC, in a riot that left five people dead and 140 police officers injured. A House committee investigating the attack has urged the Justice Department to consider prosecuting Trump for four different crimes, including inciting or aiding an insurrection.

The committee's referrals to the Justice Department carry no legal weight, and federal prosecutors are conducting their own investigation. However, the committee said it regarded its report as providing a "roadmap to justice". The focus now shifts to the Justice Department and whether it will concur that the evidence is sufficient for prosecution.

The committee said it amassed substantial evidence that Trump sought to obstruct the process of certifying Joe Biden as the winner of the 2020 election, including by summoning supporters to Washington on the day Congress was meeting and pressuring Vice President Mike Pence to prevent the votes from being certified. The committee also noted that Trump showed no concern when rioters chanted "Hang Mike Pence!" and resisted the pleas of advisers who told him to tell the rioters to disperse.

Trump was impeached by the House on a charge of incitement after the attack on the Capitol but was later acquitted by the Senate. Some legal experts have questioned whether the Justice Department could successfully prosecute Trump for inciting the insurrection based on a speech he gave before the riot, in which he encouraged the crowd to "fight like hell" but also told them to proceed peacefully to the Capitol.

Trump has denied any wrongdoing and claimed that the Biden administration is behind the prosecution. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Did Trump break the law by conspiring to defraud the US?

The House Jan. 6 committee has urged the Justice Department to consider prosecuting Donald Trump for four different crimes, including conspiracy to defraud the United States. This is a general statute that makes it a crime to work with someone else to carry out fraud against the U.S.

The committee says Trump did exactly that by trying to obstruct the certification of the 2020 election despite being told by aides that there was no fraud that could have affected the outcome. He also angrily beseeched then-Vice President Mike Pence to delay that certification even though he was told there was no legal basis for him to do so, and worked with others, both inside and outside the government, on a "multi-part plan" to stay in power.

The panel also recommended lawyer John Eastman for prosecution on the same count, noting that a federal judge in California had already concluded in a separate lawsuit that evidence of a criminal conspiracy likely existed. The committee says other Trump associates engaged in the same conspiracy, though it did not attempt to identify all of them since many refused to cooperate with the panel.

Trump has denied any wrongdoing and claimed the Biden administration is behind the prosecution. He previously pled not guilty to all charges.

Did Trump break the law by committing sexual assault?

At least 26 women have accused Donald Trump of rape, kissing, and groping without consent, as well as other forms of sexual misconduct. Trump has denied all allegations.

In 2016, a recording from 2005 surfaced in which Trump was heard saying that "when you're a star, they let you do it. You can do anything... Grab 'em by the pussy." The recording's release led to widespread outrage and caused Trump to issue his first public apology during his presidential campaign.

In May 2023, a New York jury found Trump liable for sexually abusing and defaming writer E. Jean Carroll, who had accused him of rape, sexual assault, or sexual harassment. The jury awarded Carroll $5 million in damages. However, it is important to note that this was a civil trial, and Trump was not found guilty of rape or any other criminal charges.

In addition to Carroll, numerous other women have come forward with allegations of sexual misconduct against Trump. These include Jessica Leeds, Ivana Trump, Kristin Anderson, Stacey Williams, Jill Harth, Lisa Boyne, Cathy Heller, Temple Taggart McDowell, Karena Virginia, Karen Johnson, Mindy McGillivray, Rachel Crooks, Natasha Stoynoff, Juliet Huddy, Jessica Drake, Ninni Laaksonen, Cassandra Searles, and several former Miss USA and Miss Teen USA contestants. The accusations span several decades, with some dating back to the 1970s.

While Trump has denied all allegations and has not been convicted of any sexual assault charges, the numerous accusations have raised concerns and led to legal proceedings in some cases.

Frequently asked questions